Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

OT - will paper birch resprout from the stump?

Posts

OT - will paper birch resprout from the stump?

#1

OT - will paper birch resprout from the stump?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

It's been suggested that I repost this question on the main board, because some of our arborists hang out here, so here goes:

We've got a small (maybe 4" diameter trunk at breast height) paper birch growing too close to the house and in the way of the phone lines (it was a volunteer). I've topped it once, and, in less than a year, it's back up to where it was. Today, the head gardener and landscaping aesthetician approved taking it out, yay!

I've become far too familiar over the years with trees that will resprout from the stump - after we had a locust cut down in front, to promises by the tree company foreman that cutting it to ground level would kill it, we had sprouts from the stump and from roots all over, including in the crawl space, until I killed the stump.

Is paper birch a species whose growth "spirit" is in the stump, or will cutting it down to a stub kill it? It's very close to a little redwood of some sort, possibly a dawn redwood, that is staying, so I'd rather not get into digging it out; but will if needed.

Re: OT - will paper birch resprout from the stump?

#2

Re: OT - will paper birch resprout from the stump?

del schisler

cover it with something that will keep light from getting to the stump, if a bucket will fit , of course cut it down tell the bucket fit's over and down into the soil, or a tub , that will take care of it comming back

Re: OT - will paper birch resprout from the stump?

#3

Re: OT - will paper birch resprout from the stump?

Barry Irby

Cut it off low or flat to the ground and then pour Round-Up directly from the bottle onto the cut stump. Then covering it with heavy black plastic or a bucket as Del suggests is a good idea too.

Re: OT - will paper birch resprout from the stump?

#4

Wax myrtle

Tony - Memphis

I need to try that with a wax myrtle. Great tree, but in the wrong place. This thing has sprouted up all ove the place! Amazing. I love the smell of it. I had to cut it down (multi trunk) because more of it was in two of my neighbor's yards than mine. I think it was shaded by an oak and that caused it to grow funny. Anybody tried the copper nail trick? Or is that an old myth?

Tony

Re: OT - will paper birch resprout from the stump?

#5

Re: OT - will paper birch resprout from the stump?

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

Drill a ~1" hole in the leveled stump. Fill the hole with Roundup. Re-fill over the next couple of days

Re: OT - will paper birch resprout from the stump?

#6

Re: OT - will paper birch resprout from the stump?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

The Round-Up may or may not work as it is targeted for weeds rather than woody plants; that's why you can use it around trees and bushes. We have a huge issue around us with Russian Olive and the accepted way of killing it is to cut it to a low stump and then immediately drill several holes and paint the cut surface with a full strength 2-4D concentrate brush killer which will migrate into the roots and kill them as well. The danger with this approach for you is that Redwood you mention because the brush killer may remain "soil active" and migrate to the other tree.

Re: OT - will paper birch resprout from the stump?

#7

I have done this.....

Barry Irby

On Crepe Myrtles, briers, and a number of other woody weedy type plants and it worked. I can check, but 2-4D might also work, but I have not tried it. I used Round-Up without the black cover and it worked. I also tried the copper nails and they seemed to have little or no effect.

Re: OT - will paper birch resprout from the stump?

#8

Myrica cerifera, Metasequoia glyptostoboides

William Duffield

The problem with wax myrtle (a.k.a. bayberry, Myrica cerifera) is that it also sprouts from the roots at long distances from the stump. This (and salt tolerance) makes them valuable for stabilizing dunes, and they grow wild on the Jersey Shore. I got rid of one of mine with a double bitted felling axe and an adze-hoe. The other one, which is right next to my foundation, is still "on the list".

I would think Sebastopol would be a little on the dry side for coast redwoods (Sequoia sempervirens) to thrive. However, dawn redwood should do fine. Here, on the Midatlantic coast, Metasequoia grow very vigorously, much faster than other conifers planted in the same habitat. The only problem with them is they're deciduous (like bald cypress and larch).

Re: OT - will paper birch resprout from the stump?

#9

Oh OH!

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I just LOVE IT when he talks dirty . . .

;)

Re: OT - will paper birch resprout from the stump?

#10

Coast redwoods

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

We have a healthy coast redwood at the top of the driveway. Coast redwoods take in about 40% of their moisture through their needles, much of it from fog, and we get plenty of morning fog, summer and winter, since we're less than ten miles from the coast.

From the advice I've been getting, I think I need to work on the roundup question; there's some resistance here in the household, since some of the research is showing some persistence in the environment (interestingly, from the adjuvants as much as from the "active" ingredient).

Re: OT - will paper birch resprout from the stump?

#11

Re: Adjacent trees

Doug Wolf

I had a similar problem with a Juniper and an Apple tree. I cut the apple tree just under ground level and was about ready to put Roundup onto the stump when I read the warning on the bottle of Roundup that said "If there is an adjacent tree that you want to save that has has comingled (or something to that effect) roots then there is a chance the roundup will not only kill the apple tree but also be absorbed in the inter twined roots of the Juniper".

I decided to just cover the stump with a couple inches of dirt because the last thing I want is to lose a Juniper out of my border of 20 Junipers.

You might get lucky and the roots aren't that close together but it's a chance I wasn't willing to take.

Re: OT - will paper birch resprout from the stump?

#12

Good advice already

Tom Dunlap

Lots of good advice.

Copper nails killing trees and stumps is a bit of a myth.

The catch with using glyphosates [generic Roundup] is that most concentrations that are easily available are too low to kill woody plants. If you go to a garden center or commercial supplier you might find a higher concentration of active ingredients.

Almost every garage has a bottle of old herbicide on the shelf. Using some care and usual cautions there is likely something there than can be used to kill stumps. If you're going to be able to kill the stump all you need to do is dampen the fresh cut surface. Don't put on so much that it runs off. Use rubber gloves, etc. If you're going to drill holes do it around the edge in the sapwood. There's a chance that the herbicide will disperse into the cambium and kill the roots.

Some plants will root sprout too. In that case you have to deal with the sprouts like small trees. Sometimes digging them up is the best solution.

Getting someone to grind the stump is economical too. You might find several neighbors and get a group price saving the stumper several trips.

Rental yards have stump grinders too. They are dangerous and sometimes as rambunctious as a bull.

Tom

Re: OT - will paper birch resprout from the stump?

#13

Re: Coast redwoods

William Duffield

An incorrect assumption on my part. I'm familiar with Silicon Valley, where the rain shadow from the Coast Ranges is a lot more significant than in the Sonoma Valley.

Re: OT - will paper birch resprout from the stump?

#14

Yep

Tony - Memphis

Interesting, I didn't know they were used for that. Yes, mine is sprouting up all over the corner of the yard it is in. It seems more determined since I cut it down. I sure hated to do it, but it was really getting to be a problem. Thank goodness for patient neighbors!

Tony