I am concerned about Lexan scratching. I found a version of Lexan that costs about 40 percent more but has a surface coating that is said to resist scratching and harsh cleaning products.
Has anyone had any long term experience with this product?
Yes, it is worth the price, for objects need toughness, as in break proof, yet stand up to rough treatment which would otherwise scratch regular polycarbonate, which is pretty soft and easy to scratch.
I'm putting a piece of Lexan I'm front of the lower sash of a double hung window to prevent someone from breaking the glass if they fall against the window. The plan for it to be in place indefinity. That is why I am concerned about the coating failing after ten or so years.
me experience is that the coating doesn't fail, but I've nor done any real tests to confirm this. If there is not regular abrasion on the Lexan, there should be no worries.
Call your local glass suppliers for a price. i usually buy insulated units, even with tinting if that would help cut down on utility cost. i've done this enough through the years that Nita my sales rep calls me darlin.
As for the longevity of the Lexan, I would expect what they say to be true, but maybe better if not to exposed to much abuse. And I think there may be some polishing compound kits that you might use, but I think I would still go with the tempered glass, if it were me.
If you are making this up from scratch, there are suppliers where you can buy tempered glass in certain sizes cheaper than custom cuts.
Polycarbonate does have some other problems. Several years ago I replaced several "shields" used on machinery in the manufacturing plant where I worked thinking it would be better as far as impact resistance than the Acrylic we had been using. The acrylic had worked quite well except when it was impacted ~ then it would occasionally crack. The Lexan was also easier to work as it could be bent into shape on a brake. However a few weeks after installation the polycarbonate shields began cracking and failing. It was determined that the fumes from the chlorinated solvents we were using (several feet away) were causing the material to crack and craze at every stress point (areas where we had drilled and attached screws).
After thorough investigation I found that the polycarbonate has failure modes due to several common materials like ammonia (used in many window cleaners) and other household cleansers. At our plant we produced many TV switches and controls in the past. One of these was for the manufacturer of a polycarbonate. We commonly used nylon for a shaft extension of one of the off /on switches to make it a "double insulated product". This time the customer requirement was that we use Lexan. We produced many thousands of these switches. After a few months there was a massive recall due to the shaft extension breaking ~ it was determined the cause was the solvents used by consumers to clean the (then glass) screens and outside of their TV's. Lucky our company did not have to share the cost of the recall as the material was specified by our customer!
For your application I would certainly look at using heavier gage Acrylic with the anti scratch coating, it is very durable, although not as strong as Lexan, probably more than you would need for your application. The other option is the Tempered glass, although quite a lot more expensive.