Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Forgot, What do I treat log ends with (paint)?

Posts

Forgot, What do I treat log ends with (paint)?

#1

Forgot,  What do I treat log ends with (paint)?

Ronster

After cleanup from some very recent wind falls, a friend has a couple of large diam. walnut logs. 8.5' long. If I find these to be in good shape, what do I paint the ends with? Spare latex paint ok? Can they be stored long before sawing?

Re: Forgot, What do I treat log ends with (paint)?

#2

Rick L

Anchorseal

Rick L

Cutting into boards sooner than later results in the least checking and splitting. Last year our shop did a job where we use actual tree trunks as posts for a timber frame project and we drilled a 2 inch hole through the tree trunks to minimize checking and splitting. Getting rid of the pith helped tremendously. Of course not everybody has a drill that will drill a 20 foot long 2 inch diameter hole, but we do.

Re: Forgot, What do I treat log ends with (paint)?

#3

too late

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If the log ends have started to dry coating them will have little benefit. Coating the ends has only some benefit in any case, especially for 4/4 lumber. Your best course of action is to get the logs to where they will not be baked in the sun. Get them sawed soon and on sticks with the top and ends of the pile shaded, but with good air circulation through the pile.

Anything that retards moisture transport will work- paint, varnish, linseed oil, wax. I have dried a thousands of bdft of lumber and the only time I did end coating was when drying very thick lumber, 12 and 16/4. I do not feel it is worth the effort for thinner lumber. Bottom line, if it is convenient to do, do it. If not, don't fret. The lumber will be no different than the other millions of bdft of hardwood that is not end coated.

Re: Forgot, What do I treat log ends with (paint)?

#4

Re: Forgot,  What do I treat log ends with (paint)

Keith Newton

I've had good luck with latex primer, but not with any old paint that needs a primer.

Re: Forgot, What do I treat log ends with (paint)?

#5

Now THAT's a drill!

Tony - Memphis

Holy cow! Got any pics? Sounds like a neat project too. I cut a wax myrtle down a few months ago. I saved asection that is ~4' tall and ~7" diam. I noticed the other day that it has a huge crack about two feet in length from one end. I was surprised that it cracked that much and that long. I wasn't saving it for anythign in particular, just for fun. I may cut it up sometime to see what it looks like. I'll not plant another one of those things without giving it plenty of space and sun. They do smell nice though.

Re: Forgot, What do I treat log ends with (paint)?

#6

The truth

TomD

They make wax log treatments for this, nd they are highly effective. Walnut is very valuable so they are worth it. High quality white latex is next best. Stuff that builds a thick coat.

With a downed tree, I may not do anything. So for instance, I have a decent oak that got blown over. It is still rooted, and it has it, s leaves on. It could stay like that for a long while with little loss. Contrary to Bill, s usualy correct statement, leaving the leaves on, which accelerates drying, will reduce checking, or not hurt anything.

Re: Forgot, What do I treat log ends with (paint)?

#7

real world data

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There is a log collection yard not far from where I live. Passed by there yesterday and there were several truck loads of walnut logs piled there. Probably waiting for the right price to sell them. None were end coated. I have seen many loads of walnut and white oak veneer logs traveling down TN- 11W headed for Indiana and Ky veneer plants. Never seen one end coated. In fact I have never seen any log anywhere end coated and I have seen a lot of logs at a lot of mills in this area, and few other places. That said, it must be done under some circumstances somewhere or Anchorseal would not be in business. I suspect it may be common practice when manufacturing turning squares.

When veneer logs eventually get to the plant they will be kept wet with overhead irrigation to keep them from drying out. I am told it keeps the bugs out too.

The point is that end coating provides at best a small benefit that in some cases can be worth the expense and effort. Books and articles targeting the home wood worker can make it sound like this practice is ubiquitous; it isn't. Again, if convenient do it. If you don't get around to it your loss will be small, or nonexistent. The home drier will be better rewarded for time spent fretting over how and where the lumber is stacked for air drying. It is this step where inexperienced wood workers loose value that far exceeds the minor losses from log end checks.

Re: Forgot, What do I treat log ends with (paint)?

#8

If you google, *LINK*

Keith Newton

"Economics_of_EndCoating_to_Prevent_Checking" you will find 202,000,000 answers.

Like Bill states, around here, none of the logs on trucks going to the mill have been painted, the logs are cut 6" longer than their desired lumber length. They also go from standing in the forest to the mill yard in the same day, where they will likely be stacked under a sprinkler until sawing.

After becoming boards, they get cut to their final length, 1" over, and are stacked with all boards in the stack of the same length. I think this is when they get sprayed with their color coding.

You can read more in the link below than I have time to answer.

When I'm sawing on my mill, I'm also the end user, so I coat them as early as I can, and this is the length it will be until I cut the lumber into parts.


http://www.woodweb.com/knowledge_base/Economics_of_EndCoating_to_Prevent_Checking.html

Re: Forgot, What do I treat log ends with (paint)?

#9

Re: Anchorseal

Keith Newton

Hey Rick, I have had a need to do that several times lately, and would like to see your setup, or a source what you have found to work best. Thanks K

Re: Forgot, What do I treat log ends with (paint)?

#10

Re: Data, or experience?

TomD

I imagine if that was the business the OP was in, he would already know how to do it. From his last sentence it seems he may be planing long term storage prior to cutting. Long term for uncoated ends can be a few hours, or as long as necessary.

By the way Bill, you do everything else so why not, but do you actually harvest your own logs for your own small shop, and do all the steps yourself? Or do you buy your wood from others. It is like anything else, the approach in a small shop is often different.

Also, the white emulsion stuff was made by BP, Mobil, and I think Shell, among others. I don't imagine they were making it just for the laughs.

Re: Forgot, What do I treat log ends with (paint)?

#11

Re: real world data

Barry Irby

This is one of the imponderables of harvesting wood. At least for the small user. You can cut in the summer and get differing results than if you cut in the winter. Differing species offer different results. If you are cutting for a living and for a lifetime, you might get a better feel for it than if you cut something every five years for your own use. Most of us don't have a chance to run any sort of controlled study. To do a definitive job of it you would need to cut many trees over a long period of time and control all the variables. Non of us does that.

You can go over to WoodWeb and get a lot of information. You can also go to the Forest Products Lab and get more. I researched this years ago and my understanding is the Forest Products Lab found that end coating was not worth the expense. Expense being the operative word here. If you are buying coating and paying someone to do it and the wood is abundant the trade off may not be warranted. OTOH if the wood is scarce or expensive, or personally valuable to you, and you work for free, and the coating is cheap, go for it. Even then you will not be able to tell if you were successful. If the wood does not crack, take the credit. If it does, OH! Well, it may have cracked even worse and you tried.

I harvested some walnut years ago and coated it. I tried coloring the ends of the logs to keep track of which boards came out of which tree. I doubt anyone in the industry really cares. The color faded and my best efforts were thwarted.

Re: Forgot, What do I treat log ends with (paint)?

#12

Re: Not Bill ~ but

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I do have a few thousand BF of Walnut, Cherry, Oak, Hackberry and other rough sawn lumber. The bulk of it was purchased at Estate sales from Amish / Old order estates. NONE of the wood had been end coated - I also purchase quite a bit of wood from a local mill, again none has been coated. None of the wood has been "trimmed" and I purchased much of it as a stack, often 1 tree / 1 stack. There is very little loss from end cracks, about what I see from Borg lumber.

One particular estate had a home built saw mill - bigger than most local mills I have visited. It was powered by a case tractor front end / engine and had a 48" lower blade and a 36" upper, the carrier was made with Railroad rails and I estimate the travel exceeded 25'. That estate had one building about 300' long (old turkey farm) X approx 50' wide - there were also 2 large barns and a smaller building - all were filled with air dried wood. The auctioneer told me it took two days with fork trucks to move enough wood outside so customers could get into the building to bid. All of the wood looked great, very little end splitting, many commercial buyers were there with semi's and trailers. I purchased 3 large trailer loads myself.

Re: Forgot, What do I treat log ends with (paint)?

#13

Re: too late

Sgian Dubh

Bill, my observations from another country of larger sawmill operations are that I’ve never seen an end sealant applied to a sawlog, with the implication being that few, if any, sawmills see a financial benefit in the practice so my conclusion is that end sealing is either rare or virtually non-existent.

Granted, here in the UK our logging and milling operations are generally much smaller scale than is found in North America, but uncoated ends of large piles of logs in a yard are the norm. I'm aware of smaller operations such as furniture makers that mill their own wood that do end coat both logs and boards they're drying for their own use. But these people aren't in the business of supplying wood to other businesses or amateur woodworkers.

There are examples of other less than ideal practices later in the process at the drying stage. For example, near me in North Yorkshire we have a yard that specialises in air drying native species in the open, primarily for the upholstered furniture market. 'Good Practice' suggests these piles of stickered boards should have some sort of protective sheeting over the top so that the top boards aren't exposed to the elements, and thus degradation and loss of value. The yard owner is adamant that the extra fiddle-faddle of end coating boards and covering the top is a time cost that isn't sufficiently compensated by the extra value of the timber offered for sale. He also has wood burners for heating, and uses many of the damaged top boards of his stickered piles in that during the winter, as well as for other uses that at the moment escape my memory. Slainte.

Re: Forgot, What do I treat log ends with (paint)?

#14

Re: Not Bill ~ but

TomD

Well again, I am not arguing what commercial people do with their wood, I am suggesting that 1) someone is using all this sealant, I don't know what that means but someone out there does; 2) one would be wise to do so if one wanted to maximize the yield of the wood one harvested for oneself. I mean I doubt commercial turners in large industrial operations core a bowl then stuff the shaving back with the bowl in a plastic bag for initial stabilization, but this is a time tested method that works in a small shop that handles wood that one paid a fair amount for, and will not get a mark-up on. Commercial producers can waste half the fiber, and there is always the plywood mill, or the heating plant to capitalize on the waste, etc... Not how you roll when you carry each piece of wood out of the forest with your back.

Re: Forgot, What do I treat log ends with (paint)?

#15

Bill knows lumber drying quite well, but... *LINK*

Grant in Iowa

Bill is unarguably wise and very experienced about how it is done in his area, and I respect his many years of experience milling, drying and selling lumber.

I am just thinkerthunking here, but it seems to me that the idea is to slow down the drying process so the wood can dry more evenly, and therefore check less.

So, maybe it is that in Bills neck of the woods, the air has enough moisture in it to allow reasonably slow drying. The kind of slow drying that doesn't cause excessive checking. And maybe his nearby lumber mills know that too.

And maybe, if you live somewhere that has very dry weather (other than in winter), it makes a lot of sense to end seal wood. It could just be a regional or climate thing. Here in Iowa, it varies with the year whether we have a humid summer or a fairly dry summer, so it is hit and miss. We can have humidity near 100% one day and under fifty the next. And in winter it gets to near zero % RH often, and for extended time.

I will say that I recently visited Johnson Wood Products (link and photos below) and was given a tour of their extensive drying and storage sheds. They specialize in Black Walnut, and much of their stock is full of figure, and is therefore very valuable. They air dry everything, and they put a date on each piece as it is put up to dry with a lumber crayon. I saw many dates in the sixties and seventies on their shelves. Everything on their shelves is end sealed. EVERYTHING. And figured woods are sealed wherever figure is evident. I don't think they would do this if it was a waste of time and material. I will also note that I didn't see much end check on most of their stock.

Their stock fills at least five machine shed sized buildings, some multi level.

They also have an extensive turning blank stock. Same process, all end sealed.

If you think about their customers being both hobbyist carvers and pro gunsmiths, you would likely agree that the cost of an improperly dried gun blank would be very high in terms of customer relations. This is a three generation business.

What I am really saying here is each of us are different. We have different needs, resources, and climates. We make different projects with different woods from different mills that differing skills, equipment, shade, sun, time, and rates.

I end seal my logs bound for sawing in to lumber when given the chance, time and resources. It might be a waste of time if things go just right with the drying process. For me, end sealing is worthwhile insurance.


To each his own.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa


Johnson Wood Products