Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat - Handles
Gary smyth

Tonight’s tool chat is about handles. I will not be able to chat, but I wanted to vent about the dumbing down of tools, or buyers, or both.
Last Spring I cracked one of my favorite ax handles. Off I went in search of a replacement. After a decent local retail search I found two (bottom of picture). The plain handles were essentially identical and had $12.00 stickers on them. What I wanted was one like the shown in the picture second (and fourth) from the top. Note that the thinner sections in the old handles are no more than about 1 1/8" thick. (The straight handled "camp" ax is about an inch at it's thinnest.) Those two are comfortable, fit my hand, thin, lightweight, and, in use, have a “whip” to it. The new ones were fat, not nearly as curved, and clunky. There is no comparison to the shape and feel of the fawn foot between the old and the new.
In order to do what I wanted I took the bottom handle and band sawed the shape and shaved and sanded the thickness it to get me closer to the older handles, I added some stain but even though it is unmounted it does not have the feel that is the earlier ax handle.
Had I not decided to compare old and new, I likely would have accepted the new handle but instead I got angry about what is today an "acceptable" handle. $12.00 is not a lot of money, but it is if it is wrong, then I get ticked. In the case of the new handles, more is not more.
One option with my weekly garage sale travels was to do some checking. The other pictured axes are what I found, average price (and with head), $6.
I’ve stopped looking for axe handles, but I learned yet another lesson. Beware of new stuff. Look at older stuff to see what worked when craftsmen used more talent and less ease. Little things make big differences. Get what you want because it’s out there. I know that some will ask about the grain of the wood. Well, I keep my axes very sharp, I don’t use an ax every day, I don’t have to clear land, and I don’t deal with large first growth trees. I’m betting in my lifetime I’ll have no problems with thin, elegant, “springy”ax handles and if I do I’ve a spare.