About six months ago, I came across what I thought was a Popular Woodworking Magazine. In it or on the cover someone made a box with wood, metal, and stone inlay. I've been looking all over for it. If anyone knows of this magazine, please let me know.
Thanks.
On another note, it seems as if woodworking shops no longer employ woodworkers. All I see in them are folks operating machinery. Pretty soon, if not already, woodworkers will be a thing of the past and robots will be making cabinets and furniture. What is to become of us?
Many years ago, in the late 1950's, when I was a young boy, my grandfather told me that automation was the way of the future. He was right. He also suggested I find a job that was exempt from mechanization. Here we are in 2014 and there aren't many jobs that allow people to work with their hands for a decent wage. Computerization has gone to far to fast. Don't get me wrong, I use computers to draft and communicate. But what I don't do is place input into a CNC machine and let contraption do all of the work including the assembly.
I know there will always be a place for us, but the price we charge in a throw away society is almost impossible to obtain.
Our only hope to stay alive in this business is to provide a superior product, guarantee it for life,(with the exception of normal use and abuse) and stand behind our product even if it means doing small repairs for free especially if we are going to charge thousands of dollars for our work.
Thanks for listening to me rant. It was something I needed to get off mff my chest.
It has to do with the dumbing down of our society.
Or perhaps I should phrase it the other way, everybody goes to college.
They don't want to nor do they believe they should learn manual arts.
The high schools and junior high schools have mostly if not all abandoned manual arts.
Probably has to do with the concept of college top priority and concerns about liability.
When I was in 9th (back in 1969) I took a woodworking class and a metal working class.
I then went to a private high school which didn't have any shop class at all.
Not my choice but I got into a good college. I went on to be a computer engineer.
I learned the rest of woodworking by watching videos and reading books.
And the school of trial and error.
When I went to Trinidad State Junior College in Trinidad CO for gunsmithing, that they also had a woodworking curriculum but the course descriptions looked more like it would be using machines. (I could be wrong)
There are several sides to the issue of handmade wood products and several reasons for the changes in society regarding these items.
When I was a youngster in the 1940 ~ 50's, you very rarely saw a "new" hand made piece of furniture in the "average" (working man's) home.
Most of the furniture was handed down from generation to generation and repaired as required. Once in a while a new bride and groom might get a present at the wedding (if they had fairly well to do close relations). Most of the furniture in my parents home was well worn and shown the use of several generations of ancestors.
Even today the cost of labor and material to hand-make, say a kitchen table and chairs is beyond the reach of the average person. A skilled woodworker ~ even with the normal shop electrical tools will spend weeks if not months to produce a quality table set. Even at a very low shop / labor overhead rate of say $30/hr that equates to $1200 a week + materials.
With the advent of automation (for better or worse) factory produced furniture became economical enough for the average person. Is it as well constructed, with matching wood and beautiful detailing? - Nope, but you can purchase a new, nice looking kitchen table set for less than $1000 that is nice looking and quite functional.
The issue is that most of us can afford to drive Fords and Chevy's but can't afford to buy hand assembled Rolls Royce automobiles. Is there a market for hand built quality furniture, certainly ~ but it is limited to the "few" that make enough money to have quite a lot of disposable income. I think there will always be Craftsmen that train to build this furniture, but similar to blacksmith doing artisan work, there will be few. However hobby woodworking is in my opinion actually on the upswing. This is the furniture that will be passed on to the future generations.
As an aside, when I was young I started an Appliance repair shop. I repaired TV's, Radio's, Irons, Mixers, Fans, and many other small items. Today this is a lost art. None of today's appliances are designed or built to be repaired. In fact the cost of these items are less than it would cost to repair them in most cases. In the 40's a steam iron cost 1 or 2 days wages for the average worker ($10 to $20), The Mixmaster and most other appliances were also expensive items. In the 50's very few towns and cities did not have repair shops for these items ~ other than factory warranty stations you would be hard pressed to find any now.
The picture shows a simple chest of drawers made in a shop employing a lot of hand work. It's price is a few thousand dollars which seemed fairly priced compared to similar pieces I have seen made in small shops employing traditional construction and techniques. If you are not buying your furniture from these shops you are not supporting the manufacturing you are complaining about disappearing. I would venture that that amount of furniture made in the shops with largely hand labor is in balance with the market willing to afford this product.
I don't buy my furniture from anyone. I make my own, and I sell most of what I build. What I'm complaining about is people being put out of work because of machines. If you don't like that, too bad.
When was the last time you read Cabinet Maker Magazine. Check one out and you'll see what I'm talking about.
Just because you're one of the utmost authority on WoodCentral doesn't make you right.
Buy the way, why should I have to buy furniture from another company when I can make my own. Self sufficiency has been the cornerstone of this country since it's origins. If more people would learn to do things for themselves, the U.S. would be better off instead of relying on others to do what they cannot.
I would imagine that when the first person made the change from a flint copper tool for his work there was somebody else chiding him for abandoning true craftsmanship. Then came bronze. Then came iron. Then came power. Then came carbide. Then came CNC. Then came laser. Then came...
I use machines when that is the most practical way to accomplish what I desire. I use hand tools when necessary. If I were buying furniture then there is no doubt that I would be buying machine-made stuff, economics being what they are -- regular folks just can't afford to have a manual-only craftsman build custom furniture for them.
I think I remember saying something about self sufficiency. Remember, woodwork, metalwork, sculpting, painting and the like, are taught or self taught. It has been the basis of our country since before we became independent colonies. It is alright with me if you want to give your money to other countries like China. They own us anyway.
And it applies also to tools, who buys top end hand made tools, like japanese tools. Those chests don't necessarily work better than plastic crates. With the floods that seem increasingly common chests that are made to float have a real advantage. One has to see the benefit to whatever it is one is after, and if it isn't there, move on.
is a romantic myth, David. "DIY" wasn't invented by the people who colonized this continent and then formed this country.
It may have been a necessity on the wild North American frontier 300 years ago, but Humanity's march towards specialization has been continuous for thousands of years. The carpenter wasn't the baker. The baker depended on the tinker to make him bowls, and the miller to make his flour. The silversmith needed the smelter who needed the miner for his materials who, in turn, depended on the shipwright to build the boats to move the ore, and who all depended on the blacksmith to forge the tools they needed.
You're not seriously suggesting that everyone make their own furniture, are you? How about the myriad of objects you have surrounding you? You didn't make all of them, did you? Of course not.
As our world becomes more complex, humans must rely more and more upon specialization and dedication to discreet areas for the efforts of individuals. The "throw-away" culture you describe has arisen as the result of economic necessity. If less durable but cheaper goods have the capacity to provide the most benefit for an expanding population, that becomes the real world norm. At the same time, distinct and true craft will always have a market to those who a) can afford it, and b) appreciate it's true value. Keep doing what you're doing, service your own "market", and don't worry about the IKEA shoppers; they neither were nor ever will be your customers.
Shop (a big one) if I could come in and measure and copy some of his stuff. His immediate reaction was to be horrified and say NO! I pointed out that I did not want to fake the pieces, was not trying to trick anybody and that we would have completely different customers. Any one that was buying a "reproduction" Would not buy an original and vice versa. Come to think of it, I should have taken more advantage of this after he changed his mind.
I took Memsahib and two friends to the Nakashima compound in New Hope, PA. Before we got there I cautioned everyone not to ask about making something that they saw as it would be highly insulting to the people working there. I did, however, provide insights on things like construction details and finishes as we walked through the various sections on our "self-guided" tour. At one point one of the staff asked me if I was a woodworker. I replied "yes" but that on that day I was only serving as "color man" and that I left my tape at home. It brought a chuckle.
I really don't know, but machinery changes the nature of jobs. Somebody has to design and build the machines. Somebody has to run them. Somebody has to maintain them. Transport them to the job. And scrap them in the end. The "other" argument is that these jobs are better jobs, less physical, than the grunt jobs they replace, and better paying. I just don't know. How about a job that can't be exported?
"Self sufficiency has been the cornerstone of this country since it's origins. If more people would learn to do things for themselves, the U.S. would be better off instead of relying on others to do what they cannot."
That was certainly no suggestion, Dave.
Regarding machines vs. hand work, with an ever-increasing population and the need for products' cost within the economic realities of most people, hand labor has become far too expensive to sustain as a method of general manufacturing. Craftsmen cannot work for 19th Century wages and support their families in the 21st just as companies can't charge 19th Century prices or meet modern demands for product and stay in business. Has automation (in all areas) reduced baseline manufacturing jobs? Certainly. But economies do adjust as new industries and jobs are created.
I think your view is a bit near-sighted, but, of course, I could be wrong. I would not, however, have any fear of woodworking skills being lost to antiquity in a haze of machine oil any time soon. The personal allure and satisfaction of working this unique material with hands-on effort will be sustained for as long as there are trees
Enough already. I'm beginning to see everyones point. But if you live anywhere near New Orleans and have seen old time woodworkers making hand planes and irons, copying obsolete moldings, you'd understand that woodworkers are a dying breed. I still am trying to make the same point, that machines are putting people out of work.
were created due to the current demand for "throwaway" furniture. As I said in an earlier post, my parents home (and almost all middle class families) had almost no furniture that was made less than 50 years earlier. Obviously there were very few "craftsmen" employed to produce these objects. Today almost all young families have homes filled with "new", albeit lower quality (and cost) furniture. Most of this furniture will have a very limited life compared to the "hand built" furniture of the earlier generation, and will be replaced periodically. Certainly the workers that build this "new" furniture are less skilled at traditional woodworking, but they are employed and earning a living.
In all reality, life is much easier now then when I was young. In my small town during my youth, there were no homes that had air conditioning. Several had outhouses - regardless of how "quaint" an outhouse is - those of us that did avail ourselves of them have few fond memories ~ especially in winter.
We tend to remember the "good times" and forget the ugly. I do remember the dentist visits, deaths from now curable diseases, snow on the inside windowsills, and hard labor required to do many tasks now done by machine. Yeah fuel was cheap, but homes were quite cold in winter, with long johns worn inside. Very few homes had any insulation - no thermopane windows etc. And even though fuel was cheap, labor was also, food took a great deal of a persons pay, little was left for "entertainment" or even necessities.
I remember on cold winter mornings, neighbors that were lucky enough to have their vehicle start, would jump their neighbor - this continued until most were again able to go to work. (often after inflating a flat tire).
Grocery stores in the area had only local grown fruit or vegetables (in season) or canned items. I did not have Pineapples, oranges, or most other tropical grown fruits until I was an adult. Greens were a spring / summer treat. If a family today were living like the "normal" families of the 40's they would be considered in poverty!
aren't what Dave's talking about. He rightly observes that paying jobs for skilled craftsmen (and women) are being lost to automation; the automated factories have replaced the local furniture-maker shops of barely 70 years ago, and the market for truly custom millwork appears to have shrunk in favor of vinyl-coated sawdust moldings from the Borgs. The work of true craftsmen and women is becoming the provenance of the upper 1 or 2% of the population, and the great majority of people have little or no appreciation for quality workmanship. Where cabinet shops of 20-40 woodworkers served the needs of people who appreciated well-made items that would last for generations, we now have factories of 100s of operators who may be largely clueless about the material they push or feed through the machine in front of them. CNC programs and engineered materials have replaced "measure twice & cut once" for a large portion the furniture-making world.
While Dave's observations seem to be based upon his local area, I suspect that if we could inventory the number of woodworkers producing quality work in this country, the numbers might not be so significantly reduced from say 100 years ago. However, that number, expressed as a percentage of the population, would, no doubt, be much less than in them Good Ol' Days.
To those writing about losing jobs to automation or thinking automation is better in the woodworking industry, let’s look at what’s happened in the far and recent past.
Alexandria was burned to the ground, losing all knowledge of the ancient world.
During the Roman Empire, concrete was lost for a thousand years.
When the Romans fell; we had the dark ages and the spread of disease that killed 1/3 of the world’s population.
The horse and buggy has been replaced by the automobile.
World War I killed 37 million people.
World war II saw the advent of the atom bomb and we've lived under the threat under the threat of nuclear annihilation ever since.
The blacksmith was replaced by the Industrial Revolution.
The gas lamp was replaced with electricity.
Netflix and Video on Demand replaced Blockbuster.
When was the last time you saw film get developed?
When was the last time you used a paper travel map?
When was the last time you applied for a job in person?
Payphones went by the wayside. Oh, I forgot Obama gave everyone cell phones.
Telephone books, encyclopedias, and libraries have been replaced by the internet.
Dialing 411 is no longer necessary due to the internet,
Cd’s and DVD’s were lost due to digital streaming.
Floppy discs have been replaces by a flash drive no bigger than 1” X ½” X ½.”
Most of the stamps went. 90% of our bills are being paid digitally.
Social networking means never having to sociality interact with people.
Around every corner, there are cameras watching everything we do.
High quality figured lumber is harder to get and if it available, it might cost you six months salary.
This is just a small list of things we've lost due to technology.
So, please don’t tell me that machines aren't taking over our jobs. To science, we
David Frame
P.S.
To science, we owe dramatic changes in our smug self image
By the way, I found the magazine I was looking for. It was Popular Woodworking April 2014 Issue 210
I never suggested that automation was a completely bad thing. There are things that machines can do that humans cannot and vise versa. I just mentioned that fact because of the mechanization of woodwork. People are losing their jobs, especially craftsman.
The reason for my comment is because I just received the new copy of Cabinet Maker Magazine. It lists the IWF in Atlanta. Over 75% of the advertisement is about buying automated machinery. And if anyone thinks automation is less expensive, their wrong.
A one or several off of something made by machinery costs more than if someone is made it by hand. On the other hand, if the machine makes a thousand something’s, money will be saved.
By the way, if you noticed the beginning of my WoodCentral message, I was looking for magazine. I finally found it. It was a Popular Woodworking Magazine for 2014, issue 210. It was a box made by Autumn Doucet. She has inlaid paua abalone strips and mother of pearl in it. It also has a myriad of woods in it. That is what I was looking for.
It seemed like everyone made such a big deal about my comment on automation.
I think I’ll continue to do my woodwork the old fashioned way.
All too often we overstate our position on an issue in an effort to support our point of view. I'm fairly sure you weren't advocating going back to pit saws and water-powered mills.
I've had friends who closed up shop because they couldn't compete on price with the factories. I've also seen supposedly hand-made products in high-end furniture galleries that displayed a distinct lack of craft despite their sporting 5-figure price tags.
We bought our kitchen cabinets from a local home improvement center, only to learn later that we could have gotten better cabinets at the same price from a local cabinet shop. So some things can still be done locally by individual craftsfolk, albeit with lots of electrons burned.
Are you talking in genral, or only about woodworkers, because more broadly it already happened years ago. That video about the scissor makers said there was some extraordinary number of them at one time in the one city 40K (?) now they are down to just a few. Of course it wasn't really machines, it was cheaper labour over the same machiens, but either way, the first 39,994 jobs are already gone.
"The work of true craftsmen and women is becoming the provenance of the upper 1 or 2% of the population, and the great majority of people have little or no appreciation for quality workmanship."
I don't know about that, most of the rich people are buying crap also, just different crap. For instance there are many multi million dollar homes that have drywall in them. What is weird about some of this stuff is that certain things get better, like entertainment technology, communications, or cars, but other stuff gets worse, like furniture and clothes. There seems to be very little lower limit on how crappy the average or even upper class american eats, dresses, or sits. That is the odd bit, most people are a lot better off, and admittedly have many more calls on their money, but something like shoes are just crap. The pickup I drive is in every imaginable way (other than prestige) better than a Mercedes of an earlier time. I only once took a ride in an RR, and I think it was the 70s. Crap compared to my F-150. But the other stuff we consume is often terrible.