Re: Air Filtration System
Alan in Little Washington (NC)
To reiterate and expand on a few points already made and add a few others:
The air cleaner will only filter as well as the effectiveness of the filters you use. If you put cheap furnace filters in it, don't expect good filtering.
An air cleaner only filters the air that passes through it.
Combining the first two points- if you put MERV 16 or HEPA filters on the air cleaner it will do a much better job filter fine dust- BUT, again, it will only filter the air that passes through the filter.
The more effective the filter, the lower the air permeability- lower CFM. The CFM figures for different filter combinations are typically not available, so you may want to start with the highest CFM unit you can find if you plan to upgrade the filters
MERV 16 or HEPA filters in the 12" X 20"-24" size can be 4" thick or thicker and can easily cost $100 each. Like most filters, they can't be reliably cleaned and reused.
Most of the filters that claim they can be cleaned and reused don't filter fine dust well to begin with, and that includes the Gortex fabric pocket filters used in a lot of units. The filter area isn't the greatest either. Years ago Navy ships used filter elements made from steel mesh- kind of like coarse Brillo pads in a frame. Every couple of days, the filters had to be take to the filter shop to be washed in a tank, dried, then sprayed with oil, to improve their already marginal filtering effectiveness.
Many models of shop air cleaners take up quite a bit of head room. The thinnest is probably the Jet with a 12" tall cabinet, but after you add hooks and chains the bottom of the box is now almost two feet from the ceiling - and a real hazard for a typical basement shop.
If the size of the air inlet or outlet is small, just like DC ducting, the resultant CFM will be restricted.
To help keep your shop clean, get an air cleaner, but a good DC will do a better job, and if you have health issues, get a mask.
There may be a new air cleaner design hitting the market next year that does a pretty good job addressing these issues.