Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Moisture meters

Posts

Moisture meters

#1

Moisture meters

Randy Stukenberg

I'm thinking about getting a moisture meter, pin type. Are they mostly all about the same "accuracy" or do they vary quite a bit. I'm looking at the Ligno mini and Moisture Register DC-2000. Any experience? I just need to get a rough idea of the moisture content before I build something, not for drying lumber.

Thanks!

Re: Moisture meters

#2

Re: Moisture meters

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I got a "General" pin meter from Lowe's for $10 on sale. It won't read to the depth my $120 Electrophysics pinless will, but for 4-6/4 lumber and stuff it's just as accurate. I actually got 3 of them in case I forgot one at the yard.

Re: Moisture meters

#3

Save your money

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You are more likely to be misled, or fret needlessly if you use one than if you saved your money. If you are buying KD lumber you are already fretting needlessly.

We sold lumber for 30 + years with the greatest volume going into professional shops. I never saw a shop ever use a meter. And with good reason. If you are buying KD wood from a reliable supplier it will have been dried to 7%. If while sitting around it has come up a bit by the time you get something built the lumber will be equilibrated with the shop. Unless it got rained on KD lumber is ready for building even after prolonged storage under typical under cover conditions.

Factories worry about moisture content because lumber may go from the lumber pile to the finishing room in a shift with no time to adjust.

There are some special occasions where it is essential to know moisture content. In these cases there are cheaper, more accurate means to getting the result. Tell us what your need and I may make a recommendation for a cheaper, better, multitasking way. I like multitaskers, and a meter isn't one of them.

Re: Moisture meters

#4

Re: Moisture meters *LINK*

John in NM

Years ago I bought the one Lee Valley has (I see they now have a digital one too). It's worked fine for my purposes - checking that stuff has dried to >8% - out here it will air dry to below the 6% threshold of the meter, depending on the weather.

One trick I like that was suggested with the meter is to hammer a couple finish nails into a bit of the wood that won't be used and use those to get a deeper look. The only problem I've had with it is the pins are quite soft and bendy - using the nails keeps this from being a problem.

Since the digital ones seem to be quite cheap these days, I may add one of those as well - hard to beat the $10 on sale that Mark paid :D

Even at $22+ from Lee Valley, their LCD one could be handy, with settings for drywall %MC and temperature.


http://www.leevalley.com/us/wood/page.aspx?p=45788&cat=1,43513

Re: Moisture meters

#5

YaBut

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

If you're working with air dried lumber, a meter saves a whole lot of grief. If I have to buy framing lumber or treated lumber at the Borg, I take my cheapo meter to help sort through the stacks for the driest (e.i not dripping wet) stock that I might have a chance of its staying flat and straight in use. "Might" I say "M-I-G-H-T"; not "will". :D

Re: Moisture meters

#6

Re: Moisture meters

Dick Coers

I've had my Ligno mini forever, probably 25 years. Never failed me. I don't agree with Bill, I feel they are not a waste of money. I've boughten improperly dried white oak from a very good supplier. Anyone can make a mistake. It's nice to know what the numbers are when it seems to be moving a lot in your shop. Easier to talk to the dealer when you call with your information. I also take it to auctions that advertise kiln dried lumber. Many years ago, I learned a lot about wood from reading Jerry Metz's articles in Wood and Wood Products Magazine. Unless my memory fails me, pretty sure he advocated sticking every board that came into your shop.

Re: Moisture meters

#7

Re: Save your money

Randy Stukenberg

Thanks Bill. I'm not worried so much about KD lumber I get from the mills. I occasionally get lumber from customers for their project. I recently picked up some white oak that was wet on the surface when we got a few boards down on the stack. Since the cabinet is solid lumber, I want to know how wet the wood is before I start building so I can allow for movement. I also use a lot of firewood and would like to check it once in a while.

Re: Moisture meters

#8

Valid concern

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"I occasionally get lumber from customers for their project. " This is high risk lumber.

Unless meters have improved greatly the readings near working levels of moisture are not accurate, nor are they accurate when there is a moisture gradient. If I really want to know moisture content I use the Reference Method. Dry a test piece to constant weight at 220F. You will need a kitchen scale and kitchen oven. Weigh, dry until no further weight loss and get final weight. (Initial weight- final weight)/ final weight x100 equals moisture content. In 15 of drying you will have a good indication if the lumber is fit to use.

With experience you can tell if lumber is fit to use by how it feels and behaves when planed. To wet oak and walnut have an acidic smell. Shavings and sawdust will clump from any wood too wet to use. All lumber at 7% or less feels prickly but this feature is lost by 10%.

Re: Moisture meters

#9

Re: Moisture meters

del schisler

i also bought the $10.00 from lowe's , the same meter now at other supplyer's are up around $70 ,, and higher it doesn't mean that the higher price make a good meter , it give's me a a idea of the moisture in the wood, it may not be right but why are their so many out their?? i have one that i paid $250 a few yrs back and it is just give me a idea of the moisture, i have got wood right from the mill and than air dried and kilm dried , i like to have a idea , of course i guess you could cut a piece and weight it and than oven dry , that would take some time if you had lot's of wood , and by the time you done all of this the wood would get moisture back, all a moisture meter is a ohm meter with resistance across the 2 probe's, take a ohm merter and hold the 2 probe's in the hands and the meter needle will move up the scale , that is what the wood is doing . making a resistance so the meter will give a reading , i use mine all the time