Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Off topic: residential water supply pipe choices

Posts

Off topic: residential water supply pipe choices

#1

Off topic: residential water supply pipe choices

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

The ancient - maybe a century old - galvanized water pipes that run from the water meter to our crawlspace are failing. I spent a happy half hour yesterday applying a patch to a 1/2" long crack in a pipe that was delaminating to much less than factory diameter.

So it's going to be time for that unpleasant job. Our city allows the use of copper, galvanized pipe, or PVC (which last I would never use: the local gophers apparently like the taste), as well as exotics like brass. I'm weighing galvy vs. copper. People tend to describe copper as longer-lasting, but our son comments that he's gone out to do urgent repairs on a lot more copper than gavanized (although this may also reflect how much of it is installed).

Neither our water nor our soil is particularly acidic, so it may come down to installation cost and convenience, and projected life. I'd be interested in experiences with these materials, and other useful comments. And if anyone would like to visit California and have free room and board in exchange for a plumbing job...no, actually our son and I will probably do the work, with help on the trenching.

Re: Off topic: residential water supply pipe choices

#2

Re: Off topic: residential water supply pipe choic

Joseph Mulherin, sr

retired plumber here....use the copper

Re: Off topic: residential water supply pipe choices

#3

Re: Off topic: It costs money... Because it ...

TomD

saves money.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BEmKe6KxhcM

Re: Off topic: residential water supply pipe choices

#4

Re: Off topic: residential water supply pipe choic

Tony - Memphis

Interesting. I can't offer any help, but everything here is copper and we've had no issues over the last 16 years. I have the impression our plumbers were the low bid, so I assume the material must be code and must be good enough that even THEY couldn't mess it up! No gophers here. The ground is pure red TN clay. We've had isues with PVS waste pipe, so I wouldn't use that either. The copper they use here is in a roll and is one solid run to the house (code?). Too bad the sewer line was not (long story - involved lots of shoveling!).

Saw them replace a line on TOH the other day. It was pretty interesting how they did it at the street (literally in the middle of the street).

Tony

Re: Off topic: residential water supply pipe choices

#5

Bart Goldberg

Re: Off topic: residential water supply pipe choic

Bart Goldberg

Are you allowed to use PEX? Seems like its being used fairly widely nowadays. Of course, copper is the gold standard from what I know, but PEX is EASY to install.

Bart

Re: Off topic: residential water supply pipe choices

#6

Re: Off topic: residential water supply pipe choic

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

My contractor son's been trained on PEX. He's been seeing mouse-chewed tubing, and said he's gone back to recommending copper for any installation in which rodents can get to the plumbing. Gophers qualify.

Re: Off topic: residential water supply pipe choices

#7

Re: Off topic: residential water supply pipe choic

Joseph Mulherin, sr

That's true, but remember the gophers....they might like the PEX too.

When I was a youngster I ran copper water lines across under the streets using a tool that oscillated back and forth and pulled the copper thru from the valve on the main to where the meter was to be located for the residence.

Re: Off topic: residential water supply pipe choices

#8

Re: Off topic: residential water supply pipe choic

Joseph Mulherin, sr

Bill, check with a rental company to see if they might have one of those oscillating machines for water line installation...would save a lot of digging.

Re: Off topic: residential water supply pipe choices

#9

Ditto

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Either Type K for sweat or full high pressure with threaded fittings.

I take CA doesn't allow ABS which is norm in my area.

PVC undergound? Not here, ever.

Re: Off topic: residential water supply pipe choices

#10

Re: Off topic: residential water supply pipe choic

TomD

I would run copper, it is reputedly safer, and I know I would consider anything else a demerit in living in or buying a house. I can't say that I really know whether it is safer, but plastic never fails to disappoint. I really like Pex, but it doesn't come between the city water and where we get our drinking water. It is great anywhere else in the house, I can make the fittings for special applications and insert them in seconds. I love the stuff.

Re: Off topic: residential water supply pipe choices

#11

Agree with copper

Larry Rupprecht

Location is SE MN. We replaced our 94 year-old galvanized 1" line from the street during a remodel with coiled copper. The galvanized pipe had deteriorated on the outside from whatever is in the soil and the inside was reduced to less than 1/4 inch diameter from mineral build-up. Backhoe operator was only able to salvage a few pieces that didn't crumble to flakes when he uncovered the original line. The clay soil around the line was almost a "perfect" band-aid until it was disturbed.

Inside the house, much of the original galvanized 1/2" lines had been replaced by copper in a 50 years ago remodel and those copper lines were still OK but the remaining original galvanized lines were almost down to zero flow from mineral buildup.

Building inspector also recommended copper underground over any other options for durability and total life. We used PEX exclusively inside the house.

Your mileage may vary with the chemistry of your soil and water.

Installer can push flexible copper almost anywhere it needs to go. In our case, that was about 45 feet under the basement floor. Think he missed the target by around 2 inches.

Re: Off topic: residential water supply pipe choices

#12

Just remember

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

If your copper goes through a concrete wall, be sure to insulate the copper from contact with the cement with a piece of PVC or polyethylene pipe. Copper in concrete will corrode very quickly, particularly fresh concrete where you patch the hole. My SIL had to replace the copper lines in her house that were embedded in the concrete floor due to corrosion.

Lee

Re: Off topic: residential water supply pipe choices

#13

Another consideration.....

Barry Irby

Locally most incoming water lines are Polyethylene. The black variety, some of it high density and most of it has a designation on it like CFC or some such thing for Copper fitting compatible. Unlike PEX (Polyethylene Cross linked) it is suitable for cold water only. Apparently our local varmints are not a problem.

Copper would be an excellent choice unless your local water chemistry is not compatible, but if you are on municipal water that should not be a problem. Soil chemistry might be an issue, but I doubt it. Copper on well water will impart a taste to the water. (I know that from personal experience.) The taste also indicates the water is slowly destroying the pipes.

Based on cost, I would choose Poly, but with your local gopher problem I would choose Copper because even if the pipe costs ten times a much, I don't want to dig it up again. It will outlive you.

The other consideration? Locally many older houses are grounded electrically through the bond to the incoming metal water line. If you replace the water line with a plastic one you lose the ground. You would have to drive new ground rod or rods and install a ground and be sure the bond wire now grounds the metal interior pipes. The situation reverses. The metal water pipe was grounding the electrical system, now the electrical system grounds the plumbing.

Re: Off topic: residential water supply pipe choices

#14

Re: Just remember

Tony - Memphis

Yup... All of our pipes are jacketed at least where they come up through the foundation. All connections are made above the slab too. Behind the vanity in the master batch looks like a tangled mess of copper pipes - two sinks, bathtub, shower, and a toilet - all fed from that line coming through the slab. Fortunately, it all works very well! I don't know what the sleeves are made of. It is a pretty thin material and there was read and blue as I recall. Reminds me of my parent's house - they had no hot water to their kitchen island and the neighbor had hot water in his toilet! Oops.

Tony

Re: Off topic: residential water supply pipe choices

#15

Hot to toilet is not necessarily a mistake.

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

My parents built a home back in the 70s and the plumber ran hot water to the master bath toilet on purpose to prevent the tank and bowl from sweating in humid weather and dripping on the carpeted floor. The tepid water was not cold enough to cause the humid air to condense on the surface.

Re: Off topic: residential water supply pipe choices

#16

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Another consideration.....

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

My 25 year old house has a 1" flexible plastic line from the street thru the foundation, and up to the meter. It's a 137 foot run, presumably all one piece. Once inside, it's joined to ¾" copper the rest of the runs.

On another note: At a previous house I owned - in SoCal - we replaced the galvanized water line coming into the house from the street with plastic. Before the inspector would sign off on it, he required installation of a (8') grounding rod to ensure we hadn't compromised the electrical.

My current house also has a grounding rod installed, btw.

Re: Off topic: residential water supply pipe choices

#17

Re: Just installed a new one

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

My main started leaking after at least 60-70 years of use, may have been even older (house built in the 1880's). I did contracting and plumbing as a side job and held a Indiana Contractor Plumbing license for a few years before retiring. To my mind none of the plastics have a "proven" life near that of Copper. As the trenching / installation cost exceeded $2,000, I considered the additional cost of copper vs plastic a minor. I installed 1" Type K copper (Type K is heavy wall). To protect the copper from stones in the soil I had it installed inside 1 1/2" ABS flexible tubing.

I had this installed last month, length from meter to shutoff was about 94 foot. It was laid at 41 to 48" depth. I purchased all the material myself and contracted out the trenching and pipe laying. The cost of the copper was between $500 and $600 for a 100' roll. The ABS was around $60. However the fittings required for the connection and shutoff were also nearly $100.

Re: Off topic: residential water supply pipe choices

#18

Re: Just installed a new one

Jerry Roberts

Im no expert by any means but I just had my house repiped about 2 years ago. Me, and just abt everyone in my neighborhood with houses abt30-40 years old have done the same .We all had copper pipe. I had at least 5 leaks inside the drywall . The last one was behind the kitchen cabinets and I had to have all the bottom ones replaced.We have city water so I don't think the leaks derived from the type of water we use. I used pec(pex?) and had it run through the attic. I wont use copper again but its a little strange to me why almost everyone around had the same problem.I just saw on the news the other night a person used pex and his insurance was canceled because of it.It seems they have changed the type of connector used . Mine, and everyone else is glued. Just things to consider.

Re: Off topic: residential water supply pipe choices

#19

Re: Just installed a new one

Barry Irby

Jerry, I have never seen PEX with glued connectors. PEX Is polyethylene cross linked. Poly is very difficult to glue. Are you sure you don't have CPVC? Sort of cream or light tan plastic pipe? PEX generally uses compression rings or the newer system that briefly expands the pipe and lets it shrink onto the fitting.

Why did you run it in the attic? You on a slab? Piping in the attic in a cold climate is a disaster waiting for a cold spell. If you think what a leak in the wall did to the base cabinets was bad, wait until you see what an attic leak does. Hope they insulated it really well and covered it in insulation.

Re: Off topic: residential water supply pipe choices

#20

Re: Just installed a new one

Bill Howatt

Sounds like a bad production run of copper. My house is approaching 40 and about 6 months after it was built a single copper pipe developed a pin-hole leak. Supposedly there were other cases of this happening in new construction in the area as well. No problems with it since then. I think these cases are pretty rare given all the copper that has been installed over the years.

Bill

Re: Off topic: residential water supply pipe choices

#21

Re: Just installed a new one

Jerry Roberts

You know Barry, you are probally right. I just assumed it was glued. I really didn't see the installers put it together. As far as running it thru the attic, yes ,the houses around here are concrete block on a slab and in Florida we don't know what snow and ice is. All I know is, I really don't think Id use copper again with all the problems my neighbors have had with copper. Dont know for sure but maybe there are different grades of copper pipe. The TV show I mentioned , the connectors had some sort of black collar around the connector and I think they mentioned pek and his homeowners was cancelled.

Re: Off topic: residential water supply pipe choices

#22

Re: Just installed a new one

Barry Irby

Sorry, My mistake. I looked and saw Larry's address in Indiana. South Florida, OK, Indiana, not so much.

There have been cases of mismanufactured pipe failing in attics. Not a good thing.

I think your general copper pipe failure has to be either a local water quality issue, or a batch of mismanufactured copper pipe.