I was able to get some work done this past weekend. Nice having a day off.
1.)
Laying out the legs on a piece of Walnut. Made one extra. I always screw one up.
2.) I am using a white gel pen as suggested by Bill Tindall some time ago. I've also tried white pencils, but they never seem to leave a line I can easily see (at lest with the ones I bought).
3.) Cutting to the line.
4.) Cut out, ready to be shaped and cleaned up.
5.) Looks like they will fit ok.
6.) Test fitting.
7.) They fit.
8.) Taper the legs. Before using the router to round over the tops of each leg, I made a quick little jig from scraps to hold the leg in place so I could plane a taper to each leg. 3/4" down to about 1/2" at the base of the foot. Worked well.
9.) After rounding over the tops of the legs on the router (and doing some sanding), I cleaned up the profile at the tops of the legs with a rasp to match the roundness of the pedestal. Then cleaned up with some sand paper. Everything gets sanded from 120 up to 220.
10.) Legs are done.
11.) Ready for assembly
12.)
The legs are done. All sanded and ready to go. The pedestal is all ready too. Just need to glue it up.
I made a similar three legged stand several years ago. Our dogs were running rough one day and slid into the table, which got pushed up against the wall and the pedestal split. I fixed it by gluing it back together and making a spider out of metal to reinforce the base. You may want to consider doing the same, depending on the inhabitants of your house.
I agree with the spider. I made several of these and made spiders for them. I think you can buy spiders from Lee Valley (?) if you don't want to make one.
I also drilled a hole through the spider and installed a "drop" on the bottom of one. Added a nice touch.
Also, I gave mine that was very similar to yours to my sister. Finished it with shellac. Turned it upside down at her house and discovered a drool on the underside of the top. I was embarrassed. Be sure to inspect the underside.
A side story, a friend gave me two 4x4 walnut blanks about four feet long. I saw them as future bed posts. My son turned one of them into a baseball bat for the neighbor's kid. I was horrified. Several years later the parents gave it back. I turned the bat into the post for a shaker style table.
The hard part of making these stands, and the part that has dissuaded me from making one so far, is the step of making the flat where the leg joins the post and then making the dovetail on the leg to fit the dovetail on the post, tightly. These key steps were passed by in your otherwise detailed description.
For the record I recommended a black gel pen. Light reflecting from the black gel ink shows up as a bright line in good lighting. The white, however, is dandy for photographs.
Bill, I am not the original poster, but I have made this set up several times.
My way of doing this is to use a lathe that has an indexing set, allowing you to lock the shaft in a number of positions. In this case you need three indexing spots, 120 degrees apart.
I turn the post with the bottom toward the tailstock because there is a little more room to work there. I made a box that sits on the ways and has a "key" or piece under it that indexes into the slot in the ways and it locks into place. There are several tops fr the box. One allows some freedom left to right for the router and you use that one to create the flat spots. You lock the spindle and use the router bit to "plane" away the surface. If you like you can set up a stop to prevent you from cutting to high into the post. On the post, I leave a shoulder there to cover the top of the leg. Do all three flats. Then switch the top of the box to one that has a narrow slot and matches a collar for the router. I usually use a straight bit first and route the three slots, then switch to as dovetail bit and re do them to make them dovetails.
On the legs, I make the dovetails with my router table and use the same or identical bit to create the male dovetails. While the faces of the legs are still flat and parallel, I start with a practice piece. I set the height of the bit to be a couple of hundredths less than the depth of the slots on the post. I set the bit to project out of a waste fence. I route both sides of the scrap and test the fit. Then I adjust and try again. Waste block MUST be the same thickness as the legs. Once I find the fit, I route the legs.
As an additional refinement, I often put a piece of blue tape on both sides o the legs. This makes the dovetail too thick by the thickness of the tape. Then I try each one. I find the slots vary in spite of my best efforts. Sometimes one fits. Sometimes I have to remove one piece of tape, sometimes, both. Might even try two thicknesses of tape on both sides, the first time out.
One additional thought, You can apply a small piece of tape at the bottom end of the tail on the leg to make the top a few thousandths narrower and it will make a tapered dovetail that can slide home easily and then lock up tightly. Works great. Remember that in use, the bottom of the tail is in tension and top is in compression, so that if the top is slightly loose and the bottom tight, it works well. Epoxy glue is your friend here. Nice and slippery and it fills joints nicely.
Once you have the box for the lathe, it takes a lot longer to type this out than to do it.
Barry pretty much nailed it - what he describes is almost exactly what I do. Thanks Barry, saved me some typing time!
I don't have an indexing thingamajig, so I use clamps to hold the spindle/pedestal in place. That allows slop which isn't so good. I need to get an indexing thing...
Here is my crude box for the router to sit on - it's not very precise and I need to remake it if I do more of these tables in the future:
You can also see above I used blue tape to minimize any tear out when creating the flat.
In the past, I used the straight router bit to just kiss the pedestal to create a flat for the legs. This time around, something moved (!) and I ended up going a tad too deep. I actually created a slot. This worked out well though because it was a perfect fit for the legs. Worked perfectly. You can see the "slot" in the picture below. The "B" dovetail shows it best.
And, as you can see here, the fit was perfect.
This technique (of using the router and box) was in an article on making these tables by C. Becksvoort in FWW some time ago.
Roy Underhill did an episode some time ago on making these. He of course cut the dovetails by hand and on the legs and pedestal. I wanted to do that, but I don't really have time to experiment (and re-do it). Also, he used a gouge of some sort on the legs to scribe it to fit the pedestal. I didn't want to buy one. Maybe next time. I'd rather try that than use the router.