Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

The economics of woodworking

Posts

The economics of woodworking

#1

The economics of woodworking

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I don't get out much so I don't know how far this observation extends, but woodworkers are the only hobbiests I encounter that fret over the cost of their hobby. During bass season I follow 4WD 3/4 ton pickups pulling tens of thousand dollar bass boats. In deer season it is similar trucks pulling a 4-wheeler and there are thousands of dollars of deer hunting stuff in addition. My golfing friends make golfing outings and my skiing friends go to the western mountains and my diving friends go all over the world. My woodworking friends fret over buying a hand plane, or 100 bd ft of lumber. Yet of all these hobbies it is woodworking that provides a handsome return on investment.

My son in law fretted over buying a used table saw. The front door of their new- to- them house needed replacing (idiot former interior decorator owner didn't like the looks of gutters. Rain splashed on front door which kept it wet. You know the rest of the story!) As is often the case, as we got into replacement there was a lot of repair to do to do it right......enabled by the table saw. Without the saw the front door fix would have been at the expense of hiring someone for a day to do it, I suppose at the cost of the saw or more.

For those that build furniture the return is substantial. Any sort of custom made furniture is at least $1000, and on up to many thousand. One does not have to build much furniture or repair or remodel much to get a pay back on tools ( making assumption that as a hobby the time is free).

So, every time you see a bass boat go by get out the Lee Valley catalog and feel good about ordering something.

Re: The economics of woodworking

#2

Re: The economics of woodworking

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

"So, every time you see a bass boat go by get out the Lee Valley catalog and feel good about ordering something."

I'll tell my wife you told me to do it...

Re: The economics of woodworking

#3

Clint Searl

Re: The economics of woodworking

Clint Searl

Hear,hear!

Re: The economics of woodworking

#4

Re: The economics of woodworking

Barry Irby

You are correct. Wood Working LOOKS like it aught to be productive and provide a handsome return on the investment. Skiing and golf do not and its pretty much a given that hunting and fishing do not either. There was a comedian that had a story about the guy buying the new pickup, then the bass boat, and having the trailer custom painted to match the truck. Then he and his buddies go fishing, in an icy rain. They are catching nothing. Finally there is one small fish landed. On the ride home, he hears them doing the calculation of what that fish cost per pound.

I am way past "even" on my shop and tools.

Re: The economics of woodworking

#5

One caveat...

John in NM

Just because a woodworker makes something does not mean it is either valuable or readily salable. I used to try to sell furniture and rarely could do so, even at what were bargain prices for the piece - if you build it, they will not necessarily come (borrowed from what is now an old movie, but most here will know it).

People do not necessarily want what you want to make. To sell work, most of us have to make what people want to buy, which often takes some of the fun out of the hobby - it's more fun to make what we want to make. Took me more than 20 years to stumble into a niche that satisfied both, and I count it up to luck, nothing more.

Then there is the guy with the bass boat - he buys stuff and uses it, maybe the fish are biting maybe not. Golfers do not expect anything but enjoyment out of their hobby. For some reason, woodworkers are generally expected to produce something useful for all the money they spend on wood and tools. There is a significant learning curve involved, and I've found that the angst you describe over purchases comes from the woodworker knowing that not every shiny bronze plane will improve the productivity they seem to feel is required of them.

Re: The economics of woodworking

#6

Re: One caveat...

TomD

You are right that it is very difficult to sell anything. And I largely distrust the apparent value family members may put on one's efforts. One builds stuff because on has to, and wants to, it won't get one much further than that. Or one can build stuff because one has custom needs, all my early projects were self designed, and with stuff like boats one can significantly customze them. Nobody else will buy them but at least one saves the money one would have invested in those things had one not made them oneself. One probably doesn't come out on top compared to collecting, except I only know what to collect from having been deeply involved in the craft.

Re: The economics of woodworking

#7

Re: The economics of woodworking

TomD

I think you are dealing with apples and oranges woodworkers. There are WWs who are driven by making stuff they can't afford to buy, there are woodworkers who are collecting hotleys. There is fine woodworking, and there is what PM used to be, before the handy family learned to hand cut dovetails. To the extent that for some people it is as much a second job as anything else, it has to pay off as such.

In between the extremes there are woodworkers who are buying junk tools that will not get them a single point as far as contributing to better outcomes. People buy a lot of extra golf clubs and such, for their hobbies. But most of these activities have measurable outcomes, so the self-delusion only goes so far. Then it repeats itself.

Re: The economics of woodworking

#8

Re: The economics of woodworking

Jesse Cloud

Interesting thread!

One of the main reasons I work wood is for the happy look on wifey's face when she gets exactly what she asked for - a chair that fits or a table she "helped" design.

A couple more types of woodworking tool buyers:

The Collector who wouldn't dream of getting a tool dusty or maybe even scratched by using it.

The Recreational Shopper who gives you a shop tour that is mostly stories of what a great deal he got on this piece or that.

Re: The economics of woodworking

#9

Re: One caveat...

Yonak

Return on woodworking toys can be borne by more than selling your woodwork for cash. I re-did our bathroom last year. If we were to have it done by an outside professional it would have cost us several thousands of dollars. My cost in materials was in the low hundreds. My time was my own and I was doing what I love to do. I feel a penny saved is a penny earned (I did not coin that phrase :) )

Re: The economics of woodworking

#10

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I think they all have a broad range.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I've known quite a few hunters and fishermen who partake in their hobbies in a fairly inexpensive way, and with the purpose of putting a significant amount of meat into their freezer each year. They don't have fancy vehicles, boats, guns or bows.

Likewise, I've certainly seen quite a few woodworkers on the various online fora who don't seem to be concerned with the cost of their hobby. They're clearly blessed with much disposable income, so they buy the best of whatever tool they decide they need next.

I like to brew beer (and drink it, of course). I realized long ago that if I factor in the cost of equipment and my time, I could easily drink premium beer for much less per bottle/pint/whatever. But that's not the point. I enjoy the process, and there's a certain satisfaction that comes when you (and your friends) enjoy the fruit of your labor. Same for woodworking, hunting and fishing, whether you're running a Felder or a Skil benchtop, a $30,000 bass boat or a $300 used jon boat.

What is the distribution along the spectrum of spending for both types of hobbies? Heaven only knows. Those with more disposable income tend to spend more on their hobbies than those who don't, so I imagine it somewhat follows the income distribution.

Jason

Re: The economics of woodworking

#11

Re: The economics of woodworking

David Yoho

Interesting topic. I spent probably about 20+ years working wood in my home shop while I was working a full-time job that paid the bills. I started out with marginal tool brands but over a period of time replaced most with better and more precise capabilities. I spent most of my time building custom furniture and cabinetry for people who came to me by word of mouth. I used the income my workshop generated to pay for my tools and materials. My shop was too busy during those years for me to think of it as a hobby. I always thought of it as being a semi-professional. Either way I was able to purchase and use some nice equipment that has given me many hours of enjoyment. Now since I retired from the full-time gig things are not as busy in my shop but I do get to enjoy many nice tools and make whatever strikes me with the abilities I learned along the way. To me it was money well spent and it never came out of our household budget.

Re: The economics of woodworking

#12

Re: The economics of woodworking

Randy Johnson

I don't really make money with woodworking, but I get more cash in hand back than I do with my other main pastime, shooting.

The last week of this month I will be near Yadkinville, NC for a week at a primitive muzzleloader shoot. If I win every match (better chance of hitting powerball) I won't clear enough to pay gas one way.

The Saturday before Thanksgiving I will be at the one show I do a year now that shooting has taken up a lot of the time that used to be spent turning. Even if I sell everything I take and add it to what I have sold in the past, I'm still short of what the lathe and all the turning tools cost. And left out of the equation is the cost of propane during the cold months, electricity all year long, money invested turning a termite-infested two car garage into a nice shop, and all the other tools that see less use since the lathe was introduced to the mix.

Last month, I made a walnut chest, that was actually a cooler, as a traveling trophy for a special shooting match. The wood was part of a stash given to me that I have used little because turning is the preferred use of the shop. One of the girls at the office loved it and jokingly said she would mow my grass (a chore we both hate doing) next year if I made were one for her and left out the Styrofoam. She doesn't know it, but she will be getting a similar box made as a chest. Hers will be cherry because I don't have enough walnut left but I really don't think she will mind. I won't be expecting her to mow my grass in return.

Within reason, hobbies shouldn't be about cost. They should be about enjoyment and making yourself, and maybe even others, happy.

Re: The economics of woodworking

#13

misplaced reply

Randy Johnson

My comments above were meant for the original thread instead of a direct reply to Joe's post

Re: The economics of woodworking

#14

Re: The economics of woodworking

ChuckinND

I think alot of it depends on if a person is retired or not. I'm not retired, so I don't do much of it anymore because the payback is so minimal to none existent if I'm doing it for someone else. In my opinion the industry is going to have a tough go at it because less people will be able to retire, or don't have the time because they are working two jobs to stay afloat. The industry isn't doin much about it other then expecting woodworkers to work for free in forums promoting it while they profit from it. There is alot of misinformation out there because of it. Just my opinion.

Re: The economics of woodworking

#15

Re: The economics of woodworking

TomD

One stat that floats around is that even in hard times, spending on hobbies does not go down. So we will see if that applies also to changes that may follow new economics. Woodworking can be practiced very cheaply and can be a net return. Think of depression woodworking.

A huge number of guys working today, not super rich guys, have far more tools than the best professionals had in the past. Look at the tools Krenov had to work with, his planer was massive and interesting, but not even as good as one of our toolbox planers today. When I started out I ran into a boatbuilder, a pro, who had just bought his first planer, he was ecstatic, the look one has if one never thought one would see the day. Today you can buy a planer for what it costs many people to pay their cable, internet and phone in a month.

So on the one hand people have a ton more, but you can do it with very little. Not sure that means it will go away for economic reasons.

I think it will die off because nobody does anything except go online, and many people coming up have no idea why they would want hand made. There are more people all the time, and more people coming into some kind of wealth (mostly in the rest of the world). So the business may not flag if it has billions of people to serve, but on a per capita basis it may not be what it was.

Re: The economics of woodworking

#16

Kneale Brownson

Re: The pleasure of hobbies

Kneale Brownson

Over and over I see in responses to Bill's comment mention of enjoyment in crafting something.

What do you think about while you're doing something with wood? Certainly not the politics of Obamacare and usually not about what the activity is costing you.

Part of the fun of hobbies is that they take you away from life's other issues.

Re: The economics of woodworking

#17

Re: Haven't made one cent!

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I retired 9+ years ago. The last couple of years before retirement I (and my sons and family) built my shop. It was fairly expensive as I super insulated the building and installed central air and heat. I also had saved up to purchase some of my equipment. However at the time I vowed NEVER to accept any job or to make anything to sell. I spent $50K to $70K building the shop and purchasing the equipment. I certainly am not rich but all was paid for as I built and purchased. The last thing I wanted to happen was for the woodworking to become a "business" instead of a hobby. I have had several offers of pay for items I have restored and built for family members, and have had friends want me to build items for pay. In all cases I have refused! I totally agree with Bill, I have had various hobbies in my life, if I had calculated the economic return ~ none would have came close to being at all sensible. The only one that has a chance of returning a profit is my gun collection (doubt it will be sold as long as my son lives). My wife has said the shop is a good investment for my youngest son (in his 40's) as he enjoys WW like I do. He will inherit the shop and hopefully enjoy it when we are gone!

Re: The economics of woodworking

#18

not about making, its about saving money

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

As a hobbiest the economics is not about making money, its about saving. Every time you make a gift, fix something, make furniture or other stuff around the house or do something for a friend or charity, the hobby saves money. Most that are active in their shop are going to save more than they spend.

Professional woodworking, defined as working for money, is different economic discussion.

Tool collectors are also a different discussion. I do acknowledge that there are plenty of people that buy woodworking stuff and seldom use it. I don't consider these categories "woodworkers", a word that has "work" in it.

Re: The economics of woodworking

#19

Re: not about making, its about saving money

mdclor

All of us have our own motivations-making money, saving money, etc. As for me, I work wood because I enjoy the processes and most always the final product. I also enjoy the creativity required in the design phase and figuring out how to do whatever it is that I need to do and haven't learned how to do previously. I am not opposed to selling for a profit to support my habit, but that isn't a motivator for me. FWIW

Re: The economics of woodworking

#20

I always heard you have to...

David Yoho

...make money to save money.

However, going back to your point of spending money on a hobby that in turn saves money, I'd say some of those other hobbies qualify as well. A hunter buys all kinds of things to make himself successful. At the end of the day he can stock his freezer and those of his friends or family with meats they didn't have to go to the store and buy and in some cases are better for us. Some learn to reload their own ammo, which at some point can become a savings, not to mention they can make custom loads possibly not offered at the sporting goods store.

The same could be said for fishermen when it comes to what it saves them to stock their freezers. So I don't think us woodworkers are alone in that respect.

The amount of money one spends to get to a point where their hobby saves them money is different for all. Some hobbyists can be productive with a minimum setup while others sink more into their hobby for a variety of reasons. Whether or not we're actually saving money depends on what we are able to do with a given hobby and how long it takes to get out of the "red".

As a woodworker I've been able to make and repair many things for myself and others because of the tools and skills I've acquired over the years. But I'm not sure how much I've saved because you can't qualify a savings until you know you've reached the point where you've paid for the investment. Some will get there sooner simply due to how many DIY projects they do and the scope of those projects.

I hope I'm addressing your point clearly enough. Sometimes my thoughts don't make their way to print as clearly as they are in my head. Bottom line... you first have to make the money some way before you can spend it. Then, depending on how much you spent, comes a point where the hobby becomes a savings. I've been fortunate to have had my "hobby" pay for itself so that anything I do for myself or family and friends is a savings much sooner.

Re: The economics of woodworking

#21

Re: not about making, its about saving money

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I admit I did tend to "collect" tools, however I "made do" many years working with inferior equipment (all that I could afford while raising our children).

I did extensive remodeling to our 100+ year old home with very little decent tools. After the shop was finished, my son and I made all his (Cherry) kitchen cabinets, installed all new windows and doors in his old house, and made all new Oak baseboards and trim etc. I have restored several pieces of furniture, and made a few pieces.

I probably have invested more into my shop than was necessary ~ but it certainly is a pleasure to work with accurate dependable equipment.

The reason I would / will not take any compensation for my work is that I do not want to have my "hobby" become a "job". Other than the necessity of making my sons home livable in a reasonable amount of time, I do not, nor will I ever set a timetable to make anything. I really want to enjoy my hobby!

Re: The economics of woodworking

#22

Re: The economics of woodworking *LINK*

Keith Newton

Well, I've been fortunate enough to earn my living working in my own shop for around 40 years now, and design just about everything that goes out the door. I have amassed a pretty good collection of tools over the years, and do really enjoy using them. However, I have had some great times on my boats over the years, and wouldn't trade those memories for anything.

I ran across this article on another forum, and though it was a fine piece of writing, and that anyone who responded to your question would probably relate to it.


http://waltharrington.com/books/upcoming-acts-of-creation-spring-2014/acts-of-creation-prologue-and-praise/

Re: The economics of woodworking

#23

Re: The economics of woodworking

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I read the article last night (night shift, plenty of time) and absolutely loved it.

Thanks much for posting, Keith.

Re: The economics of woodworking

#24

Re: The economics of woodworking

Frank Orfanello

I just read that piece tonight and enjoyed it so much I sent it on to a couple of buddies.

Thanks for posting it here.