Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Marine Spar Varnish...the Devil's Workshop

Posts

Marine Spar Varnish...the Devil's Workshop

#1

Marine Spar Varnish...the Devil's Workshop

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

So I was commissioned to do some tables for a local eatery. No problem says I. What finish to use? I decided to use Marine Spar Varnish. I figured it could take all the spills and wet rag cleaning....and I'm sure it will.

This was my first time applying it. I chose to spray it. The initial spray went fine. That is until later when I saw some fish eyes. Drat! Well, those of you who have used this finish know the rest of the story....the battle of rub-downs and re-sprays. Uhg!

Maybe it is a good choice for the application but I hate that stuff! Ok...I just needed to rant. Signing off.

T.

Re: Marine Spar Varnish...the Devil's Workshop

#2

Re: Marine Spar Varnish...the Devil's Workshop

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

It is also, in my observation, extremely slow to cure and stays softer than furniture varnishes. As I understand it, it's formulated to stay flexible and therefore stay on the spars, masts, etc. of the wooden boat in all weathers.

I used it on some oak thresholds inside the house, and it was weeks before I could clean them without smudging the varnish. It did eventually cure; I guess that's the good news.

Unfortunately, it seems to be the only varnish the local hardware stores/home centers are selling around here anymore.

Re: Marine Spar Varnish...the Devil's Workshop

#3

poor choice for interior table

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If indoors, floor finish would have been a better choice in a brushing varnish but conversion varnish available from many suppliers would have been ideal for a sprayed finish. You would have been done in an hour. Conversion varnish is the ultimate in interior durability.

Spar varnish is not hard and it may absorb food fats and oils and become tacky over time.

Now how did you get fish eyes? Only time I have ever encountered them is in refinishing stuff that has been silicone waxed.

Re: Marine Spar Varnish...the Devil's Workshop

#4

Re: poor choice for interior table

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Yeah,

I have no idea about the fisheyes. But as for choice of finish....not again. We have a local woodworking place and I took some advice that I now question. I should have posted here! But this was only table #1 of 6. The others will be done differently. So I appreciate the feedback!

PS....I am suspicious that the spar V was past its prime when I bought it.

T.

Re: Marine Spar Varnish...the Devil's Workshop

#5

Look at conversion varnish

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The most durable interior finish will be a conversion varnish that you add catalyst to. Sprays like lacquer. Dilute it for a close to the wood finish. Valspar makes a good one I am told. I will try it when I use up the last of the Sherwin Williams I have on hand. I have had good luck with the Sherwin Williams (Kemvar). We wash tables in our house finished with Kemvar. Immune to alcohol too. And it looks good.


Re: Marine Spar Varnish...the Devil's Workshop

#6

Re: poor choice for interior table *LINK*

Dick Coers

Unless you get advice from a commercial finishing supplier, I would be suspect. This is a good place for advice, Woodweb is even better for commercial applications. Bill is right on the mark with his conversion varnish comment. You can get any sheen from flat to gloss. Really protect yourself from that finish. Not like you shouldn't anyway, but you know, acid catalyst and all. All things considered, I'd strip that one table while the finish is fresh and soft, then go to a commercial supplier from here on out for your finish. I like to use the advice of never buying finish where you can also get beef jerky at the counter.


professional finishing forum

Re: Marine Spar Varnish...the Devil's Workshop

#7

PS

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I am near the end of my 3rd- 5 gallon container of Kemvar, so I have more than a passing acquaintance with it. The product literature on the conversion varnishes will provide information on what they are resistant to.

It is self sealing. Spray, wait about an hour, scuff sand, tack and recoat. Done. Let cure a day and deliver. Stinks when curing.

The product literature from Valspar says

Immune to 24 hour exposure to ammonia, lemon juice, olive oil, alcohol, standing water, detergent solution,. Don't try these on the spar varnish. Resists abrasion and it is UV stabilized.

The Sherwin Williams stuff probably says the same thing.

Re: Marine Spar Varnish...the Devil's Workshop

#8

Thanks All!

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Looks like the spar was a pig in a poke. I'll go with the conversion next time!!

Thanks!

T.

Re: Marine Spar Varnish...the Devil's Workshop

#9

Re: Thanks All!

TomD

The other main issue here, and I do this a lot myself, is the whole test on a finished piece thing. I normally am moving incrementally enough that I get by, but the only logical way to proceed with untested materials is through samples. Imagine your capacity had allowed you to spray all 6 tables at once, and you are now struggling with all of them.

Catalysed products are no quick fix, you need to learn them. There are thousands of pages of stuff on using those products on musical instruments. Every time a new improved product comes out you the process of learning it starts all over again. Bill normally understudies with some world class expert, so your mileage may vary.

There is a whole pace of work thing also, just getting comfortable with the process of mixing, reducing, etc... Then, I assume that if you only shot the one table, maybe you don't have a spray booth large enough to take all six, unless you regularly spray cars. So you will be doing a number of separate mix shoot, dry, clean processes. This is the kind of thing that drives people to oil, not that I would use that on this kind of product. A professional fast finish is essential to be competitive, but it isn't something you can just buy in a can.

Re: Marine Spar Varnish...the Devil's Workshop

#10

Re: Thanks All!

TomD

I agree with what Bill has said. Fisheye is a contamination problem, not a characteristic of spar varnishes. While catalysed varnishes might be ideal for this application (they usually are for most applications, cost, safety, set-up cost, and recoating aside), marine spar varnish is not a monolithic entity, and is regularly used on interior furniture through to musical instruments. It can be softer, and have UV inhibitors that may not be necessary for your application. But typically it starts as simply higher quality varnish, that is a lot more expensive (at least if you buy it from a marine supplier). I never touch the stuff if it comes from a non-marine supplier because their objective and market segment may dictate some choices that do not work for me.

Re: Marine Spar Varnish...the Devil's Workshop

#11

Re: Let the robots do it.

TomD

The stuff I use dries hard overnight and gives me recoats the following day, and I live next to various lakes, so it isn't bone dry here and there. I use Z-Spar captain's varnish since about 1980, and other stuff from time to time.

Another interesting choice is

http://www.shellac.net/rockhard_table_top_urethane_varnish.html

I find it interesting because it is not only popular as a finish for tables, but as an upsell finish on some acoustic guitars. That is interesting because guitars are often the province of lacquer, catalysed finishes of every sophistication level, and are not a place where heavy or sticky materials are accepted, yet they get played around alcohol.

That said, this URL seems to cover a new version of the Rockhard stuff, and to paraphrase Fargo: "Tom don't know it, Tom don't vouch for it".

Of course this is how we would all do it if we could... with robots:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wyOTT8nxs0