Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

OT: vehicle undercoating

Posts

OT: vehicle undercoating

#1

OT: vehicle undercoating

Grant in iowa

I recently purchased a 2012 Silverado with about 11,000 miles on it. For the first time in my life I have a chance to do something to help prevent rust on a vehicle before a significant amount of it has occurred. On my last Silverado (2003), the rockers began to bubble and the bed above the rear wheels did the same after the 145K miles and Iowa salty winters. When i purchased the new (to me) truck, I resolved to do what I could within reason to prolong its life.

Being an avid (stubborn?) do it your selfer, I began looking in to how to do this job myself. I noticed the truck has the little plastic plugs in the normal undercoating locations. Thinking perhaps the work had already been done, I checked with my bore scope (did I mention I am an avid do it your selfer?), and found no evidence of anything inside except primer/ dip coat, and some paint over spray from the painting process. So I checked out a few friends trucks I knew had no treatment. Since they all have the same plugs and the holes have factory paint on their edges, we concluded the hole plugs are normal equipment from the factory, probably to allow access for a dealer added rust preventative.

So, I looked around, reading reviews and found Fluid Film, which has the primary ingredient of wool wax. I am thinking of ordering a kit to allow spraying the product in to the doors, rockers, wheel well cavities, etc. I realize it must be reapplied periodically to keep the protection effective.

I respect the views of the collective here at WC, and thought I'd ask if anyone has used the product, and what their thoughts are on it as a rust preventative/ inhibitor. There appear to be businesses in rust belt and coastal areas that apply the product to customer vehicles, but we haven't any around here, even though we have salted roads in winter. Anyone use them?

Thanks in advance,

Grant in Iowa

Re: OT: vehicle undercoating

#2

Re: OT: vehicle undercoating

Mark Nowicki

Your last paragraph makes it hard to respond for those who have used other products or feel that aftermarket rustproofing is a waste of time and money.

Mark

Re: OT: vehicle undercoating

#3

You having done some research

Gary Smyth

I'm pretty sure that you read that "rustproofing" has it's downside. That being that whatever product you put into it gets messy in the access channels and 1. will eventually dry and flake which (if it doesn't do it in the installation) will clog the channels and the access ports. 2. When that occurs any moisture that works its way within will not be able to dry and rust starts from the inside out. The only way to dump the moisture is to open the plugs for a period of time and most people won't do that more than once as the plugs never seem to seat themselves in a seal after the original installation. AND, sure as shoot'in it will rain within 24 hours of pulling the plugs. My mechanic advised doing nothing as the factory rustproofing is permanently infused in the metal in the dips. His opinion was that the vehicle will never be more rustproof than when it leaves the bath and dries. A clear drip channel is better in the long haul than adding something that moisture can seep under and make a home.

I had two cars with rustproofing "dealer installed, both had the accumulated moisture problem. For me never again.

Maybe the product you want to use has fixed the problem, but in my experience (Western PA) in the case of additional rustproofing, doing nothing is the better option. Also, if you intend to reapply the product, you might be making things worse by sealing in any of the salty moisture already trapped.

Re: OT: vehicle undercoating

#4

Re: OT: vehicle undercoating

Bill Howatt

The little I can say about Fluid Film is that my uncle gave me a small spray can and said it was real great for all sorts of lubricating jobs and it can also be used for rustproofing.

A lot of things have changed over the years regarding rustproofing. Certainly the old, what appeared to be tar-based, coating used to crack and peel and trap salty water and did more harm than good. I think the products have evolved and are likely a lot better. The only thing is that the car manufacturer's seem to have smartened up and the metal protection done "at the factory" is a lot better. I live in Ontario and we are certainly no strangers to road salt - my car's body is literally white if I don't wash the car frequently but OTOH you do not the numerous cars with rust on them like you did in the past.

IMO, if you want to rust-proof your vehicle the way to do it is by "oiling" it each fall and this should be done with a method that mists the oil. I use "oil" in a general sense but don't use old motor oil which was indeed used in the past. An advantage is that the oil will hopefully creep into rust areas and will even stop or retard where rust may have started. I used to oil my cars in the past. A friend had a setup on his property and used to buy some oil that had a high "something" content so it really stuck he said.

If you are having it done it can get expensive doing it each year and if you do it your self it can be a bit of a PITA each year. If it makes you happy then what does it matter!

I don't bother oiling anymore and just go with what the manufacturer did at the factory. You mentioned your 2003 truck rusted in certain spots. There are indeed bad designs that cause salt, dirt and moisture to be trapped in areas - another example used to be (hopefully in the past) near the bottom of the front fenders behind the wheels on GM products where a hidden shelf held the dirt. So if you know of a problem area for your particular vehicle you can consider just spot oiling.

Bill

Re: OT: vehicle undercoating

#5

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: OT: vehicle undercoating - Krown®

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

For US$129.00, I had my truck 'rustproofed' using a product called Krown. It was 'professionally' applied, and is essentially a petroleum vapor that permeates the application area, and stays soft, thus does not flake off. In fact, the recommend parking the vehicle outside for several days after application, because the solution drips out a bit.

The tech drills (and later plugs) access holes in doors, rockers, tailgate, etc., and sprays the product into it pretty much like you want to do. They also remove taillights, etc. to spray behind them. For the amount of work involved, in addition to material costs, I figured it was worth the $129.00.

Note that they do recommend periodic re-application. It's not a 'forever' treatment.

Here in NE Ohio, we have a raging rust problem, due mainly to all the road salt that's used every winter. They don't call this area "The Rust Belt" for nothing!

Re: OT: vehicle undercoating

#6

Re: OT: vehicle undercoating - Krown®

Bill Howatt

For those that do it, Krown is popular up here too and it would be where I would go to have it done if I were so inclined.

Bill

Re: OT: vehicle undercoating

#7

Sorry, not what I intended...

Grant in Iowa

Mark,

Sorry if I worded my question poorly.

Please let us know your experience with undercoating, whatever the type. If you feel it is a waste, then let us know what has led you to think that way. Also useful would be what region you live in, and road salt is extensively used there.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa

Re: OT: vehicle undercoating

#8

Re: OT: vehicle undercoating - Krown®

Mark Nowicki

My Father-in-Law had his 2002 Honda Odyssey "oiled" every year, before leaving for Florida for the winter.

For weeks after, he would park the car over layers of cardboard and tarpaulins to collect the dripping (his driveway has to be free of any blemish as well) He sold the car this year, proudly stating that it had no rust.

I still have my 2002 Honda Accord with double his mileage. Mine has spend all winters in Quebec and has never been oiled or undercoated. I have not even fixed the numerous stone chips on the hood, none of which have rusted. As of yet, no Bondo and duct tape either.

I think that if you remember the automotive junk that was made in the nineties and before you probably feel that aftermarket rust proofing is essential.

Personally I feel that drilling holes does more damage that the oil prevents.

FWIW, even in Quebec, I don't see many rust buckets on the road.

Re: OT: vehicle undercoating

#9

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Your advantage...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Colder temps slow chemical reactions, including the oxidation of iron.

The worst thing one could do would be to drive on a salty and slushy road, then come home and park the vehicle in a heated garage.

Jason

Re: OT: vehicle undercoating

#10

Re: OT: vehicle undercoating

Keith Weber

Cars are built a lot better these days. The money that you save by not rustproofing every year, you can put towards taking your car through the car wash often in the winter. Washing beats undercoating any day.

And, as someone else has said... leave your car in the driveway. Parking it overnight in the garage will promote rusting.

Re: OT: vehicle undercoating

#11

Re: Your advantage...

Mark Nowicki

That and frequent usage.

My 99 F150 really suffered when my annual mileage dropped from 25K to 2K.

Mark

Re: OT: vehicle undercoating

#12

Re: Your advantage...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

My 2000 Tundra has only 140K miles and two years ago Toyota treated me to a new frame because of rust problems. They hadn't anticipated the problems vehicles face in northern climates where roads frequently get salted.

Re: OT: vehicle undercoating

#13

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

No surprise.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I know someone who got a very good trade-in on a new(er?) Toyota pickup because the frame was rusted beyond repair on their 2000-ish Toyota pickup.

I drive a plow truck for a friend with a landscaping company, and with the record snowfall we got last year, I spent quite a bit of time on the slushy, freshly salted roads in my work van going to and from the shop. What was just the start of some rusty spots a year ago became some full-blown body rot by this past spring. I need to get it in to the body shop in the near future for a patch panel, as I intend to keep this van for some time, and I want to keep it looking somewhat decent.

Jason

Re: OT: vehicle undercoating

#14

Car washes

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In some places car wash water is partially recycled. Not a good idea if salt removal is the objective. The car wash may spray salt laden water where it ordinarily might not go.

Something different from the old days of biodegradable cars is the treatment of the metal. The roll stock for the body parts is precoated with a corrosion inhibiting metal, for example aluminum. Additionally, cars are now primed by immersion in the primer bath. The use of calcium chloride, which makes some hydrochloric acid when exposed to water, is now less common.

Re: OT: vehicle undercoating

#15

Check your business listings

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

Check your business listings just about anywhere. Look for companies called Ziebart and Rusty Jones. They were big in the 60's and 70's in rust proofing and they are no longer in business. What does that tell you.

We had several of our cars done with rust proofing here in North Western PA where they dump tons of salt on the roads every winter. I couldn't see where the rust proofing made the car last any longer nor did it improve the resale value. Even if you protect the inside with some sort of goop, unless you regularly fix the stone chips the rust will work in from the outside. YMMV but I won't pay for it again.

Lee

Re: OT: vehicle undercoating

#16

Rick L

Re: OT: Fluid Film

Rick L

Here in western MA I know of at least three large truck repair shops that started by selling Fluid Film by the galllon and have upped it to five gallon pails. Apparently a lot of the local DPW's are using it on their snow plows and salt/sand trucks. Lots of DPW's have switched to liquid calcium chloride which is very corrosive.