Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Stupid (Prairie) Dog Trick

Posts

Stupid (Prairie) Dog Trick

#1

Stupid (Prairie) Dog Trick

William Duffield

Anyone who builds Federal furniture, I'm sure, knows who Steve Latta is, and has probably encountered the idea of his bench-on-bench. I built one a few years ago, based on his design, and I keep experimenting with alternative work holding methods. I've attached a Moxon vise to it, added removable wheels, and built a few sets of auxiliary jaws for the end vise. I've also drilled more dog holes in it than I can count (and have used them all for various and sundry purposes). A feature of Steve's bench that a lot of people really like is the tilting jaw attachment for the end vise. It's a lot cheaper than an Emmert. If you just build Shaker and Stickley furniture, you probably "won't get it", but it enables holding of non-rectilinear parts, like tapered legs, while you are joining them or decorating them. When I added my tilting jaw to mine, I didn't follow Steve's lead exactly. His tilts off the rear jaw, while mine tilts off the front jaw, which has a serendipitous advantage. The addition of a pair of Lee Valley prairie dogs to my auxiliary jaw allows me to hold flat, irregularly shaped objects on top of the bench.


http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=70156&cat=1,41637,41645

This enhancement works with the single row of dog holes Steve drilled down the center of the top, so you don't need my three rows of dogs to take advantage of it. This addition would also be useful to the carvers who have also adapted the bench-on-bench concept in their work. Except for the brass, these include Kaare and Bill in the Hay Cabinet Shop,

http://anthonyhaycabinetmaker.wordpress.com/2013/12/24/a-carvers-platform-3/

The block of oak I originally used to build the jaw was sufficient for tapered table legs, and the dog holes in the top for holding the legs lengthwise on top. To use the prairie dogs, however, it needed to be thicker and flush with the top of the bench. Thus, you might notice some seams in my jaw. I debated building another one, but couldn't find an appropriately sized block of oak in my scrap pile, so I just glued a couple of fillers to the front and the bottom.


The prairie dogs are very convenient, because I don't need to pull them out and store them when they would just get in the way, and playing "Whack-a-Mole" with them can be therapeutic.

Re: Stupid (Prairie) Dog Trick

#2

Ellis Walentine

Keeps getting better

Ellis Walentine

Nice innovation, William, to an already over-the-top (no pun intended) bench. I'm wondering what keeps the auxiliary jaw from tilting backward when you grip something between the three dogs.

Thanks for the post.

Ellis

Re: Stupid (Prairie) Dog Trick

#3

Re: Crud!

William Duffield

As Obi-Wan would say, "Use the Force, Luke!" But, as soon as the Jedi apprentice loses concentration, it fails. I did warn you that it was a stupid dog trick, didn't I? :( There's ABSOLUTELY NOTHING to keep the jaw from tilting and letting go of whatever you are trying to hold!

I hadn't had a chance to actually thoroughly test it. The jaw continued to rotate; it still held tapered table legs; the dogs popped up when needed and down when I wanted them out of the way; the magnets kept them from falling out of the jaw when I took it out of the vise and set it down on a shelf. What could possible go wrong?

I'll try to find another use for the Prairie Dogs. They're too long to use in the dog holes in the bench top, which is only 1-7/8" thick. They need a dog hole with a bottom, preferably with a washer and a steel screw in the bottom, not a through dog hole. I'll try plugging the bottoms of the holes in the front jaw of the vise. It's always been inconvenient to raise the regular brass Veritas dogs in them.

My problem is I have a tendency to invent a tool or jig in anticipation of a perceived or a future need, and then let it sit until that need arrises. I wouldn't have needed this one until the next time I hauled the auxiliary bench to some remote location, as I have a patternmaker's vise that performs most of this function when I'm working in the shop.

Thank you for the insight, hopefully before someone else goes out and tries to build one.

Re: Stupid (Prairie) Dog Trick

#4

Re: Stupid (Prairie) Dog Trick

Ron Berlier

I have not seen this type of vise jaw previously where can I find out how to build one? Thanks!

Re: Stupid (Prairie) Dog Trick

#5

Re: Stupid (Prairie) Dog Trick

William Duffield

For starters, I assume you have read the conversation between myself and Ellis, and therefore realize that your build should not include the superfluous prairie dogs. That will make it smaller and simpler. That said, I don't think there are any "plans" as such for this one, or for the original built by Steve Latta. It's not difficult to figure out. I have some more pictures of my build, but no measured drawing.

You can build and install this so it engages either the front jaw of your vise or the rear jaw. Steve Latta's engages the rear jaw, but mine engages the front jaw, and I also built a vertically tilting (horizontal axis) auxiliary jaw block that engages the rear jaw.




The back aux. jaw has a very esoteric purpose and is not nearly as useful, so I won't discuss it further. (Your customers probably aren't rich enough, anyhow.)



Materials are only a 4" or 5" length of 3/4" hardwood dowel and a block of hardwood, whose size depends on the size of your vise. Mine happens to be quarter sawn white oak 4-1/2" high, 1-3/4" thick and 9" long. I used typical machines to square the rough lumber: jointer, planer and table saw. For subsequent steps, I used a router table and band saw.

You will also need a 3/4" core box router bit (or a #6 round plane that matches the dowel).

Take the front hardwood jaw off your vise. Find and mark the center, horizontally. Do the same to the auxiliary jaw. Lay out two tapers in the back face of the aux. jaw block, from the center of the 3/4" diameter groove you are going to cut in the next step, to a point on each end that is about 3/8" from the front face of the aux. jaw. Continue the layouts around the ends and bottom of the aux. jaw block. Cut a 3/4" diameter vertical core (a round bottom groove, 3/4" wide and 3/8" deep) in the center of the face of the vise jaw, from the top of the jaw to the hole where the screw passes through. Cut a matching core in the auxiliary jaw block. With the bandsaw, cut two wedges off the back of the aux. jaw to the layout lines. You might want to true up the bandsawn surfaces with a bench or block plane or a disc sander. Glue the dowel into what's left of the core (about 60°) that you cut in the aux. jaw block, and trim it flush top and bottom. I haven't had any problem in three years with the cross grain glue joint. Relieve the edges and corners. Finish with whatever you use for your bench and other bench appliances. Reinstall the front vise jaw.

I hope this helps. If it's not clear enough, I'm here to answer questions.

Re: Stupid (Prairie) Dog Trick

#6

Re: Stupid (Prairie) Dog Trick

Ron Berlier

William - thanks for the photos and the information. Everything is very clear now and I think it was not knowing it was a hardwood dowel being used that had me a little perplexed. But I'm up to speed now, again thanks!

Re: Stupid (Prairie) Dog Trick

#7

Re: Prairie Dogs Will Be Back!

William Duffield

I'm pretty sure I've figured out how to fix my problem. Right now, the vise is disassembled, all the supplies are collected, and I'm working on the implementation of the fix. Pictures, explanations and instructions will follow, later, when I'm finished and I've tested it. This would have been a lot easier if I had known I would run into this problem when I was building the bench, vise and aux. vise block.

Re: Stupid (Prairie) Dog Trick

#8

Ellis Walentine

Re: Prairie Dogs Will Be Back!

Ellis Walentine

Seems to me the trick would be to secure the bottom part of the auxiliary jaw to the fixed jaw somehow. It would have to be a pivoting arrangement. Let us know what you work out.

Ellis

Re: Stupid (Prairie) Dog Trick

#9

Re: Prairie Dogs Will Be Back!

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

That's exactly what I'm thinking. I've started working on the enhancement, but have been away from the shop for the weekend, at a SAPFM meeting at Poplar Forest. I'll fill in the details when I get home and can finish the build and testing.