Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Tree ID help

Posts

Tree ID help

#1

Tree ID help

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Hello all.

Can somebody please ID these two large trees for me? There were in Blacksburg, VA.

TIA!

Tree #1

The Bark


Limbs


Leaves 1


Leaves 2


Tree #2




Re: Tree ID help

#2

Re: Tree ID help

John Veerkamp

First tree looks like Osage Orange to me. Not a native to your location, but in former years sometimes planted as a specimen tree.

Re: Tree ID help

#3

Re: Tree ID help

Curt Stivison

I agree with osage on first tree

Re: Tree ID help

#5

Re: Tree ID help

Keith Newton

Number 1 looks like Bois d'Arc, aka Osage Orange, Hedge Apple. Maybe male if there are no fruit.

The second may be Linden, but I'm not sure.

Re: Tree ID help

#6

Re: Tree ID help

Yonak

#2 might be basswood

Re: Tree ID help

#7

Re: Tree ID help-LeafSnap *LINK*

Tom Dunlap

Download this app.

Then, take a leaf, place it on a white/light background and Leaf Snap will help narrow your guesses.


LeafSnap

Re: Tree ID help

#8

Dale Lenz

Re: Tree ID help

Dale Lenz

First tree has the orange bark, twigs should have some thorns. Osage orange.

Second tree is a mulberry.

Re: Tree ID help

#9

Re: Tree ID help

William Duffield

The second tree is Tilia americana, the American linden or American basswood. I have a few growing on my property, and the next door neighbor's (that I can see from here) drops those seeds on us all summer.

I agree with the others' ID of Maclura pomifera. Right now, I happen to have several of the fruit, or "hedge apples," lying around on my back porch.

Re: Tree ID help

#10

Re: Tree ID help

William Duffield

I just realized, from your post on the other thread (where I also offered an Osage Orange anecdote), that your photos are very recent. Therefore, the tree you photographed is a male (or there's someone on the staff with OCD). Otherwise, its distinctive hedge apples would have been all over the ground around it, and it would have been even easier to identify.

I haven't gotten all the way down to Blacksburg, but when you next travel that way, Thomas Jefferson's Poplar Forest, near Lynchburg, is well worth a side trip, especially if you are interested in American architecture and architectural restorations.

Re: Tree ID help

#11

Dale Lenz

I was wrong...

Dale Lenz

will go with the basswood for the second tree.

Re: Tree ID help

#12

Re: I was wrong...

William Duffield

One way to narrow down your choice for mulberries, at least for the red mulberries that are have been growing in this area since Colonial times, is that they often have leaves that are in three different shapes, with one, two or three lobes, analogous to the sassafras, but with serrated margins.

The alder/cottonwood/linden group are also very difficult to differentiate, especially from just the leaf shape. I was just out taking a walk, and happened to notice another linden down the street. It had some suckers growing up from the base, and I was surprised to see that the leaves on the suckers were about four times the area of the typical leaves.

If you have an iPad, you might find this app useful:

http://leafsnap.com/

I tend to rely on Zim and Sibley for field identification, and on Hoadley for wood (real books, made from real trees :D ) when I'm in the shop.

I got stumped this weekend, by a sample of peach wood. I've seen (and worked) lots of apple, pear, cherry and plum, but the colors of the peach were much more vibrant, more like tulipwood (Dalbergia decipularis) than the other fruitwoods (Prunus, Malus, Pyrus, etc.) I'm familiar with. With all the peaches they grow around here,

http://www.sunnyslope.com

I realize I need to pay more attention the next time they are culling old trees. I've rescued apple firewood from another local nursery and turned it into tool handles.

Re: Tree ID help

#13

Re: Tree ID help

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Thanks for all the info.

I should have known Osage Orange and Basswood/Linden.

Thank you.

Re: Tree ID help

#14

Re: Tree ID help

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Thank you for the additional info re: Poplar Forest. It's on my list now.

Re: Tree ID help

#15

Re: Tree ID help

William Duffield

You took some great photos for identification. I think we all learned something from the thread, even the hundreds of "lurkers" who read it without comment. The discussion should help anybody here the next time they are confronted with one of these being taken out. They're both very valuable hardwoods for the right woodworker, although their working characteristics and applications are completely different.

The more people who learn more about tree identification, the better chance we have of putting the wood to use (the tree's "second life" as some people call it) and saving it from the chipper of firewood pile. And we slow down global warming just a little bit.

Re: Tree ID help

#16

I'll be bummed all day for missing this. *LINK*

Keith Newton

My friend Steve who keeps the grounds at Mt Holly Cemetery had told me a few months ago that the General Nelson tree was dying and coming down soon, and that I could have it. I got the call around noon yesterday that they were working on it.

I got over with my trailer, and tried making friends with the tree service owner, and letting him know that I really wanted some of that tree. His answers were always vague. As long as I stay out of his way, and didn't slow them down. This was fine, except everything he took down either went right under the guys working above, or straight into his big dump-truck.

That long straight trunk had about 1' hollow down the middle, with a hard black line, then good solid wood out from there. This is exactly how I wanted it, which would make it easy for me to chainsaw rip manageable size billets to go onto my Woodmizer, then turn the whole tree into wonderful wide QS lumber. However, he was unwilling to take over a 4' length off at a time.

Even after it was down to where he could have dropped a 10' length into the lane, he wouldn't even do that. By then, I had to just get away, I thought I was going to barf, it was so sickening. I woke up mad, and need to get busy so I can forget about it.


https://www.flickr.com/photos/7391658@N03/15427908485/in/set-72157647907549860