A potential customer has asked about using spalted maple for a stock. I've never worked with the stuff, but due to a couple factors (thin spots) I'm a bit concerned about strength and told him it would probably be wise to stabilize it like I do for burl stocks (burl I do for dimensional stability, not strength).
So I'm looking for opinions from people who've used a lot of spalted wood - does the spalting make for weak areas?
Depends on how rotten it's gotten. I've seen some just break across the grain when stressed. Other can be pretty strong. Personally, I wouldn't care for the liability myself. I also can't see how stabilizing will add strength, hardness yes, strength I doubt.
Stock as in gunstock? Some spalted wood at least as far as the inky lines go, is not that rotted at all. I used to make my own all the time, by storing wood in plastic bags to keep it wet, and it would often spalt within a short period and be perfectly strong when it came out of the bags.
Liability is an issue, but many gunstock are not heavily stresses, so it would be a non-issue there.
Another issue is that while it turns well, it would be a pain to attempt to carve or checker if it was variably workable.
I made a spinning wheel of the modern pedestal type, where the base had a large block of spalted in it, and it was really solid.
ive been carving spaulted maple lately, using CPES
Keith Newton
For the same reason, but my finished products were small and don't require much strength, unless the were dropped.
I'd like to see the stocks that you made from burl, and wondering what product you used to stabilize it.
The thin epoxy I'm using certainly makes the wood harder, especially if it is more advanced decay, which will soak it up like a sponge,. I don't know about other properties like tension, but I'm sure there would some benefit, I just haven't been able to find any specs. I think they claim it retains some flexibility, which should make it less brittle.
Just guessing that the thin U shaped fore-grip is where yo have the most concern, I'm wondering if you might be able to lay in some carbon fiber tape after the penetrating stuff had set.
One thing is for certain, getting a good finish on the real punky stuff is easy after it is cured.
Smith is the brand I have now, bought from Jamestown Distributing, and is a 1-1 mix ratio. But since my last order, another brand, another ratio pops up first on their site when you search for CPES there.
I've been using K&G Finishing's service for it. I send them the rough sanded parts and it comes back needing to be re-sanded and buffed. If I was making these for my own use, I would probably try some of the available products and make mis-use of the vacuum pumps we have at work, enjoying the learning curve. As it is I just get them done and out the door and a check in the bank
The resin they use is very hard and a little on the brittle side, btw.
Personally, I find burl to be a bit busy for a stock, but I try to please the customer within the limits of materials. Stabilized burl is ok for a 2 piece stock, but would be too heavy for a full rifle I think, and unstabilized would be a disaster going from the NM desert to the northeast.
The drawer fronts on my hand tool cabinets are spalted maple. Some of the drawers are weighted down pretty heavily, but no problems after 8 years.
The wood was funky in a few places, which I trashed. What was left was strong enough to take hand cut dovetails sharply.
Be prepared, though, for surprises. When re-sawing, I sometimes found funky spots in the center that didn't show on the surfaces.
An alternative to spalted maple is what we called "Wormy Maple" when it sold for a buck or two a board foot. Now that it has been discovered, they call it "Ambrosia Maple" and charge a lot more. It is quite strong, though.
Those are exactly why I was leery of the idea to begin with! That would be the advantage of what Tom mentioned, make one's own. Then its no huge big deal to make a few back up blanks at the same time.
Plus I'd rather make it out of some nice curly maple with a caramel color musket stain.... those look great