Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

System 3 Epoxy

Posts

System 3 Epoxy

#1

System 3 Epoxy

Yonak

I've never used it but I see it mentioned frequently. I'd like to try it as a wood filler but I have some questions.

Is it easily sandable .. say, as compared to hardwood ? Will it sand clean off a smooth wood surface or does it leave a stain on the areas beyond the gap to be filled ?

Does it come in colors or can it be colored with, say, a coloring agent that is designed for it, or with paint (I assume oil-based) ?

I notice there are several buying options such as different quantities, a thickening agent and a drying agent. (Maybe more.) I believe I understand the usage of the drying agent and I don't think for my application it will be necessary. As for the thickening agent : the gaps I will fill will range from 1/32" cracks to pea-sized voids. Would a thickener be suggested ? Are there different thickeners ? I'd like to be able to spread it on with a putty knife and have it go deep into the crack (so fairly thin, but filling).

Finally, size : I intend to try it out for a project mixing a quantity, probably, a bit smaller than a ping pong ball and then if it works, get larger quantities for regular use. What is the recommended quantity to buy ? The quart seems pretty large if it turns out not to work as well as I hope and maybe there's a smaller size. Is there a kit available that would contain all or some of the items I need or should I get everything individually ?

Thanks for any replies. If this works out I would be using this product quite a alot. Maybe there's another epoxy brand that would be better or is System 3 pretty much the best ?

Re: System 3 Epoxy

#2

Re: System 3 Epoxy

Howard

I prefer West System epoxy. Their customer service is absolutely the best. Get a copy of their instruction book, very helpful.

Howard

Re: System 3 Epoxy

#3

instructions

Jerry Gibbs

West has an extensive and free on line tech manual. Epoxy can be mixed in almost any amount and thickened with a variety of fillers. Too big a batch can heat up and harden quickly, losing what is in the pot. It can be colored. It is not typically used where a clear finish and grain will show. Thickened epoxy is a great gap filling glue. For filling larger holes and gaps that will be painted, I use Bondo, which is polyester, not epoxy. I have never heard anything bad about System Three and it is cheaper than West System. Jerry

Re: System 3 Epoxy

#4

I Use It Often

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I strongly recommend an accurate digital scale as the mixing ratio is 100 parts resin to 44 parts hardener (what you call "drier") for small batches (under 4 oz of mix).

I use it as a gap-filling glue as well as to fill cracks and strengthen weaker/damaged wood. One example of this is the walnut crib I made for my Grandson.

Another is the table where the combination of epoxy and the butterfly saved what others might have cut out as waste

You can use it colored with opaque pigments. You can mix it with wood flour to thicken and blend with the surrounding wood.

You can tint it with alcohol soluble dye (like TransTint)

You can also use it to fill and augment "defects" to transform them into unique features

Re: System 3 Epoxy

#5

Re: System 3 Epoxy *LINK*

Jesse Cloud

I'm a fan of system three also. And have a couple of thoughts to add.

Its sands ok, but it scrapes brilliantly. If you have a good bump of it proud of the main surface, and few swipes of a cabinet scraper will save a lot of sanding time.

Since you specifically brought up "penetration", I'll also mention a penetrating epoxy CPES. Its great if you are restoring deteriorated wood.

Here's a link for that:


CPES at Jamestown Distributors

Re: System 3 Epoxy

#6

Re: System 3 Epoxy

Yonak

I'm still waiting for a call back from System 3's technical support department but, in the meantime, I have investigated Bondo, based on Jerry's suggestion. I guess I live in a cave .. I didn't know they made a two-part polyester wood filler that is Golden Oak-colored and the color can be changed with grout powder. I thought everyone was talking about auto body filler all this time. Robert in their technical department was very helpful. I'll try that, as well.

Thanks for your responses.

Re: System 3 Epoxy

#7

Jesper, Denmark

Re: System 3 Epoxy

Jesper, Denmark

Just one caution: the sand-ability greatly depends on the type of filler or thickening agent you use. Low density fillers and wood flour sand OK, but silicate fillers (West High density) eat both sandpaper and cutting/scraping tools.

Re: System 3 Epoxy

#8

Re: System 3 Epoxy

William Duffield

You got a bunch of really good answers already. I won't argue with any of them. Whether you use System 3 or West System (which I also prefer), it is important to thoroughly mix the resin and the hardener before adding any other ingredients (fillers or colorants). For coloring, I have used TransTint dyes, vegetable black (lamp black), powdered earth pigments (as used for coloring paints), and powdered tempera pigments (as used for coloring water colors). In addition to sanding and scraping, I've finished it with a hand plane, and even run patched wood through a power planer.

If you want a finished surface without (or with minimal) post-processing, transparent packing tape makes an excellent dam to stop unthickened epoxy from running out of cracks. After the epoxy is cured, you just pull it off. There are no releasing issues with it.

One significant advantage of West System is the broad range of hardeners. You can choose the appropriate hardener for the temperature of your working environment and the complexity of your glue-up. Another advantage, as has been mentioned, is the extensive application-specific documentation. Yes, it's more expensive, but not nearly as expensive as a glue up that has gone wrong because you missed an important detail specific to your job. System 3's documentation is pretty good, too, and often free with all but the smallest kits.

Buying larger quantities of West System resin and hardener is not a problem. The shelf life is several years, although the hardeners will darken as they get older. I have had problems with shelf life and container failures on System 3 T-88.

Re: System 3 Epoxy

#9

Small Caveat

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Last time I looked, Yonak, Bondo, in all of its varieties, forms a somewhat porous compound when cured. As such it needs to be well sealed and painted and may still present surface "shadow" issues when finishing. As you can see from my photos, epoxy doesn't have that issue.

Re: System 3 Epoxy

#10

Re: Small Caveat

Yonak

Thanks, Mark. I did receive a call from the System 3 technical department and he was able to answer my questions. I ordered some System 3 Sculpwood Paste epoxy filler. ..And I put Bondo filler in my Amazon.com basket and I will get it when I have $35 of stuff so I can get free shipping. Thanks for everyone's help.

Re: System 3 Epoxy

#11

Re: System 3 Epoxy

Chuck Bender

T88 is a great epoxy. I've been using it for 30 years (at least). Easy to mix, forgiving where ratio of resin to hardener is concerned and can be colored using several different colorants. It planes, scrapes and sands well (though my Dynabrade RO sander generates some heat that can soften the epoxy if not fully cured).

Re: System 3 Epoxy

#12

safety

Jerry Gibbs

sanding epoxy that is not fully cured is especially toxic, although cured dust isn't good either. Jerry

Re: System 3 Epoxy

#13

Re: safety

Yonak

How long does it take for the epoxy product to fully cure ? There are times when I must sand it early because my customer is waiting, anxious for the parts. Does the Bondo product have the same issue ? Is there a problem if I have to sand it before it's fully cured ?

Re: System 3 Epoxy

#14

Re: safety

Jerry Gibbs

refer to the product safety info of what you are using. If you can keep on top of the curing process, you can easily and safely slice the epoxy or polyester with a chisel, plane or sureform type rasp. Jerry

Re: System 3 Epoxy

#15

Re: Small Caveat

William Duffield

System 3 SculpWood and RotFix (components of the EndRot system) are really useful products. If you have the SculpWood, there's no need for Bondo.

If you are using them for typical architectural restoration, make sure you cover and protect them with paint. UV does serious damage to epoxy.

Re: System 3 Epoxy

#16

Re: System 3 Epoxy

TomD

"Buying larger quantities of West System resin and hardener is not a problem. The shelf life is several years, although the hardeners will darken as they get older. I have had problems with shelf life and container failures on System 3 T-88."

West last indefinetly. I used one can 20 years after purchase, the hardener had turned bright red, worked great.

West in my number one, but I can't always get it up here, so I have used System 3 basic resin. I have used MAS, and I just bought 6 gallons of Raka to try out.

For wood filling they are all OK, but there are important differences when using them for boats. The big advantage to using some basic product like West or S3 (regular), is that you can learn to use it in so many different ways. It is also cheaper that the premixed and coloured products.

Re: System 3 Epoxy

#17

Re: safety

TomD

This is certainly true, and for a pro, you need to mind your overall exposure. That said, people had been standing in clouds of the stuff for years, before this concern became all that commonly expressed. Care taken in the normal way, or wet sanding, should be all you need. I have it as a rule to never sand epoxy when making boats, and while not strictly possible, you can get a long way with it. A hack saw blade at an angle, out of the frame, is particularly good. Chisels, planes, surforms, and overcoating should be familiar.

Re: System 3 Epoxy

#18

Re: System 3 Epoxy

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

I've had some annoyances with the pumps. Sometimes, if they sit unused for a while, air will get in, and they won't deliver a full measure. If I suspect an air bubble, I get a small cup and pump one measure into it, and pour it back in the can after I've got a good measure. I recently had a problem with the resin pump. It clogged with some gelled resin. I had to go buy another set of pumps, since they don't sell them individually. l eventually cleared the pump by disolving the boogers with acetone, but I was concerned I wouldn't get all of the acetone out, so I haven't used it again.

Re: System 3 Epoxy

#19

Rise the Pump

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

with DNA.

BTDT mine's fine now.

However, I never rely upon the pumps for an accurate measure. I mix by weight to the precise 100:44 proportion.

Re: System 3 Epoxy

#20

Re: System 3 Epoxy

TomD

The pumps all go bad eventually. If you jiggle the pump at the top, it will dispense a full measure for a long time after it stops doing a full measure a stroke.

Since you are using system 3, you can buy plans for both gear and piston pumps from John Marples. System 3 used to sell them, and I didn't get them at that point. They took me over 10 years to find, and then one day I just new John was the guy who would have designed them. Bingo

Pumps are more than accurate enough for measuring. I normally use 0 ring syringes for small amounts, pumps for medium, and scales for large enough amounts that they work with a postal scale. What works there varies with the ratios as you need to dispense a lot of resin, to get an accurate amount of hardener in the pot, to be accurate depending on your scale accuracy, when working with the 1-5s.

I always say I am going to get myself a real pump, or do the Marples plans (only problem is that all the parts are too difficult to find in Canada), I would have to make everything, so it is just a little higher hill to climb. For sure, if you use a lot of epoxy real pumps are the only way to go.

Two other methods that work well, are to use a straight sided can and just mark lines on a stick, works great, but mostly for medium large batches. Another weight method I saw, was a guy built an elegant epoxy scale out of a sawzall blade. The pot hung from the fat end, and the teeth, facing upwards, were detents for the weights at the front. The way it worked was he had two weights (per brand) that were proportional to the epoxy weight mix ratio. So say you poured in some resin, then you would balance that with the resin weight at some tooth setting. Then you hung the hardener weight under the resin weight, and just added hardener to the mix pot until it was again balanced. Really slick.

West also has a method for mixing tiny amounts that uses surface tension.