Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

catalyzed poly finish question

Posts

catalyzed poly finish question

#1

catalyzed poly finish question

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I'm finally coming to the end of my trestle table project and have been in touch with a cabinet shop to spray it for me. The guy there tells me they use a catalyzed poly finish, three coats on both sides of everything. Good answer so far.

I'm inclined to use BLO or Minwax antique oil as a base coat just to pop the grain, but the spray guy tells me that the catalyzed poly won't stick properly to any oil.

A. Is this true?

B. Does catalyzed poly darken the wood as an oil would?

C. If B is no, then what can I do to ensure that the grain will stand out?

Re: catalyzed poly finish question

#2

Re: catalyzed poly finish question

Thomas S Stockton

Bruce

I would trust what the spray guy tells you or if you have questions contact the finish manufacturer . You could use a really light colored stain that was compatible with the finish.

Every finish is a little different I would do a quick sample and see how the wood looks.

Tom

Re: catalyzed poly finish question

#3

Re: catalyzed poly finish question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It would be helpful to know what exactly the finish is. I use Sherwin Williams Kemvar M over oil and oil based stain with no problem. Any finish that sticks to an oil based stain should stick to oil.

What is the wood?

Re: catalyzed poly finish question

#4

Re: catalyzed poly finish question

Dick Coers

Is the catalyzed poly a water base? Definitely don't use BLO, Minwax not if he says no. Minwax is easy to use, but not the choice for many professional shops. It takes too long to dry. Amber dye would work, or what ever line of stain the pro uses or recommends.

Re: catalyzed poly finish question

#5

Base Preparation

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

If you want to "pop" the grain and still use the cab-shop's spray, two steps:

1. Wipe on a coat of Waterlox (red can) sealer. Allow to "dry" for 48 hours.

2. Apply two coats of freshly mixed 1 lb. cut dewaxed Ultra Pale or Blond shellac. Apply by padding or spray if you have it.

The shellac is both extra sealer to contain the oil and "tie" coat. Everything sticks to shellac.

Here's an example on White Oak


Topcoat finish is 3 coats of General Enduro Gloss Poly with added cross-linker.

Check with your shop to confirm they're OK with this.

PS: The "won't stick to oil" tells me he's using a waterborne finish. That should be easy to verify with the shop, in which case he's quite correct, most waterbornes can run into adhesion issues over oil UNLESS dewaxed shellac is used as the sealer.

Re: catalyzed poly finish question

#6

question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If there is a layer of shellac under something like urethane varnish won't the durability of the varnish be compromised? It seems to me that the result will be less resistant to water and less resistant to denting.

I have yet to see a water based finish with the brightness and clarity of a solvent based finish. The only time I will use one is when I want a water white finish over something like maple.

Re: catalyzed poly finish question

#7

Shellac

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

being merely the "tie" coat with plenty of surface details for the topcoat to cling to, is basically a non-issue. Key is the shellac isolating the oiled fibers. The difference is between a tie coat and a finish coat. Were I to do a filled-pore finish with shellac, I'd be hesitant to rely upon the "chemical" bond between the topcoat and the shellac.

As stated, Old Finishers Axiom: "Shellac sticks to everything, and everything sticks to shellac."

If you want to take the time, search back to posts between Alan Young and me regarding using shellac under waterborne finishes.

I did a bookcase for my son's apartment in Brooklyn. Build was cherry veneer-ply with solid edge banding. Finish was Waterlox Sealer, sealed with dewaxed shellac, then finished with 3 coats of General Enduro Gloss Poly with cross-linker. New Years Eve they had a fire in the apartment above them. Smoke+water+soot wiped out most of what they had; books, clothes, several antiques. The bookcase wiped clean with a damp cloth.

Shellac has been a "standard" part of my finishing routine. I use it "straight" and with added metalized dyes to blend and match colors. It is too flexible and (if really needed) reversible to not use.

Re: catalyzed poly finish question

#8

Re: catalyzed poly finish question

don stephan

Some water borne finishes are almost bluish, others look much warmer like solvent finishes. By all means get a finish sample from leftover wood. I would expect most full time finishers to have a procedure to enhance the figure and character of wood beyond just what the finish achieves. But not all finishers are experienced with analine dyes. You have the right to ask lots of questions.

Re: catalyzed poly finish question

#9

Re: question

don stephan

A couple thin (the operative word) coats of shellac as a adhesion tie layer would not be likely to compromise the topcoat. If the topcoat can be penetrated by exposure to moisture down to the shellac, it can be penetrated down to wood when not used over shellac, and the latter would cause problems. In my opinion, one or two brushed coats of shellac would not be recommended as a tie coat because the result would be too thick a layer of shellac.

Re: catalyzed poly finish question

#10

I Did Say

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

ONE pound cut and Padded or Sprayed.

Brush on 2-3lb shellac and you might have issues with a conversion varnish.

Re: catalyzed poly finish question

#11

Cab Shops

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

don't take the time that us hobbyists do with finishes. They'll shoot three layers of a KCMA approved finish and out the door it goes. You looking for chatoyance and real depth of color? Do it yourself.

[KCMA = Kitchen Cabinet Manufacturers Association]

Re: catalyzed poly finish question

#12

A nice recommendation for any finishing

Dick Coers

is to do a sample. Can't say the number of times people on the internet ask for help, AFTER messing up the finish on the project. Be patient with the cabinet shop and that sample. We are talking post cat here, and he's not going to want to mix up a batch just to do a sample for you.

Re: catalyzed poly finish question

#13

Some answers. *LINK*

Bruce, a MN Galoot

It's not a water-borne varnish. It's an oil-based catalyzed varnish, it and dries very hard. The guy said the reason not to use any BLO or WATCO kinda product is that the solvents in his stuff eat right through any other finish. I don't quite know what that means, but he said that it does a nice job of bringing out any chatoyance and highlights in the wood.

I'm not inclined to use any stain (and he doesn't like stains on cherry anyway), so I left a sample of the wood with him today and he'll spray it so I can show my friends. A little collusion goes a long way. I'll lay it out on Monday for a little sunlight, and voila!

This is the stuff:


Gemini Conversion Varnish

Re: catalyzed poly finish question

#14

some replies

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Any of the oil based products react with oxygen to cure into a film insoluble in any solvent. Properly applied a "pre-oiling" would be wiped from the wood surface to leave only a very thin film on the surface and the rest absorbed within the pores. However, the oiling must be thoroughly cured before to coating.

The literature on this stuff says it is a finish designed to resist coloring from exposure to light and the UV inhibitors are going to resist coloring of the wood too.

Were it my table I would be staining it with a general Finishes pigment stain before this finish was applied. Example below


Re: catalyzed poly finish question

#15

That's good to know

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I hadn't read through it that far, but I'm fairly sure my friends would like it pretty close to the color of your example.

Thanks, Bill, for this and so many other answers...

Re: catalyzed poly finish question

#16

I suspect....

Jesse Cloud

I suspect that the cab guy is nervous about spraying onto a base finish that he had no control over - I know I would be.

After all, if it goes sour, the customer (you) is likely to blame him and not want to pay or want a redo or something like that.

Please don't take this the wrong way. I have great respect for your woodworking talents, but he may not know you well enough to take a risk.

I know the finisher I work with would not take that deal.

Re: catalyzed poly finish question

#17

Re: I suspect....

Bruce, a MN Galoot

When we talked today, he said he had never sprayed over anything like BLO. He didn't know what it was. That's okay; many people outside the forums don't. I, OTOH know diddly about spray and cat or pre-cat or conversion varnishes. I just don't want to learn at someone else's expense, and neither does he. I have absolutely no problem with that.

The final OTOH, I also want to be guaranteed that this grain will pop. This wood was not like your normal nice cherry. It's sometimes wild, sometimes gnarly and often dramatic. It deserves to be appreciated.

Re: catalyzed poly finish question

#18

Re: I suspect....

Dick Coers

If it doesn't pop on the day it is sprayed, it certainly will in a couple of months. I'm of the school where you never add color to cherry when you finish a project. Nature started it, she will make it better with time.

Re: catalyzed poly finish question

#19

Re: question

TomD

i think a lot of people still say you can't beat nitro. I find that even the dime store water based, like Valspar's doesn't look half bad if a tiny amount of an amber agent is added to it (where that would be acceptable, which is probably almost everywhere except over something like Holy). Luthiers have gone pretty hard into water based, finish is do or die in lutherie. It is 95% of the sale. There are special products out there for guitars, and some pros are using them.