I'm gonna put up a pergola with pressure treated wood and would like to pre-finish it. Wife and I are going round and round over priming and finish coating it with paint, or staining it. Someone mentioned waiting a year before finishing? Anything to that?
Most treated pine is delivered wet, maybe wetter than it was in the tree. They kiln dry it, pressure treat it, driving the water with chemicals all the way through it and sell it.
A couple of years ago I replace the railing on the my son's house and they painted them (White) with good quality exterior primer and paint. I was back over there yesterday and the paint has basically fallen off. About 50% wood exposed. I guess we will paint it again.
I have been involved with housing as a builder and Home Inspector for about forty years and I have never seen new treated wood successfully painted. It is my understanding the treated wood industry says paint and stain do nothing to preserve the lumber. It MAY improve the appearance, but does not extend the life.
OTOH, we left the deck alone on the same house and used premium treated wood. It had weathered enough, I am tempted to stain it. Have to admit I was taken aback by the appearance.
It's all about specifying the right product. You can get pressure treated KDAT (kiln dried after treatment). Usually at specialty dealers. It is ready to be finished when you get it. Coxwood is one supplier. You can get information and dealer locator from the website.
Was this the brown or the green lumber? I just went on the Yellawood website, and they say to do a sprinkle test, a few drops of water sprinkled on, and if it penetrates, it's dry enough to paint. Sounds good, but, if one board happens to be wet then I'd be screwed. At my age, old, old, I'd like to get the thing up and finished and be done with it. Be so nice to be able to prime and paint on the horses, rather than off a ladder, which would be a hire (wife won't let on a ladder anymore).
That had to discouraging, your paint failure, I feel for you. Thanks for your input.
This is true, and I have mentioned it here many times. There is KDAT and ADAT (Air Dried After Treatment). The last batch I bought was not nearly as dry as properly Kiln Dried wood.
The typical big box store version is so wet and shrinks so badly it will ruin any miter joints you try to cut. Cracks will open up, boards will cup and twist. The process brings out the worst in yellow pine, It warps.
Also the "Premium" stuff is coated with what amounts to paraffin. Slick and "pretty" in the store, but very difficult to finish.
It has been often stated to leave the installed PT for a year before finishing. I have finished some right away over the years with good results but I can't now recall exactly how wet it was.
Even though an opaque stain looks a lot like paint, it is the only thing I will use for exterior wood since I consider it a lot more resistant to peeling; repainting a partially peeled surface is the last thing I want to do. Stains do fade faster than paint but the degree depends on the color - a dark stain will noticeably fade in a few years, a white stain very little difference.
Building just the posts and maybe the floor from PT? There is really little need to use PT for roofs and railings - unless you do plan to use a transparent finish and want everything to match.
I generally avoid PT as much as possible, because it is so wet. I suspect the "let it sit a year" advice has to do with that.
The town building code/inspector specifies all wood to be pressure treated, which seems absolutely ridiculous for wood with no ground contact. I guess you can't fight city hall.
since they aren't building entire houses out of PT lumber....
you're right though, hard to fight city hall - I once had a building code office guy insisting that I show direct ventilation for an electric water heater on the plans - even the building inspector got a good chuckle out of that one.
Mine was the green stuff and it came from a big box and was wet. My DIL insisted on painting it. I hate painting, so I guess it is not hard to talk me out of it.