Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Chipping finish

Posts

Chipping finish

#1

Chipping finish

Michael Carr

Hey there!

I have a customer who has an interesting problem: She found small, white bumps on her antique piano and when she polished them off, the finish under the bumps was dimpled. I have no explanation as to what would do that, I was using joint compound on a ceiling in the general area, but that doesn't splatter, so anyone have any ides what might cause the finish to erode?

Re: Chipping finish

#2

hair spray?


Re: Chipping finish

#3

How Old is the Antique?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Have you determined what the finish is? If its after 1880 or so it may be lacquer; prior to that, most likely shellac.

You should find a spot on the undercarriage that you can play a bit and rub with denatured alcohol. If the finish starts to come off, you've got shellac to deal with. If alcohol doesn't do it, try a bit of lacquer thinner. Once you have the finished film id'd, you can formulate a repair plan which will vary depending on the film composition.

The why? sounds like a solvent got spotted on the piece and it degraded the finish film, although just plain water, if it gets under a shellac or lacquer the finish, will do the same thing. If its a solvent-based finish in shellac or lacquer, you can rebuilt the film by careful spotting in the dimples to build above the surrounding surface and then releveling and polishing the area. With some love and care the repairs can be invisible.

Re: Chipping finish

#4

Re: Chipping finish

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Would water splatters on shellac result in the observed finish problem.

I have repaired commercially made antiques as late as the early 1940's that have shellac finish.

Re: Chipping finish

#5

Re: Chipping finish

Howard Acheson

I would bet on the joint compound. Joint compound contains some solvents which can damage lacquer finishes. You can remove the joint compound by polishing but the solvents will already have their damaging work.

Re: Chipping finish

#6

Re: Chipping finish

Michael Carr

Thanks for the ideas, guys!

A little more info for you: The piano is "old". That's all I know. It appears to be walnut, and the grain is visible, so I'm fairly certain it's either lacquer or shellac. The pits are mostly about 1 millimeter, ranging to about 2 millimeters and not uniform in shape or size. I wasn't aerosolizing the compound, and when I left the job, the piano was clean of debris. There was some old paint spatter near the keyboard that, as I suspected, came right off with a fingernail and left no lasting mark, so I'm certain the pits are not from paint. The homeowner doesn't apply hairspray in that room, so that's out, too. I was thinking there was some sort of insect that might have been there, but nothing I've ever heard of does that, and the homeowner is meticulous about cleaning, so I don't think that's it. The spots are only on one section of the piano, the small part of the lid, and only on the underside of it. Oh, and the whole thing was under a plastic dropcloth while I was working over it. Personally, I don't think I had anything to do with the pitting, but I just thought I'd pick some brains.

Thanks again!

Re: Chipping finish

#7

Re: Chipping finish

William Duffield

Sounds like spider poop to me. It's the same stuff that causes "white paint spots" on antique Stanley planes.

Re: Chipping finish

#8

I'd Be Wary

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Sounds like those "pits" were there before you darkened their doorstep, and she's been looking for an excuse to charge someone (or their insurance company) for the restoration. In the situation you describe, there are two basic options to protect yourself in the future.

a. Require the homeowner to remove the item(s) from the workspace before the job starts and make sure to put that in the written proposal that the homeowner signs before work starts.

b. Inspect the item(s) not removed, document any damage with photos, wrap and tape the item(s), and have the homeowner sign a waiver covering accidental damage.

Putting a. and b. in writing carries out the basic premise and reason for a written contract: "To keep honest people honest."