Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Cause of nail pops in 20 year old ceiling?

Posts

Cause of nail pops in 20 year old ceiling?

#1

Bart Goldberg

Cause of nail pops in 20 year old ceiling?

Bart Goldberg

I'm starting to see nail pops in the vaulted ceiling of my family room. My house is 20 years old, and I had the roof replaced about 2 months ago. Are the nail pops that are now showing the result of the stress to the ceiling joists from the roof being replaced, or is it possible that its due to a poorly installed ridge vent by the roofers, or both?

Thanks in advance

Bart

Re: Cause of nail pops in 20 year old ceiling?

#2

Re: Cause of nail pops in 20 year old ceiling?

waroland

Nail pop usually mean that the drywall was not pulled up tight to the joist and after time the drywall moves flush leaving the head of the nail in place and bulges the drywall finish and drywall compound that was put over the nail. That was my experience in my last stick house. I am now a full time RVer with no drywall.

Re: Cause of nail pops in 20 year old ceiling?

#3

Bart Goldberg

Re: Cause of nail pops in 20 year old ceiling?

Bart Goldberg

Sure - I get that - but I am not sure that would be the case after 20 years. I am more suspecting the vibration caused by the roofers.

Re: Cause of nail pops in 20 year old ceiling?

#4

My Understanding

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Is based on wet wood in the framing. If the structure is framed with wet wood, especially "green" stock, and the rock is nailed, the wood will tend to push the nails out as it dries in place. Screws won't do that, but you'll get the "undulating wall effect" either way.

Remedy is to a) reset and compound the nails or b) pull them out and replace with a screw nearby the old hole, then compound and paint.

I had the same issue in my home not far from you. Once done (or re-done) the walls have stayed flat.

Re: Cause of nail pops in 20 year old ceiling?

#5

Bart Goldberg

Re: My Understanding

Bart Goldberg

Mark, the green wood effect would not be a cause after 20 years tho I would assume.

Re: Cause of nail pops in 20 year old ceiling?

#6

Re: Cause of nail pops in 20 year old ceiling?

Barry Irby

As a Home Inspector I see nail pops often. The cause mentioned above is a common one. Gluing the drywall helps. If nothing else, the glue bridges the gap, preventing the drywall and framing from moving in relation to each other. In other words, they move together and you don't get the little bulges/pops.

Another cause was using smooth shank nails that were too long. As the lumber shrinks and swells with seasonal changes in moisture content, it "squirts" the nails back out. The cure has been to use ring shank nails that are shorter. Screws and glue were an advancement on that.

I think you are right about the roofing. I routinely tell people that want to install an attic floor that they should not nail the flooring to the joists, but should use screws to avoid pounding. The pounding will shake the ceiling below loose.

Many of the roofs I walk on are amazingly flexible, almost tent-like. If these are supported by rafters only that do not have drywall attached underneath there is no harm, but there could be damage to the drywall. The walking around, throwing down 80 pound bundles of shingles and even firing nail guns and the hammering seem like likely causes.

Re: Cause of nail pops in 20 year old ceiling?

#7

Clint Searl

Wood never sleeps


Re: Cause of nail pops in 20 year old ceiling?

#8

Re: Cause of nail pops in 20 year old ceiling?

Keith Newton

Yes, I would think the roofers are the cause. Most if not all roofers that I've ever watched, and there have been plenty, are not delicate sensitive individuals. If one of the helpers that bring the bundles up tossed down a bundle out in the middle of the span of one rafter, it would very likely flex down, pulling the rock away from the ones on either side setting the fastener head deeper, loosening those.

But probably the joist taking the blow, would also have a quicker spring-back than the drywall attached to it, so it would stand a good chance of being shaken loose too. I'm not sure why you didn't notice it sooner though. have you had any strong storms since then, this might explain the delay.

Re: Cause of nail pops in 20 year old ceiling?

#9

Re: An easy fix...

TomD

It could be the roofers, particularly if it happened really near the same time they were there, but that still begs the question what it was about the roof that made it incapable of being roofed again, which is a standard part of being a roof. It is tempting to blame the roofers, but you can be dealing with a coincidence rather than a cause. I remember reading about how root canals can cause the onset of serious diseases, like cancer, and heart disease. Apparently this is taken seriously enough in some countries to make the procedure less common than it is here. But when you think of the age at which people are most likely to encounter a root canal... same thing with re-roofing normally not something for new roofs. If they were understructured, or not cleanly framed, too few fasteners were used, the drywall was undersized...

My solution to deal with existing nail pops is to remove the nail, or leave it in pace and drill a small adjacent hole. Squirt in expanding foam, when that hardens you redrive the nail or screw. I did this cure on a semi fallen ceiling in my house that had occurred due to a roof leak. Expanding foam is adhesive as well as a solid gap filler, it dealt with 1 inch gaps with no difficulty.

Ring shank nails are every bit as good as screws, and as far as I know are not implicated in more nail pops. Maybe the same is true of plain nails. The pops in new construction occur not because the nails pull out, but because the wood shrinks back. Where than not the case, longer nails would not be larger cause of the problem. I could see a screw having a better grip to stop that happening, but the loads are enormous and the screws are normally fairly fragile, and the drywall even moreso. One thing that is implicated in nail pops is using a regular hammer for pounding in the nails.

Re: Cause of nail pops in 20 year old ceiling?

#10

Ditto

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

reset nails and been good for 20 years.