I'm building a trestle table for some friends. It will look like this, mostly:
My question is, how long do the tenons joining the uprights to the base need to be? My longest router bit will cut a 1/2" X 2-1/2" mortise. Is that long enough, or do I need to make the mortise and tenon longer?
Also, is a 1/2" thick tenon enough or should the thickness be increased to 5/8" or maybe even 3/4"?
1/2x2 1/2 deep should be fine. Get much longer, and the cross grain forces start to come into play. If the wood thickness gets close to 1 3/4, I would consider two 3/8 tenons.
It has several inherent weaknesses. If you only mortise 2.5", then just below that, it seems to me would pretty easy to break by splitting along the grain, if someone tried to move this table alone, by lifting one end while dragging the other.
Splitting along the grain is the weakest of all the wood properties, and that is a fairly short distance across that line.
But due to the height of the arc up from the bottom, there is an even shorter line along the grain on each side.
I think you could make it a lot stronger by taking some of the height out of that foot piece. Maybe you like the way it looks, but I see it as a piece doomed to fail.
As for your limited router boy length, it is not too hard to chop another inch of depth, using the routed mortise as a guide.
Sounds like plenty of tenon to me, and like Dick I worry a bit about the grain orientation more than the other concerns raised.
I made a trestle table once at work, I want to say the tenon was 1/2" by 1", and pinned, but that was long enough ago that the details are fuzzy. I don't think we made the foot grain parallel to the upright - but our foot was much smaller than that one, so we might have done that and just glued the joint.
I think I would approach this with three tenons in line rather than one long one.
Since the "leg" grain is perpendicular to the "foot" grain, Would he be better off to glue only the center tenon and pin the two outer ones with an elongated slot in the tenon?
Yeah, I have to think about it to remember what we did. It was a looong time ago I may still have the shop's catalog around, that would help jog the memory perhaps.
Gluing the center of the tenon or the center tenon of three makes sense.
I suppose one could also do a wedged through tenon like an old door - that is probably what I would do if not following orders - in someone else's shop, like the only time I built something like this.
I am no expert but I just saw a recent issue of FWW at the Library that featured a similar table build. I can recall the joinery but seeing what they used will help. The issue is likely a couple of months back. Inasmuch as a router issue, take a 2x4 and a firmer or mortise chisel and you will be amazed at how fast you can cut a mortise. This may not work well due to the 1 1/2" width you need but it is food for thought.
I would make the tenon one third of the thickness of the base. I also would have a shallow stub tenon most of the length and a pair of full length tongues separated by an inch or so. 2 1/2" should be plenty deep for the application. I would also use a couple pegs.If the wood shrinks and glue fails that base could drop off some day.---Jack