A very good friend took a new job out of state and has asked me to buy his 1996 Sears Craftsman 18" bandsaw. 115V 2HP motor, advertised as taking up to a 1" blade. As a toy designer, he would not have used the saw hard or excessively. I'd like to be able to advise him what a fair resale value would be.
Eight years ago the new price for that saw was $1300. It got average to below average reviews at that time. Ten years before that the price was likely lower and one may have been able to get one on sale for even less. Without any used tool price reference, for that saw in very good condition, I would say about half what your friend paid originally would be fair to both parties. Your friend may want to give you the "very good friend discount".
I recently sold an 18" Delta band saw for $650. Comparatively, the new price was $1600 and Fine Woodworking magazine gave it the same review as the Craftsman, curiously almost word for word.