Well I turned the Festool vac down to half suck. Notice some more squiggles, turn my sander over and notices some super glue deposits on the pad. Changed to a new pad and squiggles were gone within a minute.
So...from now on, will have a dedicated sander to grind my super-glue down, can't recall how to spell cyna..... glue, .
Thanks to Bill Tindall for coming up with the possible problem.
the stuff is an acrylate which tells one the chemical family the stuff belongs to....like "Quercus". But it is a modified acrylate, the modification being cyanide, which is called "cyano" when used as an adjective, like "Quercus Alba". "cyanoacrylate". That is the stuff in the bottle plus stabilizers, thickeners, and who knows what. When it sets the stuff in the bottle polymerizes to yield a tough plastic correctly called poly(cyanoacrylate). Actually there is yet another modification that varies depending on the details of the usage. For whatever reason this modification does not show up in the common name.
Funny, That is what I used on some triangular drawers that I made with finger joints. It sure made it easier to assemble dry, then let it flow into those tight joints.
of this assertion? With so many formulas for different purposes, I find it a little hard to swallow that the most expensive glue that I buy, is going to disintegrate.
We have been through this discussion a few years ago here at WC. It is well known that polymerized cyanoacrylate rapidly degrades in water (days) and degrades less rapidly in high humidity environment (months) and slower still in a dryer environment (years). I have been unable to put my finger on my files for the stability of this stuff which is annoying since I just ran across them recently. Will report back when I find some more references into the degradation chemistry.
This patent application "WIPO Patent Application WO/2012/139965" involved with improving the resistance of this adhesive to moisture discusses the moisture limitations but this is not the best source I have when I can find the file.
The problem is that the polymer formed when the common stuff in the bottle(ethylcyanoacrylate) cures is inherently unstable toward a great many chemicals, including water. It may be that the large suppliers have data on wood under conditions of various humidity. I have not checked. The typical product is just a crummy wood adhesive and should only be used for tacking parts prior to more permanent assembly.
Perhaps your supplier sells a modified version that is more stable. Believe what they say if supported by data. Emphasize that you need decades, if not cneturies, of stability to be competitive with other wood adhesives
I can't give you a definitive source but woodturners tend to use CA for various purposes including finishing.
It has been stated by pro turners at our club meetings that galleries/museums are refusing pieces that have been glued with CA because after 10 years there is a chance the bonds will fail.
As an Engineer who worked with plastics extensively - including "engineering grades" including Delrin, Nylon 6, Nylon 66, Polyethylene, Polypropylene, Lexan (Polycarbonate), ABS, Epoxies (many types), Cyanoacrylates (in bulk) and several others. We produced components for the radio, TV, Automotive and Appliance market. We had about 30 injection molding machines and also used transfer molding machines.
We produced filled materials using mineral and glass fiber etc as well as unfilled. We had a testing lab and did accelerated testing of all materials, using temperature, humidity and UV exposure for customer, UL and CSA tests.
In my opinion NONE of the plastic materials have a very long life. The automotive industry probably has the best materials on the market today, if you want to verify the life of plastics just take a walk through a "junk yard". After 15 ~ 20 years almost all the parts exposed to direct uv (sun) are cracked or at best very brittle. Flexible clamps clips and keepers used are either broken or ridged and brittle. CA adhesives used on weather stripping are deteriorating and the materials separating.
Unfortunately, accelerated testing just gives you a fair indication of the life cycle, the actual "proven" life cannot be truly ascertained until the material is used for a long period in actual usage.. Just the nature of the beast for plastics to deteriorate.
In reality, for extremely long life the only "proven" adhesive is Hide glue. Some furniture found in the Egyptian pyramids over 3000 years old were still intact ~ glued with some version of hide glue!
Centuries of data would be interesting, but how many glues have been used for centuries? With this guideline, wouldn't we have to avoid epoxies, white and yellow glues, plastic resin, resourcinol, . . .?
I'd like to see a scientific paper explaining how CA disintegrates in a controlled atmosphere.
I was around pretty early on using it for lots of things turning related, I have little doubt that there were more than a few turned wood objects which were either assembled or repaired using CA and wet wood, due to how hard these objects are to clamp, / easy to hand hold / quick setting time, then under lots of tension forever after due to normal wood drying stresses, which would be very likely to fail. I may have been guilty of using it that way myself, although I've not seen any problems, or gotten any callbacks due to failures yet. But maybe 25 years isn't long enough.
You state, 'the only "proven" adhesive is Hide glue. Some furniture found in the Egyptian pyramids over 3000 years old were still intact", But I have done numerous antique repairs where I'm sure the glue would have been Hide glue, which was just crumbs in the joints, and under loose veneers as well. Now, those things may have held up fine buried in a crypt deep under the dry desert sands, and I have now way of knowing what these objects had gone through.
Even stone breaks down under long exposure to Sun and other weather elements like wetting, drying, freezing, and thawing.
The OH- required comes from the equilibrium concentration of OH- in water. The water comes from water in the case of gluing tissue together or moisture in the substrate in the case of wood. This reaction can be slowed by making the substrate drier like in Arizona, changing the alkyl substitution from the typical ethyl to something more hydrophobic like butyl or octyl, and also it may be possible to add stabilizers that retard the reaction.
To give you an idea of rate, the glue was totally gone, dissolved and excreted from tissue in just a few days. The rate in a board at 10% moisture content will be much slower-years.
Glue relies on long polymer molecules to yield a tough plastic after curing. Glue fails when these long molecules get chopped into shorter pieces by some chemical reaction. When the molecules are shorter the plastic becomes brittle and looses strength. Predicting trends in glue service life is a simple matter of considering the likely chemistry that may attack the polymer molecules to chop them up.
For example, the bonds holding PVA(yellow) glue molecules together are not attacked by anything known to be present in the wood including typical amounts of moisture. In contrast it is well established that cyanoacrylate polymer is attacked by water and small amounts of water are present in wood.
I have been told by Franklin chemists that the PVA glues are stable for at least 60 years, which is how long this glue has been used.
I realize that off the cuff comments like this get a bit exaggerated, but stone is about as light stable as it gets. Weathering effects are all due to water, wind (+sand), and roots.
The moisture instability of cyano glues is well known - the only people I've ever come across expressing doubt over the point are woodworkers who don't wish it to be true. The earliest reference to cyanoacrylate properties, including moisture resistance, is probably in the Handbook of Adhesives - the chapter on cyano glues was written by the glue's inventors who were well aware of its properties.
If you doubt it I would suggest using google and the search term "cyanoacrylate moisture resistance". Among other references, you will find patent applications for methods of improving the moisture resistance of these glues.
Does all this mean wood joints glued with CA are sure to fail in 25 years? No, of course not - conditions of use and storage are too complicated to make such a prediction. Does it mean that woodworkers who desire longevity should stay away from CA glues? Yes, that is precisely the point made repeatedly whenever this question comes up.
Can't disagree that Hide Glue has failure modes - Excessive temperature (above 145 Deg. F is enough to soften the glue) combined with high humidity will cause failures in this glue. However the "proof" is still in the pudding ~ look at all the furniture in the museums built in the last few centuries - hide glue was the basic glue used in almost all the objects. Yes, it can and will fail under adverse conditions, actually quite a bit quicker than the current crop of yellow and other PVA adhesives. However it is very easy to repair as it is the only glue I am aware of that can be re-disolved with an additional amount of the same adhesive and retain almost of its original bond strength. I am not stating that PVA glue will not hold up long term, only that it has only been "proven" (as Bill has stated) for 60 years! There have been other adhesives / glues used for centuries (even preceding hide glues) including vegetable based and fish glues etc.. These have a lesser record of longevity and/or strength.
I have heard of using CA to close wounds. (A topic of interest to wood workers, since we seem to have a talent for acquiring minor wounds.) I think it would be better to get medical grade CA for this purpose, but confess to using what I have once or twice. My understanding is the medical stuff does not generate heat. My sue of the wood working grade stuff made me wonder if there was any advantage to sealing the wound and cauterizing it at the same time? But I digress. I think you just answered my question, which was how can a wound with CA in it heal? Your reply above indicates the CA is absorbed and thus is cleared out of the wound so sound tissue can form? I was thinking the body would have to heal AROUND it and then reject it.
As I understand the situation the common CA is the ethyl substituted material while the medical is butyl. The degradation products from butyl are less toxic to the wound area according to the literature I have read.
The CA polymer in the wound is not absorbed by the body, rather it is chopped up into tiny pieces by water, which leave in the pee.
The curing reaction for the adhesive is highly exothermic for all the monomers.
the wood workers version that is, once to glue a wound on myself and once to glue a false fingernail for a lady friend. In both cases it was a serious YOUSA that's HOT moment when it kicked off. She told me the version they use at the nail salon did not generate nearly as much heat.