Spice Box 2 Dovetailing the case
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Dovetailing the case
PIC 1
I dovetail a case no more than 2-3 times a year and as a result I am never certain of doing the layout optimally. Hence, I develop the dovetail layout on a piece of paper the size of the boards to be dovetailed as shown in the first picture. Then I transfer the approximate center of the pins to the board to be dovetails as shown(the brown thing is the walnut board). I have shown previously the jig I use for marking pin sizes. In fact, after making the drawing I decided to reverse the tails and pins. The rationalization for this choice was that the case would be picked up by the top so I wanted the strength of the dovetails to favor the case being lifted by its top.
PIC 2
There are some special considerations for the dovetails in a spice box case. They are handled differently by every author I have seen describe making a spice box. By looking at the assembled case we can see the problems to be solved....in the easiest way possible in my case.
The inside of the case will be filled with drawers, and these must have clearance to be withdrawn. The traditional way to get the door out of the way is to hinge it as show in the picture. This strategy then involves removing some of the right case side to the depth of the door as show in the picture.
Additionally, a rabbit is often made on the opposite side of the case to function as a door stop. The hinge mortices need to be chopped out. And finally the back of the case is to be rabitted to inset the case back. These operations are difficult to do after the case is assembled. If these needs are accounted for in the dovetail layout these operations can be easily done on the case sides before the sides are assembled. By studying the pin layout on the case side you can see how the dovetail layout enabled these operations to be made on the side before assembly.
I hand saw the dovetails, then cut out the waste with a band saw to near the base line.
PIC 3
A pesky piece of wood remains. The saw shown is ideal for removing it.
I then pare to the base line with a chisel. By band sawing very near the base line the paring cut can be made without the chisel wedging past the base line. (I have tried every imaginable way to remove waste and this technique, learned in the Headly, shop works best for me) Finally, I mark the pins from the tails.
For me the “pins or tails first controversy” is settled. I can’t reliably make the precision angled saw cuts for the tails. So I saw them first and it doesn’t matter what the angle winds up. I can saw vertical pin lines, and even if they are slightly not vertical it doesn’t matter. If I made dovetails more often to stay good at it I would likely do pins first.
I had not made a dovetailed case in several months. I can not bring myself to practicing making dovetials before getting on with it. At first I needed to do some paring to adjust the fit but toward the end what I sawed slid together nicely. A few months from now when I face some more dovetailing I will relearn these fine points all over again.
A molding covers the through dovetails. I made the pins slightly below the tails so that they would not push out the molding over time as the case sides moved.
And one last place to err. It is a whole lot easier sanding the case insides before assembly. I assemble slidy joints with liquid hide glue. The case pulled up square and I was pleased.
A note on squaring a case. I find a square misleading. If one of the sides is even slightly bowed the square will indicate the case out of square when in fact it may not be. I don’t rely on squares to square a case anymore. I measure diagonals. In this example they were the same to within 1 mm. (I like a metric rule for measuring case diagonals.)

I see taildoves too.



I agree, "awe" is the right word. For starters, it is not possible to lay out a regular hendecagon (eleven sided polygon) using just a ruler and compass, or measure the angle with a protractor divided into degrees. After he laid it out using some approximation method, there is also the difficulty of protecting the veneer of the field from 22 center points of his radius cutter, while trying to get 22 circular tangents perfectly aligned.



