My direct vent propane heater (Williams) has started to take a dump. I had a heating guy look at it and since everything is internally contained, it can't be easily repaired. Pair that with the price of propane and I'd like to make some sort of a switch.
I found some heat/ac units ala motel rooms that might be a good option. They are electric which I'll probably regret. I was at Menards last night and saw some small hang-from-the-ceiling units that were kind of appealing. But again, will likely be very expensive to run.
Does anyone have any thoughts as to what they are using?
I've got 600 sq/feet of stand alone space. Slab on grade with R13 walls and R30 ceiling. I could potentially run a gas line out there but that might be an expensive option, especially if I have to buy a heater as well.
If you are in heat pump country You might consider a "mini split" system. There are three or four brands out there and they offer very high efficiency. And they give you both heat and ac.
You did not give your location, the type / style of heating system that would be the most efficient for you is greatly dependent on the average / low temperature you encounter. Also you mentioned the possibility of running a "gas line" from your house would that be Natural gas? What distance is involved - may not be as expensive as you think. If NG, I would certainly consider that option as a long term "fix". I have installed and repaired many hanging heaters ~ repair of these units is not a big deal - I also installed and repaired other heating systems. maybe you need to consult with a second repair person. Also if the existing heater is repairable, and NG can be piped in you may solve all your issues by converting the existing unit to NG when it is repaired. Please give us a little more info for better answers!
Sorry, I'm in Madison, WI. It gets, and stays, pretty cold. Between Dec and Feb the average high is 28 with the average low being 10. (That average high seems a bit high to me but that's neither here nor there)
I haven't looked into having the natural gas line run out there. It's roughly 50'.
I contacted Williams (heater manufacturer) and they said that they don't have a kit to change my particular heater to NG. Is that something that a heating company could easily do? If that's the case, and running the gas out there, I think I've got my answer.
What would be cost of running a gas line and getting a new furnace ?
In Montreal, I would heat a shop like yours with a 5000W electric baseboard. The cost of the heater, electronic thermostat, 20A breaker and some 12AWG wire would be less than $200.
Paul, I would bet it would be very expensive to heat your shop with an electric heater of any design! Heat pumps would also be a expensive method of heating as the efficiency of the air exchange type is quite poor when the ambient temperature drops below 40 to 45 degrees. Since you have a fairly short run for a natural gas line I would certainly obtain quotes for that installation (I installed several of these in my life), gas lines typically do not have to be installed very deep, only enough to prevent damage from digging etc. You would need to contact your local municipal supplier to determine what is required in your area. The municipal NG supplier may also be able to convert your unit - and some do installations of the line for a fee. Conversion to NG is not difficult although it may require a new gas valve and pilot assembly as well as drilling out the burner orifices. I have converted some of these units in the past. A qualified HVAC service person should be capable of repairing and converting your existing unit. At worst I would purchase a new hanging unit and use NG. The natural gas would provide the heat needed at less than half the current cost of either propane or electric heat so payback would be pretty rapid.