Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Ok tree guys, which Oak

Posts

Ok tree guys, which Oak

#1

Ok tree guys, which Oak

Ray - Middletown, IN

I have gone back and forth on this, which oak is this.



Leaf top about 8" long and 6" wide



and underside



bark.

Ray

Re: Ok tree guys, which Oak

#2

Dale Lenz

Re: Ok tree guys, which Oak

Dale Lenz

There are Many oaks growing in the US. For sure it's of the red oak group. My first hunch is a black oak species, although the bark does not look like the black oaks around here, could be your picture, IDK.

Re: Ok tree guys, which Oak

#4

LeafSnap: Tree ID *LINK*

Tom Dunlap

With this app you can take a leaf sample, put it on a light colored background, and take a picture.

LeafSnap does a pretty good job of identifying samples. Sometimes though it comes up with some really wrong answers. It's helped me a few times to narrow my options of new plants.

Tom


LeafSnap

Re: Ok tree guys, which Oak

#5

Another vote for Northern Red

David Churnega

I checked my Audubon field guide and it most closely resembles Northern red. Someone once told me that White Oak typically has lobed leaves versus pointed. I am not sure if that is correct but it's a good starting point.

Re: Ok tree guys, which Oak

#6

I have one of these trees and in

Gary Smyth

comparison with a pin oak for example, the leaf is huge. I took a leaf to a landscaper a couple of years ago and he told me it was a Shumadi Red Oak. I'm not sure still. I took his word but he seemed to use the same identification books I had before going to him. Unsure, I have been calling mine a "Red Oak" since then.

Re: Ok tree guys, which Oak

#7

I agree on Red Oak

Ray - Middletown, IN

but the sinuses are shallower and leaf is bigger than most of the other red oaks around the property which made me go, Hmmmm.

Ray

Re: Ok tree guys, which Oak

#8

Dale Lenz

Re: I agree on Red Oak

Dale Lenz

Drill into the bark with a pocket knife. If the inter bark is a burn orange color and taste very bitter, it's a black oak, if not, I'll go with the Northern red oak. Sometimes leaves are bigger if grown in the shade.

Re: Ok tree guys, which Oak

#9

Dale Lenz

Another thing you might try...

Dale Lenz

Do an image search for the two different oak's acorns. Hopefully, the tree has acorns this year. The things I notice were the acorn's "cup" size and texture.

Re: Ok tree guys, which Oak

#10

Aha

Ray - Middletown, IN

This tree has grown in the shade of many ash trees over the years and this year the ashes did not leaf so it got full sun for the first time, and apparently loves it. Still looking for acorns, deer and squirrels get up before I do and have them for breakfast before I get out.

At last count I have more than 2 dozen dead ash trees and that many more in varying stages of attack.

Ray

Re: Ok tree guys, which Oak

#11

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

So...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

...those dying trees, are you going to turn the "ashes to ashes", or are you going to dig out a big area and put them in the ash-ho...oh, wait....

:D

Jason

Re: Ok tree guys, which Oak

#12

Dale Lenz

Re: So...

Dale Lenz

I have mispronounced ASH a few time while making a presentation, it's embarrassing! :|

Re: Ok tree guys, which Oak

#13

Re: Aha

Joseph Mulherin, sr

Ray, cut down the trees which would be good for woodworking, salvage all that is good, and possibly offer some of the wood for us WoodCentral woodworkers close to you for sale.

Re: Ok tree guys, which Oak

#14

Burn It!

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Sooner than later. You can help the effort to control the EAB by taking those trees down now and disposing of them so as to prevent the spread.

Do your part to preserve these beautiful trees.

Re: Ok tree guys, which Oak

#15

Re: Burn It!

Mike Potts

Burning won't help, they tried that when it first hit norther Ohio, so you might as well try to make something from the wood, that's how we can help preserve the memory of this tree. I have over 20 trees that I am losing, 7 are totally dead an I'll get them down this year, the rest I'm taking a wait and see on.

Re: Ok tree guys, which Oak

#16

Doesn't Matter what I do

Ray - Middletown, IN

They are abundant up and down the creek that flows through my back yard, and for miles up and down stream. There are literally hundreds of trees dead and dying, it would take multiple timber crews to cut them all. Just not possible. I wish there were a good solution.

Then there are the walnuts in the fence row that will probably be next.

Ray

Re: Ok tree guys, which Oak

#17

We have a plan for this fall

Ray - Middletown, IN

A friend has a Woodmizer and is going to come out and salvage as many boards as possible, 50/50 split. I will cut some more for turning and the rest for firewood. A lot of the trees are only 6-8 inches which will not provide much wood. I plan on not keeping much of anything so will post later when stuff is available. East Central Indiana for you future planners.

Ray