Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Rust electrolysis; stainless steel anodes

Posts

Rust electrolysis; stainless steel anodes

#1

Rust electrolysis; stainless steel anodes

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Another go around on using stainless steel anodes in de-rusting iron prompted me to dig further into the literature to further dismiss the claims some make about using stainless steel. (I use a huge spoon found on a canoe trip)

Background- Posted in the WoodCentral Articles and elsewhere is our description of the electrolysis process to de-rust iron objects. We recommended stainless steel anodes(electrodes) for this process. Stainless steel has the advantage that it is largely inert and doesn't crap up the bath like using rebar and other ferrous materials.

Shrill claims, unsupported by any data I have been able to discover or that have been provided by the claimants, have been made that using stainless steel anodes will result in the production of chromate (AKA Cr(VI)). Chromate has some toxicity issues that can be extrapolated to hysterical proportions by some. As a result I receive from time to time threats and dire warnings about our recommendations.

Here are some facts, including one new one I recently found.

1. Stainless steel anodes dissolve but a tiny amount in use. The tiny amount that dissolves after many hours of use , times about 17% the amount of chromium in stainless steel, is the most of any chromium species that can be in the bath.

2. I analyzed a bath used for a long time with stainless steel anodes and found only a few parts per million total chromium in solution. I do not know what form the chromium was in, the toxic chromate or the benign chromic form. But I considered this amount insignificant to worry about what ever form it was in.

3. Recently I searched the chemistry literature to see what might happen if chromate formed at the stainless steel anode. I found that any chomate that formed by dissolving the stainless steel anode would become reduced to insoluble chromic hydroxide at the cathode(the rusty part being cleaned).

If you encounter claims of hazard from using stainless steel ask for data to support the claim and in its absence direct the claimant to this post.

Chromate IS bad stuff to get into your lungs. I think it an extraordinarily bad idea to use it to color wood, especially when sanding the raised grain and generating chromate laden dust is common practice after coloring.

Re: Rust electrolysis; stainless steel anodes

#2

OC Comment

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Bill,

I don't use the process, so whether there's ugii-boogy chromate being produced is of no personal concern to me. However, since both your information and the responses of your "disputors" seem important to you, I would suggest that you include a link or links to your research information in your post and article because, otherwise, what you have to say is only your personal statement and will invite dispute unless you also disclose your sources. This is especially important since you wish to challenge your doubters by demanding their information sources.

Kind of a "sauce for the goose" situation, no?

Peace

Re: Rust electrolysis; stainless steel anodes

#3

citation

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Bockris, John O'M.; Kim, Jinseong, Journal of the Electrochemical Society (1996), 143(12), 3801-3808.

Re: Rust electrolysis; stainless steel anodes

#4

Re: citations

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

See? Wasn't that easy? Better yet, for those who steadfastly believe that anything that's not available via a "www" address doesn't actually exist (because they can't get off their FA and go look for it at the libary), copy and paste links if you gotz'em. :D

peace

Re: Rust electrolysis; stainless steel anodes

#5

"OC"

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Got an email . . .

"OC" = "On Topic" but "Off Center"

sheesh ;)

Re: Rust electrolysis; stainless steel anodes

#6

Re: Rust electrolysis; stainless steel anodes

William Duffield

If someone wants to search for the chromate VI ion (a.k.a. the number 6 in Roman numerals) they might be more successful if they searched for "hexavalent".

the OSHA standard PEL (Permissible Exposure Limit) for hexavalent chromate, which is a potent carcinogen (and not just if you live in California :D), is an exceedingly small 5 micrograms per cubic meter. This is not the ion that is dissolved out of our stainless flatware, even if we were spoon feeding the doggies in the Sigourney Weaver sci-fi flicks.

Re: Rust electrolysis; stainless steel anodes

#7

air vs other exposure

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Units of micrograms per cubic meter is a measure in the air, hence, reference to respiratory exposure. Hexavalent chromium (AKA chromate, dichromate and Cr(VI)) is a known carcinogen via respiratory exposure, which is a world of difference from other sorts of exposure, for example dipping your pinkey in some. It is for this reason that I think it mindless to use chromate for coloring wood. I have tested and shown that chromate persists on the treated wood and will, therefore, be in the sanding dust.

I was at a SAPFM meeting a few years ago. In the "Show and Tell" session a high school teacher was showing pictures of student work......colored with chromate! I was aghast. I asked to be able to describe the hazards of this use but was denied. Some traditionalists wish to remain ignorant of the risk.