Experiment w/ drawbored tenons
JL
Ash w/ cherry.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Experiment w/ drawbored tenons
JL
Ash w/ cherry.
So--how much offset? Size of dowel?
Re: So--how much offset? Size of dowel?
JL
1/4" pegs, thickness of a piece of 120 grit sandpaper.
Mixed woods discussion
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
I have been told before that I lack design imagination and this may another case of it. To my eye that is an attractive cherry table, or an attractive ash table. I just don't get the goal of the mixture.
Re: Mixed woods discussion
Barry Irby
I too lack design skills. In my case I am sure the skills are lacking, I'm not sure what your sensibilities are.
I can't start with a blank sheet of paper and design a fresh piece of furniture and have it come out with the Wow factor I thought I was going to get. Usually my response to my own designs is, Uhhh, I could have done better.
I grew up in a house full of antiques. Maybe I was so indoctrinated that I can't break out of the mold. There is certainly much to learn there and much to admire.
I worked with my son to build a table out of some sentimental wood we had acquired over the years. His mother had given him a cherry board about 6' long and two inches thick and 14" wide. We had it resawn and used it book matched and put a matching cherry border around it. We made the base for the table out of Osage Orange. Simple rails and four inch square legs taper to about two inches. At first it was a pale cherry top with a bright yellow base. Now, both woods have mellowed to the rich cherry and the dark tea color osage gets. It looks spectacular. (I wonder if it looks great because most people would never notice there are tow different woods?)
I made a A"Planter" out of craps. The lattice is redwood and the frame is osage. Same thing as the table above. The woods now match well. I keep wood working magazines in it.
Now that I think of it, I made a cabinet out of elm and cherry. The door panels are crotch elm and the frames are cherry. The contrast remains and I like it. Maybe this is the one I got right?
In this case...
John in NM
I would say that the contrast is necessary. I tend to find ash rather unappealing when used in large expanses like panels or a table top. I think it is both the color and the grain, since I do not have the same reaction to a maple table. This goes to show how subjective tastes are - I recognize differences that I can't put into words.
That said, when it comes to mixing woods I tend to be fairly conservative. Accent pieces are fine - contrasting pins, splines, moldings. Table tops can be done with caution, but it is easy to over do it. Similarly I've seen cherry console tables with a lower shelf of curly maple. Cherry and curly maple always seem to work well when the maple is the top or shelf of a table.
Mixed woods in a frame and panel almost always look awful to me. There have been exceptions, but it's rare to see them. The two woods have to be similar in tone for it to work and it seems that when a woodworker tries it, they shoot for maximum contrast rather than subtle effect.
One cabinet that I made this way is oak frame and mesquite panels & drawer fronts. It was a case of desperation, not having much wood on hand but not wanting to wait for a trip to town. The results surprised me, I did not expect to like them - I doubt I would have if the frame was maple or the panels walnut.
This brings up another point. Especially with tables, I find the mixed wood look to work best with a rustic or provincial design. Like the cabinet I made, it strikes me as a measure of expediency, using what is available or what has desirable properties for different parts. In a farm table, no one would really worry much about the aesthetics, and once the colors mellow after a few decades, it just looks right.