Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Tabletop fastening question

Posts

Tabletop fastening question

#1

Tabletop fastening question

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I'm in the final throes of building a cherry trestle table for some friends. They provided a stack of rough lumber, unfortunately only 1" thick, so the final thickness of the top is 3/4".

My question is, are figure 8 fasteners strong enough to attach the top to the base, assuming the table will only occasionally be moved but likely by lifting from the top? The trestle base is about 40 pounds, and the solid top is 38" wide.

Thanks.

Re: Tabletop fastening question

#2

Re: Tabletop fastening question

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

Four of them are enough to hold the top on Steve Latta's bench-on-bench, and it gets thrown in the trunk of a car and hauled all over the place, and it gets a lot more abuse than most tables.

How many fasteners are you planning to use? In screwed down table tops with more meat in the aprons than the top, the limiting factor is the sum of the screw threads into the table top. The same number of buttons, or pocket holes wouldn't be any stronger. The figure 8 fasteners are very stiff because they have ridges, so bending of the fastener shouldn't be an issue. Something else will fail first.

Re: Tabletop fastening question

#3

Re: Tabletop fastening question

Barry Irby

I agree with William.

If you want to be even more sure, what I did on my last tables was to use the figure eights along the sides but then add two pocket screws about three inches apart centered on each end rail. And I glue about tree inches of the top to the end rail between the two screws.

Re: Tabletop fastening question

#4

Geez!  Belt, suspenders & drawstring!   


Re: Tabletop fastening question

#5

Re: Tabletop fastening question

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Thanks, Sir W. That's the reassurance I was looking for.

Bill T suggested that a picture of the table's underside might be useful, so herewith it is:


The maple 2 X 2s support an 18" extension on each end, and the middle support is merely to keep the supports from drooping. This whole project is made of glued-up cherry. My friends had this tree cut down and rough sawn some years ago, and unfortunately it was sawn at 1", so I didn't have a lot to work with. The legs and all dimension pieces are glued. I had suggested that we find some solid cherry of the right thickness but they wanted to use what they had. In the process I learned that air-dried cherry twists a bit, even though it was stickered and weighed down pretty well.

PS, the Krenov sawhorses came from Bill T's write-up some time ago.

Re: Tabletop fastening question

#6

Another thought

DizD

Can you sink the figure 8 fastner about 1/2" deep in the apron and then glue a small ( 2" square or so) 1/2" thick block to underside of top? This would give you an effective 1 1/2" table top thickness for screws.

Re: Tabletop fastening question

#7

Looking good Bruce

John in NM

Be sure to give us a pic or two when it's done - my wife is angling for a new table, and I'd like to show her what you are doing with the end leaves. I always liked trestle tables, wouldn't mind building another.

Re: Tabletop fastening question

#8

Re: Tabletop fastening question

don stephan

Having just re-read during lunch an old FWW article on tabletop fasteners, I'll pass along a detail. Figure 8's are somewhat limited in the amount of seasonal movement they can accomodate, because they are pivoting about the screws. I like buttons, but that is a personal preference. Clever suggestion to add glue blocks to underside of the tabletop.