Bill Tindall has put together another article for our Articles department about determining drawer heights within a case. Bill has collected three examples, two from Keith Newton and one from Richard Jones on different ways to go about this often puzzling exercise.
Thanks, Bill, for continuing to add useful content to our articles collection.
Ellis is in the midst of "demolition" (his words!) two bathrooms. (talk about not having the proverbial pot to...... ) Never-the-less he took time to edit the confusing description I provided and joined it with the contributions of Richard and Keith to make a polished article for the WC Articles, and then did the computer magic to get it in some mysterious format to post. Is there a chamber pot in the house?
Re: New article -- determining drawer heights *LINK*
Trying to come up with the progression of heights that's most pleasing to the eye as well a filling the overall height of the project by pencil-paper-calculator is a cumbersome process at best, especially if the number of drawers are allowed to vary. To simplify the effort and allow design flexibility, I put together a spreadsheet that considers all the variables and returns a precise linear progression. By entering the overall height to be divided, with or without dividers, and the ratio of the bottom to top heights, it displays the heights for any series of drawers up to ten in number that fill the carcase. What's better; 7 or 8 drawers, and should the heights be close to equal or steeply declining?
Re: New article -- determining drawer heights *LINK*
"cumbersome process at best" Many would not judge the method Keith and Richard proposed, or the classic method, to be "cumbersome".
"To simplify the effort and allow design flexibility, I put together a spreadsheet that considers all the variables and returns a precise linear progression. " It is difficult to judge the utility, or even compare the difference, of your proposal with the sparse detail offered.
Keith and Richard made the effort to describe their process in enough detail that others could evaluate and use it. These techniques were judged to be of sufficient interest to preserve them in an Article. To be a useful response you need to not just criticize what others do but provide sufficient details that your method can be evaluated and employed by others.
Re: New article -- determining drawer heights *LINK*
Bill, I wasn't aware that my comment was critical of the approaches you highlighted. Any offense taken was surely unintended. My spreadsheet simply offers a quick and easy way to evaluate a variety of alternatives to laying out drawer configurations. Just another way to skin a squirming cat.
Re: New article -- determining drawer heights *LINK*
The topic of progressive drawer heights came up on the old UseNet newsgroup rec.woodworking (aka The Wreck). Several Wreckers described various methods of calculating progressive drawer heiights, but just a written description of procedures are hard to visualize. So - I illustrated three methods and how they work - and did an Excel spreadsheet that can be downloaded to do the math for you. The link to that stuff is attached.
Graduated drawers was a hot topic in the old UseNet newsgroup rec.woodworking - which was a Text Only. The problem with Text Only is that some things are hard to understand when given just a Text Only descrption. Some people will Get It, but Visual Learners usually struggle to Get It.
Being a Visual Learner, I had to take the Text Only description of methods of finding drawer heights for progressive drawers - and attempt to illustrate the concepts being written about. And to do THAT, I had to understand the math (actually just simple algebra) behind the concept. ANd once I had the math, I could luse the math in a spreadsheet, and let Excel do all the boring calculations and give me the resutlng drawer heights.
Hopefully the stuff at the attached link will help understand the WHY as well as the HOW of three means of calculating drawer heights.