Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Spice Box 2 Dovetailing the case

Posts

Spice Box 2 Dovetailing the case

#1

Spice Box 2  Dovetailing the case

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Dovetailing the case

PIC 1



I dovetail a case no more than 2-3 times a year and as a result I am never certain of doing the layout optimally. Hence, I develop the dovetail layout on a piece of paper the size of the boards to be dovetailed as shown in the first picture. Then I transfer the approximate center of the pins to the board to be dovetails as shown(the brown thing is the walnut board). I have shown previously the jig I use for marking pin sizes. In fact, after making the drawing I decided to reverse the tails and pins. The rationalization for this choice was that the case would be picked up by the top so I wanted the strength of the dovetails to favor the case being lifted by its top.

PIC 2



There are some special considerations for the dovetails in a spice box case. They are handled differently by every author I have seen describe making a spice box. By looking at the assembled case we can see the problems to be solved....in the easiest way possible in my case.

The inside of the case will be filled with drawers, and these must have clearance to be withdrawn. The traditional way to get the door out of the way is to hinge it as show in the picture. This strategy then involves removing some of the right case side to the depth of the door as show in the picture.

Additionally, a rabbit is often made on the opposite side of the case to function as a door stop. The hinge mortices need to be chopped out. And finally the back of the case is to be rabitted to inset the case back. These operations are difficult to do after the case is assembled. If these needs are accounted for in the dovetail layout these operations can be easily done on the case sides before the sides are assembled. By studying the pin layout on the case side you can see how the dovetail layout enabled these operations to be made on the side before assembly.

I hand saw the dovetails, then cut out the waste with a band saw to near the base line.

PIC 3


A pesky piece of wood remains. The saw shown is ideal for removing it.

I then pare to the base line with a chisel. By band sawing very near the base line the paring cut can be made without the chisel wedging past the base line. (I have tried every imaginable way to remove waste and this technique, learned in the Headly, shop works best for me) Finally, I mark the pins from the tails.

For me the “pins or tails first controversy” is settled. I can’t reliably make the precision angled saw cuts for the tails. So I saw them first and it doesn’t matter what the angle winds up. I can saw vertical pin lines, and even if they are slightly not vertical it doesn’t matter. If I made dovetails more often to stay good at it I would likely do pins first.

I had not made a dovetailed case in several months. I can not bring myself to practicing making dovetials before getting on with it. At first I needed to do some paring to adjust the fit but toward the end what I sawed slid together nicely. A few months from now when I face some more dovetailing I will relearn these fine points all over again.

A molding covers the through dovetails. I made the pins slightly below the tails so that they would not push out the molding over time as the case sides moved.

And one last place to err. It is a whole lot easier sanding the case insides before assembly. I assemble slidy joints with liquid hide glue. The case pulled up square and I was pleased.

A note on squaring a case. I find a square misleading. If one of the sides is even slightly bowed the square will indicate the case out of square when in fact it may not be. I don’t rely on squares to square a case anymore. I measure diagonals. In this example they were the same to within 1 mm. (I like a metric rule for measuring case diagonals.)

Re: Spice Box 2 Dovetailing the case

#2

Re: Spice Box 2  Dovetailing the case

Lars Parrington

Is it just me or does your pencil sketch show taildoves instead of dovetails?

For paring to the baseline, by far my favorite apporach is to line up the baseline flush with the top of a moxon vise. The vise then acts as a jig for the chisel, and I can chisel from both sides:


Bill, these series that you are posting are great! Keep em coming. I trust they are being immortalized in the articles section?

Re: Spice Box 2 Dovetailing the case

#3

Re: Spice Box 2  Dovetailing the case

Hank Knight

Lars, I thought my dyslexia was acting up. :b I see taildoves too.

Re: Spice Box 2 Dovetailing the case

#4

Ellis Walentine

Articles material

Ellis Walentine

You asked about immortalizing Bill's forum posts in our Articles section. The short answer is yes. The longer answer is that time and resources are stretched around here, as I've been working on a new feature that I predict will amuse you. On another note, if anyone would like to be an editorial assistant here, I'm open to volunteers.

Ellis

Re: Spice Box 2 Dovetailing the case

#5

What I meant to say.........

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Provided was a case of "haste makes waste", or never hurry a picture post. I inadvertently erased the picture I intended to post of what I actually did. Shown was the drawing with the pins on the case top and bottom. In my haste to convert locating dots to pin ends I made upside down tails instead of pin ends. And then I didn't use this configuration anyway. It's amazing I get anything built.

Below the situation is corrected with a retaken picture, what I should have done to begin with.


Shown is the drawing I actually used to located dovetails on the board ends. The drawing is of the right side of the case showing the more narrow right side to accommodate the door thickness. Also developed in this drawing is the pin size for the front pin that will move the corresponding tail on the side over enough so that the piece can be sawed off the side for the door inset. Sawing the piece off before case assembly is greatly easier than dealing with removing this piece after case assembly. Ditto for making the hinge mortise.

Re: Spice Box 2 Dovetailing the case

#6

Ah! That looks better


Re: Spice Box 2 Dovetailing the case

#7

Re: Spice Box 2  Dovetailing the case

Stephen Kirk

That's a nice auxiliary bench. I'd love to make one of those. I have the LV twin screw vice mounted in the face position, but it slips a lot and is often in the way. This looks like a great way to get the extra wide clamping when needed, and get it out of the way when not needed. Good trick for cleaning the dovetail bases.

Re: Spice Box 2 Dovetailing the case

#8

Re: Spice Box 2  Dovetailing the case

Stephen Kirk

The box is really coming along and should be nice looking when done. A couple of years back I made a spice box with Chuck Bender (when he had the Acanthus school) and I learned a good trick for removing the waste. We'd rout it away - a simple jig holds the pieces and adds support for the router bases. Then you just rout as close as you dare to the edges and pare away what little remains. Works great for half blinds, but I've used it for through dovetails as well.

Re: Spice Box 2 Dovetailing the case

#9

Re: Question

William Duffield

…so that the piece can be sawed off the side for the door inset. Sawing the piece off before case assembly…

Are you describing the process by which you are making the right side narrower than the left side by the thickness of the door?

You are most assuredly correct: There are many different ways to build these spice chests. Here is a picture of one that the builder sawed the top and the right side to the same width, fitted the dovetails (6 tails in the top; five pins and two half pins in the sides), and then applied a strip to the front of the top the same thickness as the door. Regrettably, the pictures I have do not tell me how he sized the left side or the bottom.


The reason for this asymmetry is to provide a place for the strike for the lock. Historically, they all had locks, even though a lot of reproductions do not. I guess the people who could afford a spice box and the spices to store in it could also afford to keep servants, who sometimes had their hand in the till.

I've seen other boxes that inset the door and the hinges, and then added another board to the inside of the right side, so the drawers would clear the door. This hid the asymmetry until the door was opened.

On the spice boxes built and popularized by Steve Latta, with a frame and panel door, the panel is obviously (once you know to look for it) offset from, and does not align with, the bracket feet. Reference FWW Issue #196, Jan/Feb 2008, pp. 58-67. I suppose you could balance it by making the right stile wider by the width of the exposed left case side, and make it even less obtrusive by scratching a groove in the right side of the right stile. FWW's copyright prevents me from providing their picture of it, but you can buy plans from them for $25., Here is another one built by Steve Latta:


I have a photo of another spice box (also displayed at the 2012 SAPFM Mid-year Conference) with a flat panel door with an inlaid border that is offset to the left by the exposed width of the left carcass side.


Re: Spice Box 2 Dovetailing the case

#10

Re: Question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Are you describing the process by which you are making the right side narrower than the left side by the thickness of the door?" YES

Re: Spice Box 2 Dovetailing the case

#11

Comment

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Every day I walk by the one I made for wife years ago (see WoodCentral contests). The eye is so drawn to the door that the framing issues are looked past and not noticed.

For this build I fretted over avoiding the asymmetry and in the end decided that all the fixes were no improvement. The inset door leads to other appearance issues when the door is opened. I suppose a knife hing would be a fix but it would look strange on a 1720 style box, I decided.

I am in awe of the layout challenge of the last box door. I suspect that the last element was hand carved to get it adjusted to come out right.

Re: Spice Box 2 Dovetailing the case

#12

Re: Comment

William Duffield

I hope you understand I'm not trying to be critical, just analytic. I've looked at lots of spice boxes, and this is the first time I became aware that the solution to the lock problem had this sort of repercussions in the overall symmetry of the design.

Bill wrote: I am in awe of the layout challenge of the last box door. I suspect that the last element was hand carved to get it adjusted to come out right.

If you want to find out more about the design of the line and berry on the last example I posted, Phil might be able to help. He took the photos and might know who built it. I have no idea whether it is original, or a reproduction. That may be because I don't have access to a copy of Lee Ellen Griffith's monograph on the art form. In explanation, that shouldn't be surprising, as there are currently only three copies for sale anywhere, and the lowest asking price is $275. I should just "bite the bullet" and buy it. I've spent more on books.

Maybe he used a roll of quarters and a coffee can lid? ;) I agree, "awe" is the right word. For starters, it is not possible to lay out a regular hendecagon (eleven sided polygon) using just a ruler and compass, or measure the angle with a protractor divided into degrees. After he laid it out using some approximation method, there is also the difficulty of protecting the veneer of the field from 22 center points of his radius cutter, while trying to get 22 circular tangents perfectly aligned.

For those who have problems finding things on the web, Bill's previous superbly interpreted and executed spice chest is documented here, along with a critique by some well known woodworkers:

http://www.woodcentral.com/contests/jewelrybox/index.html#winners

I disagree with Lee Grindinger's analysis of the weight of the top molding, because it is dictated by the functional requirements. It must effectively conceal the drawer that is hidden behind it. I also disagree, philosophically, with David Mark's criticism that being a "copy" of a traditional form somehow distracts from its artistic merit, and the artistry of the builder. I don't have the energy to write an essay this morning that would do justice to my opinion. Maybe later.

Re: Spice Box 2 Dovetailing the case

#13

Spice Box to Article.......let's make a deal

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I collect stuff for the Articles so functionally I could assemble the posts over the course of this build into an article for the Articles, if that is the place to record it. Or, maybe it should be in Shop Shots, or stay where it is at?. Anyway, I don't mind assuming the task of putting it together. However, my writing needs an editor. If someone will volunteer for editing an eventual write-up for clarity I will do it. Volunteers respond to my email. And if not , settle for my haphazard posts.

Re: Spice Box 2 Dovetailing the case

#14

Ellis Walentine

I'll take care of editing

Ellis Walentine

What I'd like at some point is to have an articles team that can solicit (and/or) collect, edit and upload the articles. Before Dan passed away, he acted as coordinator, Garrett Lambert did the editing and Rod Peterson converted them to HTML. Time marches on, and I'm holding the fort, but I don't have enough time to divert to article production. Actually, there are some support roles here that I'd like to have filled, including editing, HTML production, ad sales and moderating for a new feature I haven't even announced yet. If anybody would like to get involved and help me make this place even better, get in touch.

Speaking of which, I haven't run a fund raiser in years. Maybe this would be a good time to have one. We have a handy Recurring Donations program with PayPal (see link at top of page, "Support WoodCentral"). If you enjoy this site, now would be a great time to sign up for one of the recurring donations options. It's painless, automatic and *Very* much appreciated.

Onward and upward,

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Spice Box 2 Dovetailing the case

#15

I can help with that...

John in NM

Looks like we're finally settling down to regular observing at work, that gives me more time to do computer side projects.

I had been bringing small woodworking projects, but I started hearing some grumbling about dust :D

Re: Spice Box 2 Dovetailing the case

#16

Ellis Walentine

Re: I can help with that...

Ellis Walentine

Email me and let's discuss.

Re: Spice Box 2 Dovetailing the case

#17

Sent!