Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Samantha's dresser-16 applying final finish

Posts

Samantha's dresser-16 applying final finish

#1

Samantha's dresser-16 applying final finish

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Finishing

Applying a finish to a piece of furniture has two purposes, and a bit of personal philosophy. The finish alters the appearance of the raw wood and the finish provides a protective barrier to the wood against physical and chemical(spills) damage. The finisher must optimize these two functions.

The school of minimalist finishing, the Krenov followers for example, focus on the appearance and largely ignore the protective role of the finish. This strategy can be successful for a wall cabinet that functions more as decorative art than furniture. A farm house oak floor with three coats of polyurethane could represent the other extreme. Furniture builders mostly find themselves between these extremes and we are forced into a compromise between appearance and durability, or even tradition in the case of reproduction work.

I found myself standing beside a magnificent mahogany pie crust table carved by one of the leading furniture reproduction craftsmen of the northeast. Other reproduction enthusiasts were also admiring the work when its maker showed up. Someone asked in more of a statement of fact than a question, “Is it French Polished”? “Oh, no”, the maker replied, “it’s polyurethane”. A gasp could be heard from the onlookers. He went on to explain that this table was made to be used in his household and hence it deserved a durable protective finish.

There are two conclusions from this tale. The first is to finish according to function. Second, appearance has more to do with the way the finish is applied than the chemistry of the film former. There was not a person among the onlookers that recognized this application of polyurethane from French Polished shellac.

I spray my finishes. It is fast and the result is glass smooth when done right. Ideal spraying conditions are a great assist to me doing it right. I like cool to facilitate leveling and dry to avoid water condensation.

PIC 1 spray gun


I use a DeVilbiss spray gun with a #30 cap. One is a type “MBC” and the other a “JGA”. They seem equivalent in my hands. They are commonly available used and they are inexpensive. They use a modest amount of air at 35 psi. For this project I am finishing with Sherwin William Kemvar “water white” (which means it is an aliphatic resin varnish not aromatic which will yellow in the sun) conversion varnish. It has a bright luster like shellac or lacquer. It is hard to resist scratches and it is resistant to household chemicals including water. We can wash furniture finished with this material. It may have been developed for kitchen cabinets.

Additionally, for this piece I want a close to the wood look. A thin film application achieves this appearance no matter the material applied. Hence, the finish is diluted 1 part xylene to 3 parts varnish.

PIC 2 scuff sanding


The weather the day I finished was an ideal 70 degrees in the AM. I applied the first wet coat of finish, allowed it to dry about an hour and then lightly sanded with 400 grit stearated paper. I prefer to hand sand at this step with a piece of folded paper and no pad. I want the paper to follow any contours of the surfaces.

PIC 3


After scuff sanding, the piece was blown off with compressed air and tacked with a tack rag. One final wet coat of thinned finish was added to the sides and 2 coats to the top to provide more protection. I want scratches to not penetrate the finish into the wood where they would be difficult to remove at some later time.

PIC 4 finishing the interior



Finally, the interior is finished with two coats of Zinser shellac, lightly sanded and waxed to provide a nearly frictionless travel for the drawers. Shellac is easy to apply, it dries quick and sands smooth.

Re: Samantha's dresser-16 applying final finish

#2

PS= Figure

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

A dull finish hides figure so this fact becomes another decision. The feature of this piece is its figured drawers and more than average figure on the sides and top. Hence, the piece demanded a bright finish to not subdue the wood figure.

Re: Samantha's dresser-16 applying final finish

#3

Re: Samantha's dresser-16 applying final finish

TomD

"The school of minimalist finishing, the Krenov followers for example, focus on the appearance and largely ignore the protective role of the finish. This strategy can be successful for a wall cabinet that functions more as decorative art than furniture. "

I don't think there is a proportional difference there. The same criticism could be made of the spray poly guys, as they are obviously concerned with the look of the coating, and it's shine, and generally are willing to concede on either heavy wear or long term issues. Krenov, for whatever reason he became famous, does have to consider a lifespan beyond his own. His furniture could conceivably still be in demand several centuries hence. We know several things about the scientific super finishes: One, they have no long term testing or track record; two, the experience has not been reassuring so far, many finishes do not look too good down the road; three, they will be very difficult to identify, even should they be recoatable, or workable in the future.

As far as short term durability, some of the modern finishes crack and shear when dented in heavy use. Traditional oils and such do not armour the furniture, but are easily recoatable. I made an art table for one daughter, that was really a cherry and hickory end table. She trashed the surface, a couple of whisks with a plane, and half a year under the oil, and it looked great again. Can't do that with 2 pack super finish.

Also, light use is not a non-furniture use. Most of the best funiture is lightly made, it isn't proletariat grade, but nonetheless it is furniture.

"I found myself standing beside a magnificent mahogany pie crust table carved by one of the leading furniture reproduction craftsmen of the northeast. Other reproduction enthusiasts were also admiring the work when its maker showed up. Someone asked in more of a statement of fact than a question, “Is it French Polished”? “Oh, no”, the maker replied, “it’s polyurethane”. A gasp could be heard from the onlookers. He went on to explain that this table was made to be used in his household and hence it deserved a durable protective finish."

What is "use"? People lean up against bus stops in their best suits, while waiting for the commuter. Welcome to the slobetariat. Slob living is normal. I was brought up very frugally with silver, tea cups that had saucers, and had my first custom suit (short pants) pretty much as I got out of diapers. A men's custom suit was about 60 dollars in the 60s-70s from an Irish tailor; tea cups were more environmentally friendly than endless paper landfill, and the silver was something you could pass on. I now have some from my wife's family. But if you are a slob, you better armour everything with epoxy, because you know someone is coming by with a drippy scratchy cup to put on your repro from another time and place table.

Furniture and finishes usually tell a story and in some cases it is of tastes that rise well above the level of the owners manners. How people want to live is up to them. Why shouldn't they be a mess if they feel comfortable that way. Though it is perplexing, the hunger for finer things. My only point is that in some places living requires a bullet proof vest, and in other places we are on good terms with our neighbours and don't need such heavy protection. I guess if you live with the vest, the other way of living may not seem possible.

All typed while dressed in sweats with holes, in transit to the wed whacker and chainsaw.

Re: Samantha's dresser-16 applying final finish

#4

Clint Searl

Re: Samantha's dresser-16 applying final finish

Clint Searl

The pie crust table anecdote is telling. Poly and other synthetic resin finishes can be manipulated in the application process to achieve any desired appearance while delivering greater durability than traditional film finishes, especially shellac; yet there seems to be some prejudice in the woodworking community that modern formulations "just ain't right."