I decided to use Waterlox Original Sealer for my latest project (a walnut bookcase). I am looking to get some advice on the dust nibs. I've already applied multiple coats of Waterlox, and did some wet sanding with 400 grit in between one set of coats. However, I still have a fair amount of dust nibs from subsequent coats of finish after wet sanding and am wondering whether to keep applying more coats of finish, despite the nibs, and assume to get them off after all coasts are applied by rubbing out with 0000 steel wool, or should I do some light sanding now, before applying any more coats of finish?
Get rid of them before recoating. I wet sand with mineral spirits or turpentine and wipe/inspect often if I need to get rid of them. Seems like a step backwards, but it's worth doing for a nice finish.
I usually put the Waterlox on as thin as possible, with the most lintless rag I can find. Usually with the original sealer, by the third or fourth coat I can only wipe it on and maybe pass over it again real quick before it starts getting too tacky. Out here where it's usually hot and dry, I can get 3-4 applications in a day after the first few coats.
It's not that good for grain filling of course, being so thin. One thing about Waterlox, it will gel in the can on you if you leave it a week or two, maybe a month after opening. I pour it into old jars and only use a little at a time (mostly gunstocks these days, so a little is just right). One use for the gelled stuff is grain filling with some pumice powder. May not be the look you're after though - all smooth and glossy.
No reason for wet sanding between coats, and no reason to sand between each coat, particularly if not much time has elapsed between coats. For thin wipe on coats, it takes 3 or 4 wiped on coats to be equivalent to one brushed on coat of "full strength" varnish. You can wipe on "sets" of three coats, spaced only as long as necessary so that a finger touch wouldn't come away with varnish. That will space the coats about 3 hours apart. Then after three such thin coats let the set cure overnight, and then sand lightly before the next set. That should keep dust nibs at bay for a time. After the last set you can put paid to all the dust nibs by doing a more complete rub out process. Applied in sets, the coats will chemically meld together enough to reduce the risk of cutting through to reveal witness lines.
You should also really work to reduce dust in the environment if at all possible. Easier said than done.
I've used Waterlox quite a lot - on my own kitchen, hardwood floors, and furniture projects- and haven't had any problems with dust nibs. It sounds like you need to control the dust in the air, or use a better rag to apply it. I have used an old white tshirt with good results. Maybe wash it first to make sure it is good and clean, then cut squares out of it and give it a shake for good measure before using it. Sometimes the first coat needs a little light sanding after it is dry (12-24 hours) but usually no problems after that.
But it does definitely depend on a number of fairly intangible parameters that will vary greatly from person to person.
What it basically comes down to is patience and confidence - both of which come from experience as far as I've ever been able to tell.
From Bart's post, I gather he wants a quick and easy finish that will look nice - and Waterlox will provide that once he learns the technique. Rubbing out all the dust problems at the end are not what I would suggest for him based on what I perceive to be his level of experience with the product - but that perception may well be in error.
The advantage to wet sanding is that it's fast. Early in the process, there is nothing wrong with fast (ie aggressive). You don't care much if you sand through the finish, since you are effectively starting over - starting over on the assumption that you will prevent a repetition of the dust and lint problem going forward.
I do not advocate sanding as a regular step to achieve a smooth finish - it is too aggressive for that. But as remediation, it works very well.
It sounds like we need a definition of sanding between coats. Waterlox is a varnish, and you don't "white sand" it like you do a catalyzed or lacquer finish, at least I never have. For one thing, Waterlox will just gum up sandpaper unless it's fully cured. To me, sanding between coats to remove dust nibs is about using 320-grit stearated paper backed by something hard like an MDF block for flat surfaces. Use just the slightest amount of pressure -- just enough to barely contact the surface. You're not trying to abrade the whole surface, just get rid of the nibs.
Whether or not you wet sand depends a bit on how much pore filling you want to do with that sanding slurry. If you want an open pored look, wet sanding will compromise that a bit.
My Waterlox technique is to first decide how much film I want on the finished piece. If it is a lot, I don't even start with Waterlox anymore because it builds too slowly and I don't ahve the patience to lay on ten or fifteen coats over a week or two. I will use another heavier-bodied clear gloss varnish -- spar usually -- for one or two (or more) base coats to get close to the finish thickness with the least time and effort.For an average finish that doesn't need quite the film thickness, I will wipe a couple wet coats of Waterlox on, letting each dry before applying the next one. I've rarely tried to apply more than two coats in a day, and that was in good drying conditions. One a day is average for me. Once the base coats are established, I lightly level any nibs again with 320 stearated paper on a hard block and follow up with a few coats of Waterlox wiped on very thin with a cotton cloth.
It's a little tricky to gauge and even harder to explain, but I use just enough Waterlox to extend that coat quickly and evenly over the whole surface, with just a glistening of product left behind -- not wet, not bone dry. This will dry more quickly than a heavier coat and give you fewer dust headaches. To me, this "handling" capability --this ability to extend the film without having it seize up on you while you're working -- is the reason I started using Waterlox to begin with back in the 60s and 70s. Other varnishes and wiping finishes are just too difficult to handle, for me at least. One exception is General Seal-a-Cel, which I find very similar to Waterlox in most respects, maybe a little less amber in color.
After the whole magilla hardens up for a few days, you can adjust the sheen with 0000 steel wool and possibly some paste wax for a satin look. You can even build a gloss with Waterlox, but it's fussy and time consuming and takes a lot of coats.
One caveat: I don't use Waterlox for horizontal surfaces in particular that require abrasion resistance, such as sideboards. Waterlox just doesn't get hard enough to resist things like stoneware and other scratchy items. Similarly for dining tables, it'll take on a nice used sort of patina, but not a pristine one. For that you want a conversion varnish or something that dries hard as a rock. Of course then you don't get the tactual appeal of a Waterlox/varnish finish.
I've heard a lot of wiping varnish advice over the years, and all I can say is that everyone's mileage varies. I just try to understand what I'm doing rather than just follow a cookbook. Select the product you want for the protections you need, apply it to the thickness and sheen you want, adjust on the fly as necessary.
Thanks everyone for taking the time to write such significant replies - especially Ellis!
As an FYI - I was following a process described in Fine Woodworking that included wet sanding once you put down a base coat.
My big mistake was to try and do the finishing in my garage versus in my basement workshop. I was trying to keep the finishing fumes out of the house. That ended up causing me major dust issues. So, I've moved into my son's old playhouse that is a fairly well sealed structure.
I did use some 600 grit and light sanding to remove all the nibs before adding more coasts of finish. I also started using some cotton cloth to wipe down the Waterlox, instead of shop towels. Hopefully, the combination of these two things will get me a better result. Will post final results and pics when done.
The smell of finish is a sign of a project nearly done. This smell should be welcomed.
The notion that a whiff of mineral spirits is bad is a recent development in the history of wood finishing. I don't imagine people abandoned their homes for days when it was time to repaint or re-varnish with solvent based products.
Daughter recently had occasion to use some ketone solvent. When she opened the bottle the smell brought back fond memories of Dad spraying lacquer on finished projects.
Moth balls brings back memories of getting out the woolens for winter.
Ok - so I guess the smell is a personal preference thing. I, personally could do without the smell permeating my house.
The choice of the playhouse was not just due to smell. Its a small, but contained space that limits the amount of airflow that could cause dust issues. So far, I'm finding it to be an excellent place to do finishing.