So I might break down and buy a Festool Domino sometime soon. Chico has me convinced. So the DF500 is $850 and the DF700 is $1,250. What does the 700 do that the 500 doesn't? I hope to only drop this kinda coin on a tool like this once. So is the 700 worth it??
Do you use tenons over 3/8" thick? The 700 is for bigger, longer tenons. More of a use consideration more than money. The 700 is much bigger and heavier. It is a must for house doors and something like a trestle table base. But if you mainly continue with your furniture, save your money. It's also very easy to put in double tenons if you need that.
The bottom line is that the 500 makes a mortise 250mm (about an inch) deep, while the 700 goes 350 mm. The 700 mortises are a little wider as well. The 700 does not do the smaller thickness mortises (e.g. 5, 6mm) but there is a third party adapter that fixes that.
Both machines make extremely precise mortises that produce close fits to the tenons that Festool markets. You may also make your own tenons, but then the fit is up to the skill of the user - certainly not a problem for you.
The fits are so tight that a dry fitted assembly of say a chair, can stand up and take a load, so that you can be quite sure all is ok or identify problems before glueup.
The mortising process is quite fast, once marked, a minute or two for each mortise. Alas, as with regular joinery the marks need to be in the right place .
I make chairs, cabinets, desks, tables, etc. with the 500. Exterior doors and beds bring out the 700.
Whichever machine you buy will save you a tremendous amount of labor and give you more control over cost and price.
And the customer will not be able to see the difference.
One more thing, the used Festool market is crazy. A tool thats a year or two old often resells for 90 percent of what you paid for it. So there's not a huge risk whichever way you go.
One caveat, the Domino won't do pretty through tenons. But if you want to do G&G, you can certainly put a decorative plug on the end of a regular m&t.
I'm not as giddy about them as you are Jesse. I've cut floating tenons for over 25 years with a Multirouter, and still prefer it. The Domino fits too tight in my opinion, and can be even tighter in end grain compared to long grain. In a recent picture frame job, I used common pine for the canvas stretcher. The domino would have required a hammer to drive them in the end grain if I had not modified the thickness. That's too tight and I would consider it being a dry joint. I feel the rpm of the Domino cutter causes a fuzzier cut in soft wood end grain compared to the router. I also prefer clamping my stock to cut mortises for absolute precision. Hand held, not so much. Just my opinion of course.
I have both and would only purchase the 700 if I was buying again. There is an outside (non Festool) company that makes 6mm bits for the 700 so Domino diameter is a non issue really. The big difference is depth and the 700 takes the cake in depth; good for chairs, beds, doors, etc. but also for small pieces of furniture. On a side note the 700 has better balance than the 500 and can more easily be used single handed (also more ergonomic handle design). The way it functions makes alignment easier in my opinion.
As for the fit of the Dominos I agree they are overly tight and I almost always sand off the little nib on the radiused edges along with a quick pass or two on the flats. You can make your own but having bought and used many thousands of them I still think my time is better spend building furniture.
I've been looking at them but am not going to buy one since I don't do commercial work, and as better as they may be they don't produce the goods of hand joinery or do much at the cheapo end I can't get done with biscuits. For stuff around my shop I might need to throw together, biscuits are fine, and beyond that it is hand joinery. But I have looked at them and probably for the reasons above, as well as hearing the fence was better, I would buy the 700. I suppose also because people seemed to think it was the hands down favourite.
You are right about them not producing hand cut joinery or the look of hand cut joinery. They are simply a tool that allows a shop to produce faster. I am in a commercial environment and faster production pays the bills better than hand cut joinery; which I have never had a client ask for or be willing to pay for. If I was just making things in my home shop I would probably still buy the 700 even if only to not have to use biscuits ever again. Never did like them and the Dominos are so much stronger.
This is pretty much the norm for any purchased wood joinery piece, dowels, bisquits, dominoes. They are not engineered or manufactured to be too tight, it is pretty much always the conditions that they are stored in that does this. As all are compressed in manufacture for the 'squeeze out' features they really like to grow when there is a differential in humidity from their manufacture. The key to keeping them the right size is to keep them really dry. Two solutions; your freezer, or a dedicated hot box/ micro kiln. The hot box may be needed if the packaging was bad or you have/bought really old stock
Freezer works well for home based shops and the other more for production.
A dissenting opinion on the 700. I own the 500 and like it alot. One of my professional woodworking friends that also owns the 500 has tried the 700 and was of the opinion that unless you need the larger size domino's, the 500 is lighter and easier to use/maneuver then the 700.
Since you're using the multi-Router for the mortises, have you ever considered using the Domino 6mm tenons? They work great with a ¼" bit in the Multi-Router.
I haven't tried it, but the 8mm tenons ought to work with a 5/16" bit, too.
I've made sticks of floating tenon stock for so long, I don't consider making it a problem. Only problem is when I don't make enough, and change the setting on the thickness planer. Then you have to go through the process a second time. I learned early on to not do that again! I also put 45 degree angles on the sides of the stock and not try to match the router bit radius. I like that because it leaves a reservoir so the excess glue has someplace to go and not hydraulic lock or squeeze out excessively.