Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Cedar roofs

Posts

Cedar roofs

#1

Cedar roofs

Lynn Surgner

Does anyone have an educated opinion on whether it is worth it to treat a twenty five year old cedar roof with Amteco's TWP200?

Re: Cedar roofs

#2

Re: Cedar roofs

Barry Irby

It depends on several things. How was your roofing installed and where are you?

Locally, all cedar roofs are installed "wrong" according to the Cedar Roofing manufacturer's association. The time honored and recommended way to install them is to put them on sheeting boards that are spaced apart or skip sheeting. From the attic there are spaces about as wide as the boards and you can see the bottom of the shakes. This allows for excellent ventilation and promotes drying. Basically the wind blows through.

Locally, almost all roofs are installed on solid sheeting (plywood) with heavy base felt and felt (tar paper) interleaved in the courses of the shingles or shakes. This keeps the wind out and prevents wind driven rain out, but also retards drying and the shakes rot.

If you are in an arid climate and it never rains, this does not matter but locally we get 40" of rain a year and we are lucky to get 20 years out of a shake roof. The ones installed on the skip sheeting will last twice as long.

I don't know anything about the product you mentioned, but I am guessing that because of environmental concerns preservatives have gotten less effective over the years. Also, spray on treatments are generally not effective because they only treat the exposed surfaces. The water soaks in from the bottom of the shakes and they rot from the inside out.

As a Home Inspector I have seen hundreds of cedar roofs, many of them failing. I seriously doubt there is anything you can apply to the roof that will buy you enough time to be worthwhile. Save the money and apply it to the new roof.

Re: Cedar roofs

#3

TWP

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I use TWP 1500 on my decks. Good stuff, lasts for 2 years.

Waste of money on a roof.

Re: Cedar roofs

#4

Re: Cedar roofs

Tony - Memphis

Barry, I've noticed on THis Old House, they have been adding a mesh material under the shingles to achieve air flow. Have you seen this? Does it work?

Tony

Re: Cedar roofs

#5

Re: Cedar roofs

Jerry Nicholson

Two of my neighbors got new shake roofs a few years back. The old shakes had been installed over the original cedar shingles so the old ventilation argument was moot anyway. One guy stayed with the "skip sheeting" and the other had 7/16 OSB installed over the old "skip sheeting". Big hailstorm came - baseball size plus. The guy with the skip sheeting had a couple of hailstones go right through the roof between the boards. The one with the solid deck had minimal damage to his roof. (If the shakes had been old, they probably would have been shredded) The guy with the skip sheeting has had so many leak problems that this summer he had a new composition roof put one, over solid decking of course. I don't know about anywhere else but here in Kansas we save a bundle on insurance when we replace cedar shakes or shingles with composition roofing. Really cuts down on the silverfish roaches and the brown recluse spiders that feed on them too.

BTW, if anyone cares, cedar shakes and cedar shingle are different and have different installation requirements.

Jerry

Re: Cedar roofs

#6

Tony/Jerry....

Barry Irby

I saw the TOH show with the mesh. I wondered if it would work, but have no evidence either way.

Interesting about the hail damage. Not sure any roof is designed to withstand baseball sized hail.

Another difference in the skip sheeting and solid decking is that the solid deck serves and a back stop. On skip sheeting the shingles are subject to wind driven rain penetrating. With the solid decking the shingles are basically a wind screen and any rain that blows through is stopped by the decking or hopefully the felt on the deck and drains out from underneath without leaking into the house. (There are many uses for the wind screen effect. Vinyl siding is a wind screen) The difference is that shakes on solid decking appear to be nearly 100% leak proof, even in high winds. (The joke is that its really a tar paper roof and the shakes are decorative and hold the tar paper on.)

The price you pay for the improved resistance to leaks is it cuts the life of the roofing in half.

The 100% leak proof roof is a fairly new concept. If a howling wind blew a cup of water through your Grandmother's shake or slate roof, staining the ceiling, her response might have been, "we need to paint the ceiling". Today we think of roofs as binary, they either leak or they don't. The current response might be, I need a new roof, even though it does not leak 99.9% of the time its raining.

I like the appearance of a shake roof, but I am not a fan. They cost twice as much as an asphalt shingle roof, don't last as long, and are also a fire hazard.

Another common installation error on shake is the bottom course. They use shingle for the starter course.They are thin and short compared to shakes. At the top of the slots in the first course of shakes, the starter shingles are probably less that 1/8" thick. All the water from the roof runs over them, and they erode away. There are seldom two courses of starter shingles as there should be. I have seen many roofs where the starters and the felt has completely worn through and water is leaking into the soffit. I am not a fan of shake roofs.

Re: Cedar roofs

#7

Hail

John in NM

About the only thing that will stand up to big hail well is a metal roof. It will dent, but you will have no leaks.

What gets me is that after we had a midwest style hail storm here last summer, all these people got their steel roofs replaced due to "hail damage" - ie dents. I'm surprised that the insurance adjusters were dumb enough to fall for that - I guess they figure what is good for cars is good for houses, but man, talk about a shallow society. I would prefer to get a discount on my insurance for the steel roof and no replacement for cosmetic damage - good for the insurer, good for me, and bad for the shallow idiots.

Out here you never see shake roofs. An old friend who was a USFS firefighter for many years once told me they didn't even try to save structures with shake roofs - just a waste of time and energy. Structures with a steel roof got some attention if they had the resources for it.

Don't they make a tile product now that imitates cedar?