Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Can feet know difference between cement and wood?

Posts

Can feet know difference between cement and wood?

#1

Can feet know difference between cement and wood?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It is common for shop owners to install a wood floor, or at least dream of installing a wood floor, with the assumption that wood is easier on the feet. Is there any engineering basis for believing one's foot separated from a floor by a sock, foot bed and sole of a shoe can detect a difference in rigidity of wood vs cement, tile or diamond? Is it possible that either material is compressed a detectable amount by the few psi exerted by a shoe? And if the floor material is not compressed a detectable amount then how could one material actually be better than another with regard to foot fatigue? I am not denying a psychological difference, but is there any data from double blind testing to support the claim or engineering data to make it plausible?

Re: Can feet know difference between cement and wood?

#2

Re: Can feet know difference between cement and wo

Bill Howatt

Good question but I think it is indeed more than psychological since the medical profession says it is a real problem for people who need to stand for long periods on concrete floors.

I wonder if the issue isn't the wood surface itself but the fact that what the wood is supported on yields a bit. In other words, if all the wood flooring was directly and rigidly fastened to the concrete would it make much difference?

You don't have ask a dropped water glass which surface it would sooner land on when dropped.

Bill

Re: Can feet know difference between cement and wood?

#3

I think the theory is...

John in NM

That the spring of wood between joists tends to exercise muscles in the feet. It would obviously need to depend on the thickness of the wood - 3/4" hardwood over 1" sheathing wouldn't have as much spring as just 3/4" plywood.

Whether there is anything to it or not is beyond me. I do know my back aches less after a night on a moderately uncomfortable bed - all that tossing and turning is good exercise :D

Re: Can feet know difference between cement and wood?

#4

Re: Can feet know difference between cement and wo

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Piqued my curiosity Bill, so I searched the net - as I am sure you did - and found no "blind studies". However I did find a bit of info obtained from workers that were transitioning from wooden block floors to concrete. http://ehstoday.com/ppe/foot-protection/ehs_imp_36713

I think the issue is that although fatigue is often cited (as I observed from about 40 years of walking on concrete on my job) it is subjective and typically a person doesn't really have an accurate comparison, IE: those of us that did work on concrete in a factory didn't have equal time on a different substrate. Empirical data does suggest that damage does occur to persons bodies that do continuously work on concrete, I had to have my hips replaced in my late 50's and had several co-workers with knee, hip and back problems - far more than my friends that worked in jobs that didn't require long hours on concrete.

One of the problems that I see obtaining a comprehensive study is that any damage that occurs due to the shock to the body from walking on a non yielding surface is quite long term and will certainly be more severe on heavier bodies than a light weight person. The issue is also compounded by having a lack of very similar subjects walking / standing on other surfaces (wood /cork etc.) for the same time frame and in the same patterns. It would be quite hard to find and study 2 or more groups of people that have identical jobs that work on - say wood and concrete for 20 or 30 years! Since there are so many other variables I doubt concrete could be proven to cause body damage or fatigue!

It is a fact determined by many studies that shock is detrimental to the human body, the doctor that replaced my hips stated that almost all pro football players end up with replaced hips. It is easy (for me at least) to tell how much more my body aches after a few hours on concrete in my shop vs walking around the house. I'm truthfully not certain that a thin pad or crepe soles on shoes or wood directly laid on concrete would have a great effect, but am certain that a wooden floor on joists that flex do have a huge difference from concrete - it would be fairly easy to measure the difference in impact force with the right equipment between those examples.

Re: Can feet know difference between cement and wood?

#5

I would think cement would be best.

Keith Newton

If you really want to test, I think it would be best to take the shoe out of the equation. When I think back to when I was a kid, we went barefooted all Summer long, until mid junior high. Back then, I could run barefoot down a gravel road, which now just a few steps would leave me crippled.

The closes thing to cement, was running down the dirt lanes which were about 4" deep powder. I can still remember the pop or thumping sound my feet made as it compressed the air mixed in with the loose dust, making a little explosion, sending up a little cloud behind me. But I suspect you really meant concrete floor, instead of the loose powder used to make it.

Still, back then we played basketball barefoot on the wooden gym floor, and on concrete when we couldn't get in the other. I can tell you for sure, when we jumped as high as we could going for rebounds etc, that coming down on the wood with wood framing underneath was certainly easier than on concrete, where the jolt may carry on up past the knees.

As for how McKay was using it in his shop, I noticed that he had the OSB grain running with the 2x4 sleeper, and I don't know what centers he used, 16" or 24", but there should be plenty of give in between the framing, although it might make some heavy tools kinda wiggly, unless extra blocking was provided under their designated location.

Another nice thing about doing this, would be that one could easily run some wiring and air lines under there, and have them come up under workbenches or tools, getting cords and hoses out of the walking path. Then it would be a good idea to use screws so making alterations would be easier later.

Re: Can feet know difference between cement and wood?

#6

Jesper, Denmark

Re: One wonders.........

Jesper, Denmark

How you would arrange the placebo in the double blind test???

Re: Can feet know difference between cement and wood?

#7

Not The Feet

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Skeleton does a good job of transferring the step impacts to the knees, hips, and lower spine. I have a concrete floor (basement with no room to put in a raised floor) so I have fatigue mats around each machine and work bench. They make a huge difference in the amount of sleep I get after spending a day in the shop.

Re: Can feet know difference between cement and wood?

#8

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I think you're on to something, Larry...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

...and that is the concept of "impulse" in the collision between one's foot and the floor. With very unyielding concrete, any step creates a pressure (force per area) vs. time impulse that has a sharp peak, whereas, with the extra little bit of give of a wood floor on joists or sleepers there is a lower peak value of pressure, but the impulse also lasts a little longer, spreading the load over time, so to speak.

Here's an interesting part: I've done enough work on my knees as a painter that I've found it's easier (less painful) for me to kneel on tile, concrete and the like for a short time without knee pads than it is to kneel on a wood floor. My hypothesis is that the tile and concrete surfaces have a higher rate of thermal transfer giving them an ice-pack-like effect on my knees versus the wood. The older I get, the shorter that time is that I can go without knee pads.

Jason

Re: Can feet know difference between cement and wood?

#9

Re: Can feet know difference between cement and wo

waroland

I'm an engineer and yes it does make a difference, but more on the knee joint than the feed. I work on a lot of concrete floor and I like to use the foam pads to stand on if I am stationary for a while. Oh by the I was I am an electronics engineer, so disregard any expert opinions. Ha ha.

Re: Can feet know difference between cement and wood?

#10

Re: Can feet know difference between cement and wo

Barry Irby

This is a question I have wondered about a lot.

If there is a difference, I think it would be between wood floors supported by joists verses a concrete slab or a wood floor directly on a slab.

Over time wooden floors have become lighter and springier. Think of an old school floor with massive joists and inch thick sheeting with heavy hardwood over it, verses The new truss joists with a plywood skin and carpet or laminate flooring. I get a lot of complaints about the newer lightweight floors. (a tall thin china cabinets on lightweight floor is a great seismic detector. People are often happy with their floor until they get a china cabinet). I think people are feeling the shock wave from walking on the floor. A 200 pound man walking on a 500 pound floor would be different than the same man walking on a 1000 pound floor.

I can not imagine that the old school wood block floors on a slab were much better for you back and knees that the slab itself. There might be a temperature difference that affects the sensation or working on it.

Soft sole shoes would seem to be an obvious help.

OTOH, a friend told me that that each pound you add adds 3 pounds of impact to your knees. Losing a pound has a triple effect on your knees.

I also wonder if we could learn to walk better? Tiptoe through the tulips?

Good topic, thanks for posting.

Re: Can feet know difference between cement and wood?

#11

just a thought

Mike Potts

Might it not be the temperature difference, concrete holds the cold, while wood or a mats would act as an insulator. I know in my shop with the concrete floors my feet stay a little to cold, and sometime i'll prop them up in front of the wood burner to warm them up. I know the older i get the less I tolerate cold.

Re: Can feet know difference between cement and wood?

#12

Re: What is the evidence there is a psychological

TomD

difference? In your rush to pseudo science you assume there is a Psych difference. What this does is simultaneously accept there is a perception of difference. Assume it is psych. This seems like a very shoddy start to a thread.

Re: Can feet know difference between cement and wood?

#13

Re: Can feet know difference between cement and wo

John Veerkamp

A good fitting support shoe with Orthotic inserts if necessary will more than make up for the difference between the surface resilance(sp) . I worked on my feet on a concrete floor for 10 years after I retired. Once I found the shoe solution no more foot issues. IMHO good foot wear is much more important that the surface. Shoes are also more cost effective when you price it out.

Re: Can feet know difference between cement and wood?

#14

And your point is? and some philosophy

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

My post was a plea for data. Some people made a positive contribution with some hypothesis. As far as I can tell your post wasted electrons.

To clarify:

There was a time that man believed the earth was flat and the center of the universe and that this and that god whimsically controlled their lives. Some still do. Others have found that sound data has led to knowledge that has led to benefits from enlightenment.

Some of woodworking lore is based on the equivalent of witchcraft. It may be true but not for the believed reason, or it may be baloney. I reread a Fine Woodworking article last night on "Oil Finishes" written by a self proclaimed expert and consultant in finishing. This person's knowledge of what he was writing about was so flawed that he didn't even realize he was using what any knowledgeable person would call varnish, not oil (thank you Bob Flexner for correctly revealing this information). All of the negative things he has to say about varnish applied the very product he advocated.

Personally, I have learned a lot of useful information from questioning "conventional woodworking wisdom" and will continue to do. I asked on Badger Pond why abrasion resistant tool steel was not used for woodworking tools. "Can't be sharpened to a keen edge", was the collective wisdom and this bogus statement is still to be found. Others were motivated to explore this claim and found it to not be true(Elliot a notable example). Questioning this woodworking belief by others has led to the availability of higher performance steel woodworking tools ( for example LV). A while back I asked what the chip breaker actually did. "Stiffens the flimsy Stanley blades, breaks chips, etc" was the collective wisdom among many. To my astonishment I got this same argument from a LV hand tool "expert", recently. (Some still believe the earth flat.) While some knew what it really could do, now more know because the conventional wisdom was challenged in discussions. Research (Kees, Weaver) was done to rediscover what it did, discoveries made more than a century ago, it turns out. Now the willing can benefit from this rediscovered knowledge.

My 6th grade teacher, who at the time I hated, told me in response to some stone headed notion I had, "Challenge your prejudices!!". It was the most useful advice I received in school. For those interested go find Feynman's lecture on teaching science. His thoughts on the benefit of each generation questioning everything in the light of new knowledge and capability may be inspiring.

To that end, if questioning conventional wisdom makes you uncomfortable don't read my posts.

Re: Can feet know difference between cement and wood?

#15

Shoe inserts- a success story

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Shoes used to have arches built into them. For some reason they vanished during the past decade. I tried without success many inserts to be able to make wearable some recently purchased expensive work and hiking shoes. In exasperation I tired the pricey Dr. Sholls inserts. You go to the pharmacy section of Walmart and stand on this machine which tickles your foot. Then a recommendation is spit out of the machine. I bought the recommended insert and they have enabled me to wear all day otherwise flat arched shoes that I could not bear for more than a couple of hours. $50 spent and several hundred dollars of shoes made wearable.

BTW, why have shoes become flat footed and little to no heel elevation? My favorite shop shoes are some 25 year old Merril Hiking shoes with a high heel and arch. They are too frayed to wear hiking but the do well in the shop. And then 10 years ago arches disappeared from Merril and Clark shoes.

Re: Can feet know difference between cement and wood?

#16

Re: And your point is? and some philosophy

Jesse Cloud

Thanks Bill. That's the spirit we should approach woodworking (and life in general) with.

The most effective manager I had would hardly ever let a meeting finish without asking the question "How do we know that?". We all feared being on the receiving end of that question and the level of preparation for the meetings skyrocketed!

Re: Can feet know difference between cement and wood?

#17

Wood is softer on dropped projects

mark valsi

I was taking a woodworking class in a Local High School at night. The floor was wood, and I asked the teacher why.

he said if you drop your project, do you want it to land on wood or concrete ??

Re: Can feet know difference between cement and wood?

#18

Skew chisels

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I had just bought a skew chisel and spent a great deal of time getting it in shape. I dropped it off the bench onto the concrete floor and I don't have to tell you which end hit first. Next time I was at the flea market I bought a thick "anti fatigue mat". It saves my feet and tools. Edged tools most certainly know the difference between wood and concrete.

Re: Can feet know difference between cement and wood?

#20

Also...

Jesse Cloud

When you spill glue or finish on the floor and need to clean it up later, wood sands a lot easier than concrete.

Re: Can feet know difference between cement and wood?

#21

A really wild guess...

John in NM

As to why shoes have become flat - easier to manufacture probably, or perhaps wisdom of cobblery lost in offshoring.

My other guess is that as rubber soles became viable, the need for a formed arch was deemed less crucial. I used to wear boots with the white vibram sole that was really squishy - a very comfortable boot, but the sole wore out quickly. I'm considering getting some of those again, since I hardly hike any more and lug soles are a real pain around livestock.

Re: Can feet know difference between cement and wood?

#22

Re: And your point is? and some philosophy

TomD

"To that end, if questioning conventional wisdom makes you uncomfortable don't read my posts."

I always enjoy your posts, right up there with the best. I rarely agree with anything you say, but that is what makes your posts so interesting. I'm familiar with your biography.

I think my point was clear. You assume the psychological component, you dismiss the experiential aspect. Your application of the rudiments of science is largely influenced by your personality. It's unscientific when it doesn't confirm to your prejudices. However, that is as good a starting point as any. One needs a starting point. You shouldn't really bristle at any flaws being pointed out. Part of the scientific process is review. People who suggest flaws probably read your stuff carefully. I intend to keep up the good work.