This morning, it dawned on me that I didn't know mush about the Janka scale, so did a Google search, which turned up a nice chart showing the hardest at the top, then decending order from there. While the list was not very long, nor containing many of my local species, it had some surprises. Osage being less than half the top species for example.
Down to the question, does anyone know of other list for other properties like this? While I have The Encyclopedia of Wood, which has all the woods alphebetacly, with each of the properties, listed under both hard and soft, it would sure be nice if I could find a list of woods with the best tensil perpendicular to the grain, for a project I'm thinking about.
The Janka scale was on Wickipedia if anyone is interested. I'm out using my iphone, and can't figure out how to copy the link, if someone wants to help.
On the right side of the page, under Wood Properties (Techsheets), there are four links to four sections, on Lesser Known Woods, North American Hardwoods, North American Softwoods, and Tropical Hardwoods. In those sections you should be able to find a page, with myriad physical properties, on just about any species you can find for sale at a sawmill.
I forget which is which, but as far as I can remember, for tensile perpendicular and parallel to the grain, your best choices are American hornbeam, Carpinus caroliniana and hophornbeam, Ostrya virginiana. Hence, make your carver's mallet from hophornbeam and you joiner's mallet and chisel handles from hophornbeaam (or vice versa?). The colder the climate where they have grown, the better. Note that there is a lot of data to digest, and it has been many years since I looked it up, so you will want to redo the analysis for yourself.
I make splitting wedges from dogwood to be used for freeing steel wedges form recalcitrant blocks of wood. . Loom shuttles were traditionally made from dogwood. I pound on these wedges with a 10 pound sledge hammer and they last for several years.
I made chisel handles from dogwood and I have pounded on them with a 3 pound hammer to seat them with no ill effects.
That link has a lot of good information, but is too cumbersome for what I was hoping for. Instead of having an Alphabetical list, with links, I was hoping for a list in descending order of any given property that I should choose. This one is slower than looking in my books, which at least has it all on the same page. On this link, if I have looked at a few, after a while if I've forgotten the actual number of one view 4 or 5 pages back, I have to go back.
This would be a lot quicker to use, and doesn't seem like it would be that hard for someone with number crunching skills and spreadsheet, to just put the info in the computer give you the option of properties parallel or perpendicular to the grain, or whatever.
William, you seem to have an appetite for obscure tough woods, and I couldn't help noticing one of the toughest around here that I've never seen on the list anywhere. That would be Highbush Huckleberry, while I was freshening my property lines, I needed to whack a few with my machete, and I'm here to tell you that it is tough.
Not that I would go out and cut them just to have in my inventory, due to their migratory bird food source. Down here, they are ripe in the Fall. I need to get back out where the loggers cleaned up the storm blowdown. Those guys on the big harvesters and skidders don't pay any attention to plants like this. I know I saw some about 4" diameter that got run over that I should go harvest before the insects destroy them.
Using limbs for the legs and stretcher. I'm already familiar with most of the woods in my area, but I still like to study the numbers for comparison. Down at the cabins where I go most weekends, there is an abundance of American Hornbeam, which I'll probably use, since it fits my requirements. I like the muscular look, and thin bark, but the insects really get to it quickly down there. However, I think I'll really soak them with CEPS, which should provide enough of a barrier.
Also, I'll drill out the piths, and dry them in the hot-box to see if I can get the wood through the critical stage.
You'd think, with the wisdom and resources of the USDA, that they could provide this information in a format that was more easily processed by their customers.
Even 3 decade old technology, in the form of an .xls file, or 5 decade old technology, in the form of a mainframe database with an SQL front end would be more useful to a wider range of users than what they provide.
I'm going to have to look into the highbush huckleberry. The last time I encountered any of them in the wild was about 30 years ago, up on the Blue Ridge Parkway in NC. I knew there was something important to investigate when I noticed there were 30 or 40 cars parked alongside the road, and a bunch of people with buckets running off onto a bald. My only current acquaintance is with the blueberries that they cultivate commercially in the NJ Pine Barrens. I fill my freezer at about a buck a pint from Stony Creek in Hammonton (the Blueberry Capital of the World). They never get big enough to use as a source of lumber. The deer eat almost all of the ones my next door neighbor and I grow.
Bill's dogwood recommendation is also a good one. Over the last few years, we've lost most of the Cornus florida trees that grow in our woods, due to Anthracnose fungus attack. But, like the huckleberry and hornbeam, they are not rot resistant.
Since I have a little on hand, left over from a restoration project a while back, I'm finding more and more things to use it on, and liking the results.