Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Basic lumber questions

Posts

Basic lumber questions

#1

Basic lumber questions

Colin Cannell

Hello, I'm new here. I had a sycamore fall on my property last year. On the advice of a local woodworker, I left it to spalt. The logs went to the mill last week.

So I'm about to be the proud owner of several hundred bf of spalted sycamore, despite the fact that I really do not know what I'm doing. I have no background in woodworking or lumber sales or decorative arts or anything. It just seemed like a fun project.

My first question to the board is, should I have these kiln dried?

The main argument in favor of it is that I need to sell most of the wood in the next nine months. In theory, KD wood should have a convenience factor that would make it more valuable and/or sell faster.

The arguments against it are that (a) many woodworkers prefer air-drying or drying to their own specs, so if you're selling decorative wood then KD is a waste of time, and (b) KD wood needs to be stored in climate-controlled conditions and I don't exactly have a warehouse sitting around.

What do you guys think? Should I kiln-dry all of it? None of it? Pick a few pieces that meet certain criteria?

Thanks for your help. Here's a pic of some of the wood.


Re: Basic lumber questions

#2

good luck

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The market for sycamore is what we call "thin" and partially decayed sycamore even thinner.

Spalted wood seems to be most popular with turners. They have their own ideas of what sizes and shapes are required for their products. Big chunks for bowls are a popular size.

To deal with your questions specifically:

On the advice of a local woodworker, I left it to spalt......I would try to sell the logs to this person who provided this dubious advice.

The logs went to the mill last week.....If they have not been sawed, STOP. Don't saw until you have identified a market.

It just seemed like a fun project....that it will be

My first question to the board is, should I have these kiln dried?....No, don't dry until you have identified a market. No point in wasting money drying until you know you can sell the dried lumber. The lumber will last forever in an air dried state, so the drying decision can be postponed.

The main argument in favor of it is that I need to sell most of the wood in the next nine months.....good luck. We were in the lumbr business for 30+ years and I would not have been able to sell 100 bd ft of sycamore in all that time.

In theory, KD wood should have a convenience factor that would make it more valuable and/or sell faster....true if it was some wood that had a wider market. If it was something typically used like oak it would be easier to sell KD.

The arguments against it are that (a) many woodworkers prefer air-drying or drying to their own specs.....actually very few prefer air dried wood.

KD wood needs to be stored in climate-controlled conditions ....not true. Most KD wood is stored in sheds

Re: Basic lumber questions

#3

PS Testing the market

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

See what the sawyer would be willing to pay for the logs. Presumably the sawyer is knowledgeable about the local market for spalted sycamore. His reaction will give you some idea of what the wood is worth. Let us know how it all works out.

Re: Basic lumber questions

#4

Re: good luck

Colin Cannell

Hi Bill

Thanks for your insights. Perhaps the market is different here in PA. Certainly I wouldn't try to market this wood for anything structural due to the intentional decay. However, "functional art" pieces such as tables and boxes made with spalted sycamore seem to sell rather well around here based on my research.

Time will tell, I suppose! I'll keep you posted.

Re: Basic lumber questions

#5

Re: PS Testing the market

Colin Cannell

Yes, the sawyer seemed quite positive about it and said he would send pics of the results to his regular buyers.

Re: Basic lumber questions

#6

Re: good luck

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Where in PA are you? I may be interested in some.

Re: Basic lumber questions

#7

Re: good luck

Colin Cannell

I'm in Allentown and the wood is currently down in Doylestown, so pretty close to you.

Re: Basic lumber questions

#8

Contact

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

email your contact info please

Re: Basic lumber questions

#9

Re: PS Testing the market

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If you want to get an inkling of how much your lumber will be worth the question to ask is not how excited the sawyer is to get paid for sawing a log but rather how much he would be willing to pay for the logs.

Re: Basic lumber questions

#10

Once it is sawn, if you do

Keith Newton

I would think it would be a good idea to KD it, due to the insects which I'm sure are already in there. Sycamore is like candy to them.

Re: Basic lumber questions

#11

Quarter sawn sycamore is the best

Dick Coers

You get amazing fleck patterns if it's not already cut.

Re: Basic lumber questions

#12

Re: Quarter sawn sycamore is the best

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

It's cut.

Re: Basic lumber questions

#13

Re: Quarter sawn sycamore is the best

Colin Cannell

Yes, it's mostly or all been quarter-sawn, I think. Here are some pics I just got.








Re: Basic lumber questions

#14

Quarter sawning

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Quarter sawed is a sawing strategy to yield mostly lumber with a quartered grain orientation. If there is bark on both edges of the boards the log was not quarter sawed, but that does not mean that there will be no quartered grain orientation in some or part of some boards.

If sawed on a portable band mill, a common sawing procedure is to just start on one side of the log and keep sawing boards till you get to the other side. This strategy will yield boards with bark edges on every board, until and if they are are edged to remove the bark edge. The board that is sawed from the middle of the log will be 100% quartered grain orientation. It will also have the pith and likely split its length as it dries (however, sycamore resists splitting so maybe it won't). The remainder will be rift cut, progressing to flat cut as you get closer to the log outside.

In my limited experience sawing sycamore it appeared to me that to get the flakes the radial rays had to be almost exactly parallel to the board face. Rift cut had no flake showing.

There was a furniture parts manufacturer nearby. They bought sycamore lumber and turned stair balusters from it. That is the only commercial use I have seen for it. Don't know why it is not used in places where poplar is used, but it isn't. It makes long, straight trees when grown crowded with neighbors, especially in a grove of poplar. The wood is light weight and light color with a plain grain. It turns well but I have never made anything flat from it. But it must have some disadvantage for it gets left in the woods by the loggers in these parts, unless they are harvesting pulp wood.

Re: Basic lumber questions

#15

Re:  Quarter sawning

Colin Cannell

Thanks for the clarification, Bill. I went down to the mill yesterday to look at things. The logs that were largest and in the best shape were sawn through, with varying quartering on the successive sections. One of these is going in the kiln and we expect some degree of splitting on the weaker sections. Logs that were rotted through the middle or otherwise damaged were cut up and quarter-sawn on the best parts to yield smaller lumber.

I think we got some good saleable material out of it and I will post again in a few weeks once everything is stored away and cataloged. Total for sale will be about 700 bf, mostly in 10/4.

Re: Basic lumber questions

#16

Re:  Quarter sawning

William Duffield

The folklore on Sycamore is that it is very unstable and will warp during drying and move a lot with the change in seasons. I've heard the advise to "tie it down, otherwise it'll get up and walk away." :D I haven't worked with it, so I don't know., but if true, then the more practical advise I've seen is to use the radially sawn wood for panels, where the ray fleck is shown to its best advantage, but make the frames from something else, to hold the panels flat. Of course, radial sawing is an immense amount of work and wasteful of a lot of wood.

Another name for sycamore is buttonwood. If you were going to make it into buttons, you would avoid most of your problems with wood movement. :D

Re: Basic lumber questions

#17

Re:  Quarter sawning

Dick Coers

I've heard the same thing about movement during drying on flat sawn stock. I was given maybe 150 board feet of nearly ruined quarter sawn sycamore. Maybe it was run through the kiln too quickly, or the log was a bad one, but it came from the kiln filled with long splits. With lots of strategic cutting, I've gotten a lot of stock for tops and bottoms of bent wood shaker boxes. The wood owner was sick when he saw the result from the kiln. All he got was "we're sorry, nothing else we could have done" from the kiln operator.