Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Lost a friend today....

Posts

Lost a friend today....

#1

Lost a friend today....

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

....R.I.P. to my Dewalt 5" random orbit sander. It finally died today. This time for good. With the Festool sanders I have, you would think that a cheap Dewalt sander would be a stepchild in my shop. Oddly enough, it was my go-to sander.

All efforts to resuscitate it have failed. I knew it was on borrowed time. It served me well. I will give it a proper burial....followed by a ceremonial trip to the big box to find its successor.

Good bye old friend.

Re: Lost a friend today....

#2

Re: Lost a friend today....

William Duffield

I'm curious. Which Festool sanders do you have? I have an RO90 and an RO 150 and have never felt the need to return to my old random orbital sanders (5" P-Cs and Makitas), which have had annoying belt and bearing failures, but never croaked completely. I also have a Fein Multimaster, but I didn't buy it for its sanding capability, Since I have the RO 90.

Re: Lost a friend today....

#3

Re: Lost a friend today....

Stephen Kirk

Condolences on your loss. I too have an aging Dewalt sander which I fear will not be with us for too much longer. They are great little tools that do their job without complaint and with decent dust collection.

Re: Lost a friend today....

#4

Re: Lost a friend today....

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I have a 125 and a 150. They work fine. My preference was quirky!

Re: Lost a friend today....

#5

Re: Lost a friend today....

William Duffield

No, not particularly quirky. Before I bought the RO 150, I also tried out the RO 125 and the ETS 125, and didn't particularly like either one of them, because I had trouble controlling them. It may be that they just needed breaking in, or I needed to fiddle with the speed and suction to tune them to what I was sanding and the abrasive I was using.

Re: Lost a friend today....

#6

Re: Lost a friend today....

John in NM

While I'm sorry for your loss, I'm a little surprised by your sense of discernment :D The best I've managed to achieve with any hand sander is an uneasy truce!

I've never yet bought a Festool sander because I'm secretly afraid that I won't be as enamored with those as with their saws!

Re: Lost a friend today....

#7

Re: Lost a friend today....

Jesse Cloud

Hey John,

Next time you're in town, come on out to the shop and spend some quality time with a few Festool sanders. You might be surprised!

A couple of not well known aspects are that with good dust collection, you keep the dust off which 1)lets you sand raw wood instead of dust and 2)gets rid of any leftover lower grit quicker - both of which saves time and sandpaper.

Re: Lost a friend today....

#8

I'll take you up on that!

John in NM

I should have thought of that when I came out for the wood. I'll make sure to bring Jean along too - she almost sands more than I do, and absolutely loves the ATS.

You know, I've been going to great lengths for years to get a vacuum onto RO sanders - it makes such a huge difference in speed and abrasive life.

Lately I've been using the square sander more than anything, after 20 minutes I feel like I'm vibrating too! :D

Re: Lost a friend today....

#9

Buy an air driven sander

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

For the price of what you have in sanders you could have bought a compressor big enough to run it and one of the air driven ROS sanders. After using one it will be clear why they are the sander of choice in any shop that can afford the air supply to run them. My 5" ROS Dynabrade weighs 1.5 pounds and with a flexible hose it feels about like hand sanding with a block, except it is 100 times faster.

Re: Lost a friend today....

#10

Re: Buy an air driven sander

Dick Coers

Having a compressor hammering away has always been an annoyance to me. When I ran my small business, 2 guys could keep an 80 gallon, 2 stage, running pretty heavily when both were sanding. I always loved the sound of silence when we moved to assembly. I bought the Cerros so I wouldn't have that in the basement. Love that sander!

Re: Lost a friend today....

#11

Better yet, best of both worlds *LINK*

Bob Lang

The Mirka Ceros is essentially an electric powered pneumatic sander. Pricey but worth it, especially with the Abranet abrasives. All the advantages of the air sanders (light weight, low vibration, great dust collection) without the compressor running.

Bob Lang


Mirka Website

Re: Lost a friend today....

#12

Re: Better yet, best of both worlds

William Duffield

Even on the Festool forums, there are pros who strongly recommend the Ceros over the Festool ROSs.

Re: Lost a friend today....

#13

Re: Lost a friend today....

paul woolson

I had the same thing happen a couple of weeks ago. I really LOVED that Dewalt sander. Probably abused it a little too much.

I bought a Festool sander when the bearings on my Dewalt started to squeal. But I could never really get used to it. Always seemed like it sanded much more slowly.

So I just bought a new Dewalt. I like it, but don't love it. They changed the body a bit so it doesn't quite feel the same. I'm sure I'll get to love it but not quite yet.

Re: Lost a friend today....

#14

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Burial?

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Rather than toss it away I'd take it apart, you can always salvage the new one with older parts once it starts to barf on you,

:-)

Re: Lost a friend today....

#15

Tony Reynolds

Re: Better yet, best of both worlds

Tony Reynolds

Agreed! The Mirka Ceros is great! Just bought the 6" about a month ago with the Festtool CT-26 using Abranet abrasives. Life is good, wish I had done it sooner, but get your wallet out.