Cherry finishing schedule
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
To me unstained walnut or cherry has a raw informal look to it, suitable for some things and not others. Hence, I stain both walnut and cherry. Some protest that stain "hides the grain". You can be the judge of that from the pictures.
For years I stained cherry from a quart of Sherwin Williams pigment stain purchased in the 70's before they reformulated everything. When that ran out I went on a quest to duplicate this color, a reddish brown. I don't like red cherry and I don't like brown cherry. Goldilocks cherry is just right reddish brown. The result was a mix of 85% General Finishes "Candlelight" which is too brown and 15% ???? that is red. Can't make out the name but it may be cherry. In any case a mix of Candlelight and a red mineral stain or red Japan Color will get one to their preferred reddish brown. Because it is a mineral stain (iron oxides of one sort or another) the color will not fade.
My staining technique has been described here many times and it involves using a "rubber" dipped in stain to control the application density. A quart of stain will last nearly a life time with this technique.
Top coat on bed is shellac. Top coat on table is Sherwin Williams conversion varnish.
Most important is sanding. I sand to 220 on cherry and the sanding must be defect-free. If there are any dull places they indicate torn grain that is catching sanding dust. They will over-absorb stain and go dark.