Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Spice Box Jewelry box- Design

Posts

Spice Box Jewelry box- Design

#1

Spice Box Jewelry box- Design

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Spice box jewelry box

I will be building a Spice Box style jewelry box for granddaughters. Step one is design. I design on a drawing board or a sheet of graph paper where I can create a scaled drawing. It will be interesting to hear how others approach design of a woodworking project.

Design involves making decisions which quickly begin to rule out possibilities, as will be illustrated.

PIC 1

I built three boxes some years ago (see Woodcentral Jewelry Box Contest) and fortunately enough time has passed that I have forgotten the tedium of making all the tiny drawers. At the time I swore I would never make another.

The boxes I built then had the full complement of “secret” compartments including the drawer under its bonnet that is accessed from behind the case. The thickness of this drawer necessitates a tall molding on the case top. I was never fond of this feature and it will be discarded from the current design. I have become disillusioned with secret compartments and these boxes will have none. I think in most cases they become waster space. What are your thoughts on secret campartments?

Now that I can do Line and Berry decoration I want to decorate the door this way. The doors in many traditional boxes were one piece, while others were frame and panel. Some were highly figured while othres were decorated with inlay. A tomb stone door leads to a taller case, which can be desirable. I am not fond of tomb stone doors but I like the look of frame and panel. I have Griffith’s PhD thesis on Line and Berry decoration. She has figures for every pattern she found in her studies. Additional patterns can be found by searching Google and Explorer “Images”. The typical geometric pattern is developed with a compass and elements of a circle. A pattern involving elements of a circle means the pattern will fit in a circle which in turn means that at least the pattern, if not the door, must be a square. So the Line and Berry pattern is where we begin the design of the spice box. A traditional sized spice box is too big to attractively sit on a dresser so I need to come up with an attractive design that will be about 12” x 12” plus its feet.

PIC 2

The next step is to get out the drawing board and drafting tools. Many spice boxes have decoration that strikes me as showing off and results in a busy pattern. I experimented with less busy patterns with some examples shown in PIC 2 and finally settled on a pattern different from any I have seen used before. Then it was a simple matter of building(drawing) a door frame around this pattern and a box to house the frame. I diddled with the door frame width, and the molding and feet sizes, until they looked right. To my design challenged eye I have found that if it looks right in a scaled drawing it will look the same when built.

PIC 3

This design has one significant departure from a traditional spice box. To get the hinges out of the way of the interior drawers a traditional spice box is hinged from the outside of the case. As a result the case side shows on the lock side but not the hinge side (see PIC 1). Surprisingly this asymmetry looks ok. For this design I will set the door in a rabbit in the case side which will keep the hinge barrel from interfering with the drawers and leave the door framed by the case on both sides. I need to mock up this idea to see if there are flaws I have failed to detect.

PIC 4

Finally the interior arrangement of the drawers is worked out. Again, this arrangement is not traditional, but then neither is the size of this box. The box will be dovetailed together and bracket feet added in a traditional fashion.

Next I will dimension the drawing and make a cut list for parts

Re: Spice Box Jewelry box- Design

#2

Re: Spice Box Jewelry box- Design

Merle Clor

Bill, I personally would add a secret compartment just because I think they are neat whether they are used or not. However, that is strictly personal preference so there is no right or wrong. Like you, I design with graph paper and a pencil. I have never been able to make friends with SketchUp; just a deficiency on my part. :(

Finally, to my eye your design looks a little too short and squatty. Here is a link to one that is a little taller than it is wide and I find it to be aesthetically pleasing. It may be a bit overdone in terms of the decorative elements, but the dimensions work for me.

Please bear in mind that I have never made one of these, so take my comments for what they are worth. :D

https://www.google.com/search?site=&tbm=isch&source=hp&biw=1366&bih=667&q=spice+box&oq=spice+b&gs_l=img.1.3.0l10.1452.5083.0.9252.7.7.0.0.0.0.252.690.0j1j2.3.0....0...1ac.1.53.img..4.3.688.gm-bteRRUqg&gws_rd=ssl#facrc=_&imgdii=_&imgrc=CJ8VgNQ6Z8yv6M%253A%3BMUn5i_fhVahriM%3Bhttp%253A%252F%252Fwww.inlaybanding.com%252Fimages%252FLine%252520%2526%252520Berry%252520Spice%252520Box.jpg%3Bhttp%253A%252F%252Fwww.inlaybanding.com%252Flonnie_sbc.html%3B321%3B480

Re: Spice Box Jewelry box- Design

#3

Re: Spice Box Jewelry box- Design

Rick Snyder

Bill,

Your spice box builds have inspired me to build some (2). I will be starting my third one later this year. Your line and berry d (hope it works out). Where do you buy your stringing, or do you make your own.

Thanks,

Rick

Re: Spice Box Jewelry box- Design

#4

reply

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Finally, to my eye your design looks a little too short and squatty"

I agree. To make it taller would mean making the circular decoration on the door asymmetrical. That in itself is not a show stopper for the eye is likely to be more influenced by the case shape than the decoration on the door.

We would both find a box about 2" taller more appealing. This is enough taller to add another rank of drawers, but with a box 6 drawers high the symmetry about the middle tall drawers is lost. Staying with a rank of 5 would make the drawers inconveniently deep for jewelry, with the benefit of a taller box.

As I stated, fixing one design element has effects everywhere else. I am going to draw up an interior 5 drawers high and taller drawers and see how it looks, but I suspect squat will be the choice.

Re: Spice Box Jewelry box- Design

#5

Buy Steve Latta DVD

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Do what he does. It is unlikely you can buy string that will exactly fit your tools.