Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

Posts

OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

#1

OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

William Duffield

I have a Flowering Apricot or Chinese Plum (Prunus mume) That was very recently broken by an employee of my wife.

Can this tree be saved?

Re: OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

#2

Re: OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

Hank Knight

William,

Years ago I split the main trunk of one of our crepe myrtle trees trying to pull a wisteria vine off of the tree. I clamped the split and screwed it back together with some long #10 stainless steel screws. The split was longitudinal and didn't damage too much of the tree's vascular system. The tree never skipped a beat and is still viable today. As long as the vascular layers are intact and capable of supporting the distal branches, I think you could probably repair your tree with screws and even, perhaps, some epoxy. It's hard to tell from your photo, but it looks like the vascular layers are pretty compromised by the break. I'll be interested to hear what the experts say. I'm certainly no expert.

Hank

Re: OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

#3

Re: OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

William Duffield

Thanks for the encouragement. I have lots of clamps and 2-1/2" stainless screws, and epoxy. The split is perpendicular to the vascular system, so there is minimal damage. It's only been split an hour, so I think the tree has a chance. I suppose I should permanently pull it together with Stainless steel cables and eye bolts, but I'll have to go find the eye bolts.

Re: OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

#4

Time is critical

Dick Coers

When did that happen? An immediate repair may have saved that broken side, but if it has dried out, I doubt if it will heal. Air exposure does the damage.

Re: OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

#5

Dale Lenz

Re: OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

Dale Lenz

Pull together with screws/bolts. X the epoxy....not healthy for the tree's tissues.

Re: OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

#6

Re: OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

Hank Knight

William,

Don't wrap cables AROUND the trunk. They will constrict the vascular tissue and cut off the flow of nutrients. I'm sure Dale is right about the epoxy. It was just a thought. I didn't use epoxy on mine. I have used wide nylon straps (2" webbing) looped around a tree trunk/branch to pull it in another direction. The wide strap is kinder to the tree than cable.

Hank

Re: OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

#7

Re: Time is critical

William Duffield

I've got it pulled back together with pipe clamps and stainless screws. The wound was less than two hours old when I got it closed back up. I understand about not wrapping the trunk and strangling it. Next, I will be off to the ships chandler to find some stainless eye bolts, nuts and washers. I already have stainless cable to run between the eye bolts, and crimps and a crimping tool. I've studied how they do that at Longwood Gardens, for huge trees that are a hundred years old. I know the screws won't hold it by themselves, at least not for a few years, and the pipe clamps are temporary.

Re: OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

#8

Re: OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

William Duffield

Thanks for the warning on the epoxy. I was just about to mix up a batch to try to seal the surface. Is there something that I can and should use to seal the surface of the wound?

Re: OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

#9

Ironic

Tony - Memphis

I was just out at lunch gathering up some items for repair of a dogwood damaged ina storm. This was a large branch (2 1/2" diam.) that was split. I did the best I could with what I had at the moment which was clamping it together with some clamps from the shop. I then wrapped it with some natural twine I had. I covered the break with plastic to keep the rain out - it was winter and I was afradi that if water got inside and froze, ti would not be good. Both halves are still alive. I don't know if there is growth between the two. The twine is surprisingly still tight. Thought I'd put a couple of hose clamps on it. I saw an episode of Ask This Old House where they just bolted the tree back together. I just figured the hose clamps would work because the cross section is so small. I looked into using wax to seal the crack to keep moisture out. There is a grafting wax product that I hear works well. I never got aroudn to trying it. I may do that this fall since the crack is still "open" where water could get in and freeze maybe. I think some folks have use toilet ring wax too. Good luck with your tree - hope it makes it.

Tony

Re: OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

#10

Re: OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

Could be Phallus impudicus aka Stinkhorn

I repaired a much larger tree by drilling through the tree across the split and using 3/4" threaded rod with washer/nuts to bolt the tree back together. I actually used an impact driver to drive the nuts and close the gap. It worked, and several years later, the nuts are nearly embedded in the tree. As others have already stated, do nothing to the wound. Let the tree heal itself. Anything you add will make it worse.

Good Luck

Bart

Re: OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

#11

Hmmmm..

Tony - Memphis

Well, the hose clamps may not be a good idea. Some folks suggest they will cut off flow. Not sure about that, but the bolts seem to be quite common method. The twine has been on there since the winter and the two halves are very healthy. I may just get some SS bolts and do that instead of the hose clamps. The twine will eventually rot and fall away. I read about one such repiar where they use shellac to seal the break?

Tony

Re: OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

#12

Re: OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

Bill Howatt

Yes. Even the special pruning paint is no longer recommended. Just let the tree do its own healing thing.

Bill

Re: OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

#13

Grafting Wax

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

google is your friend

Re: OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

#14

Re: OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

Dick Coers

Somebody is going to get a surprise when their chainsaw meets Mr. 3/4 Rod in the future. I was cutting some prime ash with my big Husky? Saw sparks and it feels almost like the saw stopped. I had sawn into a concrete patch that someone poured into a void. It had completely healed over. I lost some teeth on the chain, a 36" chain! Oh the advantages of urban trees.

Re: OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

#15

Re: OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

John McGaw

The method you describe is pretty standard in the industry. Some people advise that the drill bit and the rod be sterilized before being run through the trunk as a precaution. A healthy tree with a well-done repair should grow right over the nuts and washers in a few years.

Re: OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

#16

Kneale Brownson

Cables

Kneale Brownson

My parents had a huge Oak that had branch splits like that that was repaired by running a piece of heavy threaded rod through both sides and held together with large washers and nuts. Last I knew, 40 years later, the tree still stands in that yard.

Re: OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

#17

Dale Lenz

Re: OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

Dale Lenz

Grafting wax should be about as good as any thing. I'm a forester, I know something about trees and tree's growth.....Want to keep petroleum base products away from the tree. If it was my personal tree and using what I had on hand, I might use some latex caulk to cover the wound, nothing inside the tree's wound except good tree tight tree tissue contact.

Re: OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

#18

Re: OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

walta

I can’t tell from the photo. If it is a redbud I would cut it an inch or two above the ground.

It is amazing how fast it will grow.

Walta

Re: OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

#19

Re: OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

William Duffield

I'm sure it's not a Cercis canadensis. I have two huge eastern redbuds, and their seedlings spring up everywhere.

Re: OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

#20

reviewing objectives

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You need to bring the parts together so that new growth will eventually seal the opening. You need to keep water out of the split or it will rot. You need to mechanically support thus limb forever because the new growth will not provide sufficient strength.

What you see will never stitch together. It is no longer cell dividing and in fact it is likely heart wood and no longer living. Hence the need for permanent support from fasteners.

What ever is added to seal the opening must not screw up the new growth that is hoped to stitch the opening together and seal it. You need some professional advice here.

I think you are screwed. A limb that large will have a lot of force on it in a wind and I doubt you will ever be able to mechanically hold it together sufficient that it will seal with new growth. I would cut the limb off and hope the wound eventually sealed, which I doubt. To cover my bets I would be planting a new tree beside this one.

I have learned from training peach trees to become open that these fruit trees have little crotch strength. On a smaller scale I have seen many limbs like this one as a result of forcing a crotch to become more open.

Re: OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

#21

To seal or not to seal,

Keith Newton

Once a tree has a wound like this where the wind and gravity are working it around, rain will be funneling spores and anything else which collects on the bark and leaves down into it, which will start the decay process. I'd be tempted to try silicone caulk, and try to leave the gap at least 1/8" wide, so it would have enough thickness to wiggle, without tearing away from the sides.

I would still go with the all thread to pull it together. I've done that, and seen it used on some really large trees successfully which have grown so large, even though the heart has completely hollowed out that it boggles my mind that what is left could even support the weight above, not to mention wind forces.

Cutting off a limb will soon heal over, but when the cells divide, they will never bridge across a split like this which goes clear to the heart and can wiggle. Then the Ants will move in and make a home, bringing lost of goodies which enable faster decay. Ants are one of my favorite subjects, ha. Who would have guessed?

Re: OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

#22

Re: OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

Barry Irby

I have about twenty redbuds in my yard, of various types. One of them I a Forest Pansy which is a dark red leafed variety. It is brittle. And it has split numerous times. On smaller ones, I cut the offending part away. Just smoothed up the wound and let it go. Several years ago I noticed a huge split that would have taken away about a third of the crown. In desperation I wrapped a 1" wide nylon strap around the two limbs and twisted the loop in the middle with a stick and pulled the crack closed. I intended to get some stainless steel rods or cables and make a permanent repair, but a squirrel ran by and life got in the way. The strap has now grown into the tree and I think the gap has healed. I would go look at it and see about reinforcing it better, but that would burst the magic soap bubble.

(If you don't understand and believe in the magic soap bubble, I doubt I can explain.)

Re: OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

#23

Re: OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

William Duffield

I'm one of those good Samaritans who cuts off the dysfunctional straps that were installed on trees in parking lots and are beginning to strangle them. I think we need some GM squirrels to do that job for us. The naturally selected ones already do an excellent job of planting and maintaining our Appalachian hardwood forests, even though my wife usually disagrees with their choices of locations for black walnut trees.

Re: OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

#24

Re: reviewing objectives

William Duffield

I can't cut the limb off. It's half the tree, and the split goes all the way to the center of the main trunk. If I cut it off, there would be no way to seal the split, and the tree would be so unbalanced it would soon fall over just from the weight of gravity. So, I'm going to tie it back together with cables. As evidenced by the clamps I have temporarily installed to close it up, there are good anchor points for the cables that should carry the strains well and counteract most of the storm generated intermittent twisting forces.

I'm considering sealing the external split in the bark with 3M 5200 Marine Adhesive. I know of nothing else that is as sticky and remains as flexible over a long time period and out in the weather. I've pulled it closed, and there is no perceptible detritus that has gotten down into the split to start the rot process, so I might get lucky.

Re: OT: Need Tree Surgery Advise

#25

Modern Arborculture approach

Tom Dunlap

Dr. Alex Shigo is the Father of Modern Arborculture. He was a plant pathologist with the USFS. His task at the beginning of his career was to find a wound dressing that would stop decay. By the time his research came together he found that there is NO wound dressing that stops decay. More importantly he discovered the 'brach bark ridge' as well as a new model for how trees isolate decay called Compartmentalization of Decay in Trees CODIT. Trees have physical but more importantly chemical barriers inside them to isolate wounding.

Google will serve up more for anyone who wants to get up to speed.

Some good, proper advice has been shared. Some out of date thoughts and solutions too.

I'm a HUGE fan of cabling/bracing/supporting trees. In this case, with the little information I have, here's what I would do.

Subordinate [Dr. Ed Gilman is our go-to for this...ask Google] some of the over-reaching growth on the broken limb. If you think of that limb as a tree and the break as the where the roots are you want to reduce the ends by about 20-30% measured from the 'canopy' volume. Cut back to another limb that will become a new leader. Don't top or stub off the cuts.

Pull the broken limb into place. Use threaded rod and flat washers. A friend of mine came up with an additional step. Add another washer/nut combo and cut the end off flush. By having the double nut/washer you'll end up with a stronger anchor. Decay will start around the hole for the threaded washer. If the bark is crushed by the first washer there will be a decay pocket. Each year the tree will grow another layer and flow over the first washer. Year after year another layer upon layer like a volcano flow or Chianti Candle at the Italian restaurant. A few years from now there will be a nice solid ring of wood grown around the first washer. then the second washer will be enveloped. It will be seated on solid non-decayed wood because of the CODIT function.

Don't wrap any cable/rope/cord around the branches to support the canopy. They'll girdle the limb like a garrotte. Gechhhh! I don't think the limb is very large in diameter. I'd be tempted to use some wide polyproplyene webbing tied with a bowline large enough to accommodate many years of growth. Do NOT use wire and old hose either.

If you really want to reduce the decay you'll setup a watering system to keep the wounded area completely wet. The decay microorganisms are aerobic. Think of all the sunken wood that is being salvaged. Or, keep it dry...that would mean dead. In between is damp...perfect conditions for the Rougish Fungiis to live and rot the wood. That's the world we live in.

If you're successful in holding the broken tissues in place within a few years the new growth will add layer upon layer of new growth and seal the crack. Once the edges of the new growth seal and blend together the cambium layer will be one again.

We've all seen this in lumber but most woodworkers don't know what they're seeing. If you have lumber where a branch has been cut or broken off then milled with the cut right through the branch...a dissection of sorts, you can see the year that the tree sealed off the decay and grew clear wood again.

Dr. Shigo was adamant that we, as arborists, use words correctly. In our language trees never heal, the seal. Healing is biological and connotes new tissue forming to replace the injured tissue...with a bit of scar. Sealing is a better biological term because the wound never goes away. The tree grows a layered replicant of itself each year. Cut any branch and you'll see the rings just like in the trunk or our cherished lumber.

Tom