I have an island kitchen with a Jenn Air down draft range. It time to replace the range. What would you buy? Would like another down draft, but its not really necessary. I never grill steaks on it. (too slow and too messy.)
Re: OT What brand of electric range would you buy?
Re: OT What brand of electric range would you buy?
John McGaw
Price range? Size? Electric? (Coil, smoothtop, induction?) Gas? (Exposed burners? Dual-fuel?) Convection or conventional oven? Single or dual ovens? There are seemingly a million possible permutations.
I'd give some consideration to proper venting of the stove no matter whether you are grilling steaks on it or not. It is really more a matter of maintaining a healthy home than merely extracting visible smoke.
Right now CR is rating Hotpoint as requiring the fewest repairs if that might be a deciding factor.
Re: OT What brand of electric range would you buy?
Part of what I wanted and did not know how to ask is what do you have and like?
I have run the old Jenn Air into the ground. Time to move on.
I don't know what I want. Want it to work well and be easy to clean. The Jenn Air is full of cracks and crevices. The numbers have scrubbed off the knobs. (New knobs cost way too much.) I could go to propane, but I don't think I want to.
Re: OT What brand of electric range would you buy?
I haven't used too many electric stoves, but if you like to cook good food, some form of flame is the way to go. If you just cook to eat, you can make do with electric.
Embrace your inner caveman.
Jason
Re: OT What brand of electric range would you buy?
Re: OT What brand of electric range would you buy? *LINK*
Hank Knight
Barry,
I bought a Dacor smooth top 5 or 6 years ago and have been very pleasd with it. I'd never heard of Dacor until my dealer introduced me to the brand. I'm glad he did; it's a nice range.
Re: OT What brand of electric range would you buy?
Ralph Lipeles
If you have any of getting a gas line in, I would go that way. When we redid our kitchen about 20 years ago, we had electric and did not think there was a way to get a gas unit. I spoke to the local propane co and they said that their hose could reach 100 feet. The place where we wanted to put the tank was 90 feet away so we were good. With the previous electric when we changed the temp setting it took forever to get there. With the propane, it's almost instantaneous. We also have a limitless variety of heat ranges, not just those on a dial. I enjoy cooking and find the propane tiers above the electric that we had.
And yes, since I had to buy a 100 foot coil of the special stainless steel gas line, and only needed 15' for the kitchen, I installed a propane wall heater in my garage.
Ralph Lipeles
Re: OT What brand of electric range would you buy?
Re: OT What brand of electric range would you buy?
John in NM
We bought an Amana smooth top downdraft last time. It has had minor problems but nothing serious enough to fix.
Last house we had an Amana NG downdraft - open flame and downdraft don't work well together. The downdraft vent needs to be a few inches above flame level - you wouldn't think it makes that much difference but stuff heated noticeably slower on that stove with the fan on.
I believe many appliances or their components are made by GE regardless of how they are branded. Our Amana fridge has a GE board that supposedly controls the defrost and is bad. The previous model in the last house still used the old clockwork mechanism for defrosting and never failed us, and the bits were about 1/3 the price of the improved and less reliable newer parts. Progress
Re: OT What brand of electric range would you buy?
Odd. I have a 12-year-old Jenn-Air downdraft range and it is a smooth-top. Well, the usual right-side module is a halogen smooth-top type while the left side is the standard grill unit. I also have a coil-type for the right side which accommodates really huge pots for when I'm in mass production mode for chile and such. That is the supposed advantage to this sort of range (which doesn't really make up for its relative unreliability).
Re: OT What brand of electric range would you buy?
I have a Jenn-Air that is about 12 years old. It has a smooth-top halogen module on the right side although I also own a coil unit that accommodates huge pots suitable for mass production of chile and stew and soup. It has been OK although I've had to replace the main control/clock module. I do my own repairs but, as you have noted, parts can be pricey ($12 and up for simple knobs).
If money was not a major problem I'd go with a dual-fuel range with a single convection oven. I'd have to do something for venting, either one of the rear downdraft units or a new hood suspended from the ceiling over the peninsula and that single expense can be pretty major. If I was willing to do with a little less control over temperatures a smooth top would be quite acceptable although an induction rather than a hot top could be neat if it wouldn't call for replacing many of my utensils (which it would).
Re: OT What brand of electric range would you buy?
Re: OT What brand of electric range would you buy?
David Yoho
Barry, we did a big kitchen upgrade earlier this year (countertops, appliances, back splash, cabinet hardware, sink and faucet, and disposal. One of the major appliances we replaced was our Jenn Air brand range.
In shopping for the appliances we talked to a local independent shop owner who was very knowledgeable from the service to sales sides of things. We went in with a negative bias for GE. Thought we wanted anything but GE. After hearing why he recommended GE and looking at reviews online it turned out he was right. We bought a smooth top GE range with a convection oven. We also purchased a new GE microwave. He said to only get one with the features we needed and not to let a higher price make us think one was better than the other since they are no longer made to last more than five years for the most part.
Another thing we learned was that most of the major brands like Whirlpool, Amana, Kitchen Aid, and so many others are owned by Whirlpool.
When we were considering dishwashers, we had a couple of features that were deal breakers. Bosch was out due to QC problems many are reporting. In fact, he stopped carrying them for that reason. Kitchen Aid was in the running until they didn't meet our criteria on one feature. We ended up with the German-made Miele. Talk about top line quality and priced appliances - look not further.
More than you asked about but maybe it's useful.
Re: OT What brand of electric range would you buy?
Re: OT What brand of electric range would you buy?
Jesse Cloud
Most of what I've read in Consumer Reports and anecdotal evidence from my friends confirms the idea that none of the appliances are built to last more than a few years. Most brands, as John suggested, use stock parts from other manufacturers.
What I would suggest, though, is to look for a liquidator - someone who carries last year's models. The product changes very little from year to year and last years model comes with the same warranty and a much lower price.
Re: OT What brand of electric range would you buy?
Wife and I think the Europeans have this one figured out. Induction is big there. We're about to outfit a new house, so we bought an induction single element hotplate sort of thing to experiment with over the past year. We think the real thing should be even better as we spent less than $100 on the single. Yes, you may have to change out your cookware, as not everything works on induction, but you can get genuinely high, quick heat, unlike normal electric, but even more efficiently. That's gaslike without creating fumes in the home where you breathe and have spent good money to condition your air, so why suck it out all the time.
Downdraft, don't even get me started about that antiphysics nonsense. Been living with it for over 10 years.
Re: OT What brand of electric range would you buy?
We bought a smooth top Whirlpool a few years ago ("glass" top). I'm not crazy about it. When it is clean, it looks nice. But, it is hard to clean (can't use any windex, etc.) and it scratches. We don't cook a lot, so ours still looks ok, but I would bet a serious cook would have it all scratched up. The glass stays streaked with the slightest bit of oil, grease, etc. and you have to let it cool to clean it off, then use the special cleaner. So, I owuld look at something else next time. On the plus side, it does heat well and quick.
Tony
Re: OT What brand of electric range would you buy?
Weird... nothing in windex is going to hurt glass.
We clean ours with a homemade concoction of ammonia and isopropyl alcohol, diluted with water. Basically stronger windex without the blue dye. Use a clean rag rather than paper towel - the paper usually has added oils to make it feel soft.
Re: OT What brand of electric range would you buy?
Our smooth top range still looks good after 5 years. I made a commitment when I bought it to keep it clean. We wash it daily with dish soap and water as part of the dishwashing routine. Occasionally a spill or boil-over will char and stick to the surface, a quick scrape with a single edge razor blade takes care of that. Every month or so I polish the surface with an abrasive stove-top polishing compound sold at your local grocery store for the purpose. It takes about 5 minutes, if that. Grease left on the surface streaks and builds up to an ugly mess. We don't allow grease to remain on the cook top after using the stove. Keep it clean and it will look nice for a long time. It's easy to maintain. We like ours a lot.
Re: OT What brand of electric range would you buy?
I clean mine on a day-to-day basis with Windex, to get the grease off before it burns on. When it needs a good cleaning of charred grease and boil-overs, I use Bar Keeper's Friend with a White (non-abrasive) Scotch-Brite pad.
It's a Sears Kenmore, with two ovens, five top elements and a convection mode that we hardly ever use. We have absolutely no complaints about it. I would definitely buy it again, if someone assassinated the one we have now. We've had it several years. It appears to be identical in looks, controls and features to this one:
I can cook on my smooth top electric when the power is out (ref. link in my post below for specs), feeding it from the generator. I just have to make sure I only use one surface element or the small oven at a time. It's also a good idea to not run the water pump or the furnace or the water heater at the same time. They're both fuel oil, so they only need electricity to run the thermostat, oil pump, igniter and blower.
And besides, I have a Weber gas grill out in the back yard.
Re: OT What brand of electric range would you buy?
How would one locate an appliance assassin? I never knew anyone specialized in that field
I remember all too many years ago when I was a handgun enthusiast going to a dump site where there were lots of items for targets to practice shooting. There were also several old appliances there but I think they were already dead. However, I did enjoy shooting a variety of electric alarm clocks I took with me that failed to do their job properly. A 357 magnum really doesn't leave much intact. Of course all I was really doing was just killing time
Re: OT What brand of electric range would you buy?
That's what the book says. I took them for their word because Windex is disastrous to the screens on our handhelds (I work in a group that helps manage about 70k handhelds!). So, I know it can be a problem. Glass ain't "glass" anymore!
I've never tried Windex on our top. I'm committed to things being clean too, but at some point, if its too much effort to clean, I'll try something else. This one is too much effort to keep clean (clean is relative). The cleaner they sell also gets on the silicone (or whatever sealer) around the edges much like when you wax a car and leaves a white residue. Sorry, I'm just not a fan of these things. I don't like that I'm afraid to move pans around while cooking and I'm always afraid I'll drop something and crack it or scratch it (there are a few scratches in it).
My parents have an older smooth top that appears to be some other material. It isn't clear or smooth like ours and is actually a grey color. Not sure what that is. They seem to like it ok.
Tony
Re: OT What brand of electric range would you buy?
Just looked up the manual online. It does not specify Windex, but does specify ammonia as a no no. Listed a whole bunch of no no's actually. Even states that one should not slide pots and pans across it. Too finicky for me (my wife bought it!).
To be clear, this is the glass type. Looks like a big sheet of glass. Does look nice when it is clean. I can see the attraction over the old coils and such.
Tony
Re: OT What brand of electric range would you buy?
LOL. Of course, I didn't really expect you to hire one for my range. I just meant I can't imagine it having reliability problems, or us feeling the need to replace it. But, like everything else, eventually it will wear out and need replacing, but maybe not before me.
Re: OT What brand of electric range would you buy?