Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Samantha's dresser- sanding and staining

Posts

Samantha's dresser- sanding and staining

#1

Samantha's dresser- sanding and staining

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Sanding and staining The secret to good staining is proper surface preparation. One must not mistake sanding to 1000 grit with proper surface preparation. Proper surface preparation is uniform sanding to remove all machining defects to a grit size appropriate for the wood, stain and finish. In my case I end at 180 for this project.

For this project I began with 120 grit for one part and 100 for another part, determined by how much machining defects I needed to remove. Hence, my sanding sequence was 100, 120 and 180.

PIC 1 defects visible


The first picture shows an inadequate amount of initial sanding. There is a glue stain top left and some faint planer ripple on the top center. Good light is a must.

Pic 2 torn grain not removed


In picture 2 we see a dull place indicating torn grain that has not been removed. Any place that is dull after the last sanding step is a place with torn grain. The torn grain is catching sanding dust and it will similarly catch pigment stain. These places will absorb stain more than the rest of the piece and make a dreaded blotch.

PIC3 end grain


End grain must be bright after the last sanding step. In this case it will stain no darker than the flat grain.

PIC 4 Finished side


This picture shows the finished case side. It must be a uniform dull at his stage, indicating no torn grain, planer burnish, or glue stain.

PIC 5


This picture shows the stained back of the top. The stain is 10 % Japan color Burnt Umber, 10% linseed oil and 80% General Finishes wood conditioner (which is what GF uses for pigment stain base). For this piece I stained a bit lighter than typical to enhance its more modern look. I compensated for less stain with a bit of oil to enhance the figure. Stain is applied with a rubber like shellac, squeezing out stain as the rubber is rubbed across the surface. With this technique over staining is avoided. Only about 50 mL of stain was used for the whole case and probably half this amount is stuck in the rubber. You can choose to like the stained color or not. It is what it is and will largely stay that way forever. My monitor shows it a bit redder than reality.

PIC 6 stained side



After staining the figure in the wood begins to come out. It will come out more when the finish goes on

PIC 7 finished piece


Re: Samantha's dresser- sanding and staining

#2

PS

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In the next and last installment I will reveal why there was a large time gap in this build. It has to do with a change of horses in the middle of the stream resulting from the concurrent independent opinion of two artists that said I was on the wrong track with my intended feet. Changing feet in the middle of a build is not nice. I was left with the advice to "keep working on it till you get it right". Not useful advice for someone design deficient. But they both agreed that I got it right eventually, after consulting every book of furniture I own for inspiration and numerous failed prototypes.

Re: Samantha's dresser- sanding and staining

#3

Clint Searl

Re: Samantha's dresser- sanding and staining

Clint Searl

While I agree completely with the necessity to start with an evenly sanded surface to 180-220, the process of applying color depends on several factors: water or alcohol dye stain; pigmented oil or water stain; stain combinations; clear coat; etc. The choice suggests an individualized stain and finish schedule which achieves the desired result.

Re: Samantha's dresser- sanding and staining

#4

Pic 2 torn grain not removed

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

How did you resolve the torn grain? More sanding? Card scraper?

Just curious.

I love how your walnut finishing schedule works. I've used it (or at least my best attempt at duplicating it) and the end result of the color and so on is very nice.

This dresser is looking fantastic.

Thanks for the continued updates.

Thanks.

Re: Samantha's dresser- sanding and staining

#5

torn grain removal

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It takes a lot of sanding to remove torn grain. A card scraper works much faster.

The torn grain in the picture was on the edge of the top which has a broadly spaced curl. I had hand planed the top with cap iron set close to mitigate tear-out and indeed the divots I used to experience before the cap iron discovery were avoided. However, there was still a small amount of torn grain at this particular grain reversal and for whatever reason it was stubborn. Oddly this area was way more difficult to deal with than the much more figured side shown in the pictures. I never got it perfect, merely good enough. The risk is to make a depression while removing the torn grain. A depression on the top would show because of the lighting. On a side I would have risked more material removal.

Re: Samantha's dresser- sanding and staining

#6

One of the disappointments......

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

.....in writing up this series is that others have not joined the conversation to describe alternative means to get a similar result, be it framing the case, making the drawers or choosing and applying stain as examples of what others may do different or even better. This additional discussion would have been of great value to the people learning.

Re: Samantha's dresser- sanding and staining

#7

Re: One of the disappointments......

Henry W

Bull - not having made a case piece like this, I can't add much to your excellent write-ups.

I can say that I love the detail you have included.

Many thanks.

Henry

Re: Samantha's dresser- sanding and staining

#8

Re: torn grain removal

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Working with some seriously gnarly walnut with grain going every which-a-way, I seem to have the best results with torn grain by using my 3x21 belt sander riding in a sanding frame with fresh abrasives that are cleaned often. The frame holds the platen and belt parallel to the work surface (preventing bellies and digs) and the micro-adjuster allows me to to take the just barest amount of surface needed to resolve the problem. I've actually been able to remove the finish on thin veneer plywood without losing the veneer this way.

Is the result perfect? We all know there's no such thing.

I really did give the card scraper a shot with careful honing and raising the burr, but even with rounded corners I still had some divots and tool marks that had to be sanded out.

Just a note on planing, with sharp knives you can prevent a lot of tear-out by wetting the surface to be cut with a light water mist.

Re: Samantha's dresser- sanding and staining

#9

Re: torn grain removal

Jesse Cloud

In the spirit of your lament that few offered alternatives to your description...

One technique that helps in the repair of torn grain is to apply a light coat of glue size (diluted glue) to the area, let dry, then scrape with a card scraper. The glue size helps avoid further tearing. It will not show up in the final finished surface.

Re: Samantha's dresser- sanding and staining

#10

Good idea...

John in NM

I'll have to try that next time. Hide glue of course?

Re: Samantha's dresser- sanding and staining

#11

Re: One of the disappointments......

Paul in NJ

Rob Millard, the Federal Period furniture maker, has a finishing schedule for walnut that he described in his blog. It was a lot of work but I was pleased with the results when I tried it. It warms up the cold tones of the walnut and keeps the walnut from fading. You start with orange transtint dye followed with a light coat of sealcoat shellac. Next came a grain filler and another light coat of shellac. Then a quickly wiped off coat of minwax mahogany stain for a glaze. Finally a few more padded coats of shellac and a rubout with wax and 0000 steel wool. Sorry about the poor quality pictures.

Paul Dzioba



Re: Samantha's dresser- sanding and staining

#12

Re: One of the disappointments......

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

I have to agree with Henry W.

I read your posts to learn.

I really can't add anything... :(

Re: Samantha's dresser- sanding and staining

#13

I don't like water

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

I prefer to use mineral spirits instead of water.

I just don't like to use water around my tools. Although, I suppose a quick wipe on the board wouldn't do any harm.

(Plus, my basement, er, awesome woodworking shop, is damp enough as it is...)

I don't know if using mineral spirits is bad for the rollers and what not, but it's about 15 years old now and still keeps ticking.

ETA: read Marks next post in this thread. Using mineral spirits is probably a stupid thing to do...

Pretty much like you said Mark, I've found keeping the rollers clean, having sharp knives, and giving the board a quick wipe with mineral spirits valuable as far as reducing planer problems.

However, all that said, I find myself using hand tools more and more (for no really good reason). I typically only use the planer to get close to final thickness, then use hand planes to get to the final thickness. Same in regards to my jointer; I usually use hand planes to get one side flat before using the planer mostly because the jointer is usually too small (6" Delta).

With the little half round table I recently completed, I used mostly hand tools for the curly maple top out of necessity. Using a sharp iron, tight mouth, and the cap iron set very close/tight, I was able to plane the top nicely. I had very minimal tear out that was easily fixed with a card scraper. Sanding was minimal also.

It's amazing how quickly you can get things done with nicely tuned hand planes. Even hand saws. It is so quick to grab a saw and cut a board. Even rip it. No set up. Just grab it, cut it, done.

Sorry Bill, getting off topic and rambling. I'll leave now... :\

Re: Samantha's dresser- sanding and staining

#14

Re: I don't like Flameables

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

in the dust collection system.

ADR, Joe, but I would caution any readers against this. Steel on wood creates heat and a errant spark in that planer could easily start the last fire you'd ever not want to see.

I keep my planer bed waxed so a couple drops of water won't hurt a thing. I keep a spray bottle of "tear-out preventer" next to the planer. Works on the jointer as well. ;)

Re: Samantha's dresser- sanding and staining

#15

Yikes!

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Thanks Mark.

I never thought of that. Sounds pretty dumb to use mineral spirits now that you say that. I'm sure I read about using it here a long time ago, since this is the only ww'ing forum I frequent, but I don't think I will now...

Thanks again.

Re: Samantha's dresser- sanding and staining

#16

Wise Choice 


Re: Samantha's dresser- sanding and staining

#17

Re: One of the disappointments......

John Pappas

Perhaps, even if one had a valid alternative method, they just appreciated what you had to offer, and considered it "your parade" and simply let it be about you and your fine craftsmanship.

Re: Samantha's dresser- sanding and staining

#18

Adam of Oakland

Re: PS

Adam of Oakland

Bill thank you for your notes on this build and I'm especially curious about the foot recalibration process you mention here. I'm thrilled you will devote a separate thread posting on this as it leaves lots of questions about, well, the process.

do you make cardboard models? drawings? power point presentations (my god i hope not!). do you ever throw your cards down and call your critics for philistines?

end of the day: i love to make something that someone else loves, too. so i can understand struggling to please someone who cannot articulate exactly what they want, but what i got is not it, so i must keep dancing until it works!

Re: Samantha's dresser- sanding and staining

#19

Evil machine

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I regard the belt sander the most difficult machine I own to learn to use and use reliably. Torn grain is easy to deal with compared to belt sander "digs".

I am not questioning your ability to get good results. And when skillfully employed a belt sander does do an excellent job of removing planer defects. But I would caution the novice not to jump on a table top with a belt sander until your proficiency is proven. (voice of painful experience here. I get to look at the screw ups on a 100 year old cherry table that was my great aunts wedding present every time I eat dinner).

Re: Samantha's dresser- sanding and staining

#20

Taming The Beast

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

The key is the supplemental frame that holds the sander. I have a Ryobi 3x21 worm-drive for which a frame is made. PC used to make one for one of their sidewinders; don't know if B&D has continued it.

The Ryobi frame rests on the wood surface and holds the sander above the wood. You then use a micro-adjuster to carefully lower the belt's contact point until is just touches the surface. By keeping the belt's contact surface parallel with the wood, those sander "digs" are eliminated completely, and the frame indexes that contact patch to the surrounding wood surfaces to prevent over sanding and control removal of high spots. I've used this rig for years (before I got the P-Max 22-44) to flatten stock too big for my little 13" planer. True, I had to work through the grits, but it's just right for the job, especially when working with large heavy slab table top material that I don't feel like hiring 2 men and a boy to help me move around the shop.

Re: Samantha's dresser- sanding and staining

#21

Followup on torn grain

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The picture shows the stained and finished top. The place with the recalcitrant torn grain is bottom left center. The clarity of the wood here shows that the torn grain removal was good enough. An variation in shade is due to desirable grain figure. With torn grain the stain over absorbs in the area and results in a dull or opaque spot.


Re: Samantha's dresser- sanding and staining

#22

Re: Good idea...

Jesse Cloud

I've only done this a couple of times, both times on African Mahogany, but I just used plain ole titebond with a 10 to one dilution with distilled water (in case the wood has any tannins). Finished just fine, maybe something to do with Bill's point that the torn grain absorbed more of the stain than normal - maybe the glue size offsets that???

Hide glue is a good idea, in any case!

Re: Samantha's dresser- sanding and staining

#23

Prefer Shellac

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

to glu-siz in this application. Using a spritz of dewaxed shellac at about 1/2lb cut will raise the grain just slightly and stiffen the wood fibers making them easier to remove. It will also even out the wood porosity to mostly prevent blotching. Biggest problem for me with torn grain was the divots that would aggregate stain particles. Pretty much solved the remaining issue by going to NGR dye stain rather than pigments.

Re: Samantha's dresser- sanding and staining

#24

Interesting...

John in NM

African mahogany can be a real pain to plane.... and to stain, just to complete the rhyme :D :D :D

I'll have to give it a try next time, I have a couple doors to build in A. mahogany.