Porter Cable recall *LINK*
Ray - Middletown, IN
Found this in the morning browsing.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Porter Cable recall *LINK*
Ray - Middletown, IN
Found this in the morning browsing.
Re: Porter Cable recall
William Duffield
Either the CPSC or WoodworkingNetwork didn't do their homework!
My 7518 doesn't have any handles, metal, plastic or otherwise. Does that mean it will electrocute me?
http://www.woodcraft.com/product/0/18196/portercable-7518-314-hp-motor-only.aspx
Surely, Porter-Cable isn't going to replace the handles on this one. It wouldn't do any good anyhow, because I never plan to use it with handles. It is permanently mounted on my router lift in my router table. The router lift, plate, crank, etc., are all metal.
Re: Porter Cable recall
Joseph Mulherin, sr
I would suggest wrapping the handles with pipe insulation and taping around the insulation.
Re: Porter Cable recall
William Duffield
If you are responding to Ray's message and correcting the problem that is addressed by the recall, maybe OK, until you wear through the insulation with heavy use. However, if you are responding to my message, my point was that most 7518 routers are sold "motor only" for permanent use in a router table. In this application the metal barrel of the motor is usually attached to a router lift, which will conduct electricity from the electrical components within the router motor to the router plate, which is exposed on the top of the router table. Whatever electrical failure caused the recall will still occur and still be dangerous in this application, and replacing the non-existant handle will not obviate it.
Re: Porter Cable recall
Bart Goldberg
Bill, I too have that PC router base permanently mounted in my lift - and I also got the recall notice in email. I am also wondering if I need to be concerned about this notice given the way I am using it (sans handles).
Bart
Re: Porter Cable recall
William Duffield
If the CPSC concerns are real, and I will assume they are, then yes you should be concerned. I am not overly concerned, because I built a GFCI into my router table, and the router and light switches and accessory outlets all feed through it. I would be smart to also ground the router lift.
Re: Porter Cable recall
Bart Goldberg
I called Porter Cable - the rep stated that there shouldn't be am issue with using just the motor in a lift, but even tho I didn't buy it with the base, they insisted on sending me a free base/handles.
Bart
this doesn't make sense ??
del schisler
if the handles aren't insulated for protection ?? just where is the voltage comming from ?? not the handles, so if the motor which is where the winding's could short out to the metal case and cause a shock ?? so the motor is the cause than why does just making the handles insulated ? that would help the person holding the router for top use , but now if just the motor in a router table , this problum could still be their ?? now i don't have that brand in my table , not it the router with sopose problum is in a table with a metal plate that could cause problum's ?? but if it is used in a hard plastic type than ever thing would be insulated, but the problum may still exist ?? i belive they aren't fixing the real item problum ?? my 2 cent's
Re: this doesn't make sense ??
Bart Goldberg
Dan -I agree - their Customer Support person didn't really help explain the underlying issue here. They are just CYA by sending me the base.
Just Following Orders
I got the email too...
John in NM
But like William, mine is in a router table so I'm not worried about it. I suppose there is a slim chance of getting a shock from the router lift plate in the table, but one could easily ground that. Perhaps I will 
Re: this doesn't make sense ??
William Duffield
Del, that was exactly my point.
I wish Porter-Cable would give us more information on the root cause of the problem, because now I have imagined another scenario which could cause the danger: If you were using the router hand held, installed in the base, and struck the cord with the spinning router bit, the base could easily become charged. This is a much more likely scenario than something going wrong inside the motor. However, it is extremely unlikely to happen with a router in a router table secured within a router lift.
You would think PC would be wise enough to just trade the new bases for the old, defective ones. This would get the defective bases "off the streets" and it would save them the cost of giving away new bases to those who own just the motors.
I figure if I change my mind and decide to use the router with a fixed base, I should have to buy a base, which PC does sell by itself. I think in that case they would sell me an improved, insulated base, instead of giving me one for free, now, just because I took advantage of the recall.
Please Confirm
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
You expect a company trying to carry out a CPSC recall mandate of many thousands of units to individually assess each customer's situation and adjust its remedy to various scenarios and variables dependent upon contacts with each of those product owners? Really? Can you guess what the cost escalation factor on the recall would be using that method? Given the time and personnel requirements, let alone the likelihood of mistakes, it might well be cheaper to just have all of the routers returned and be replaced with new ones.
William & Del, I'm not criticizing your analysis; only questioning your view on how the alleged problem is being addressed. Unquestionably they are using the "sledgehammer" approach of "we send a new base to everybody and this will solve the issue whether they use the unit hand-held or not since they might use it that way in the future so at least we did what we could to remedy the problem."
A suggestion: Since you think the proffered remedy (always worked out between the CPSC and the company) will not solve the "reported" issue, contact the agency in writing with your detailed reasons. That is the only way you might get anything changed because, at this point, the company is operating under an agency mandated procedure. It might not change anything, but you might get a more detailed explanation of the core issue that could exclude your concerns over getting zapped by your router table.
Re: Please Confirm
William Duffield
Thanks for the clarification, Mark. You are right, they can't do the fix selectively, and of course, they have already reached a "mandated" agreement with the CPSC. I now think their prooffered remedy will fix the reported issue, but that change in my opinion, as I tried to explain in my post that you responded to, is based totally on speculation. I don't think there is a hazard with use of this router in a router table.
Re: Porter Cable recall
Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana
I would wager that this recall is based on the "double insulated" issue where the tools/appliances were equipped with a 2 prong plug, with no grounding prong. I really doubt there is any real safety issue, but that the Gov'ment decided they didn't "double insulate" properly. Heck many older homes don't even have a ground wire attached to the duplex outlets. I can't say how many times I have used an adapter that allows a 3 prong appliance to plug into a 2 prong extension cord!
However I was raised in the 40's and they just started wiring new homes with Romax NM with ground around the 50's. My old house still has quite a bit of Knob and Tube wiring ~ I have rewired much of the house & installed a new 200 amp service, but am not going to tear up the downstairs ceilings or upstairs floor to replace the old wiring!
Will someone get a shock? Possibly, if the router is used in very wet conditions (as with any non grounded tool that isn't truly non- insulated), but it is very rare for a 120V shock to really be serious. I don't have one of the recalled routers, my 7539 is a plunge 3 1/4 hp and does have the insulated handles - but do have a very old Porter Cable router that is all metal, (and several of the 690's) and I sure will use it without worry.
Re: Porter Cable recall
William Duffield
That's another viable theory. I just had to go check on mine. I would have guessed that it had a three pronged plug, but you're right, it has a two pronged plug, which means it is a double insulated design.
Re: Please Confirm
del schisler
2 things if used only free hand , who's going to garentee that that will be the only way it is used, than the handle fix would solve that fix, which is realy not a fix at all but only a band aid for that use ? so now in a table with a metal plate the i guess the problum is still their ? now with a plastic place the problum is gone or maybe no shock on top, but when you adjust for height wouldn't the problum still be their ? the motor or cord or winding's could be the problum point ? of course we don't have motor's that have this problum to check out and see where it accour's and if the same in more than one , but the problum is still their reguardless of the handle fix, i been around electric all my life , fixed motor's and such , in radio and tv repair for 50yrs retired now so i know a little about electric item's , not saying i know about the trouble with the router's motor's but that is where this all is comming from ?? my 2 cent's
Re: Please
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
Del,
Rather than playing "what-if" games as to the cause, why don't you contact the CPSC or the company (or both) and ask what the specific problem is that prompted the recall action? Remember, the company and the CPSC both note that there has not been a single instance of the unit shocking someone. I seriously doubt this has anything whatsoever to do with the motor housing, switch, or internal motor wiring.
In my view, it looks like somebody just decided that uninsulated handles were not a Good Thing and should be changed as a preventative measure; nothing more.
To be really reeeely cynical, companies have insurance for this kind of thing. One way to get such a change covered by your insurance, rather than taking the full hit to your bottom line, is to get the CPSC to order a recall of the product.
Hmmmmmm? 
Re: Porter Cable recall Explained
Ken Eaton
According to Danielle at Porter Cable, (888-344-7973) the reason for the recall is to prevent shock in the event one cuts into the power cord with the router bit. There is no issue when being mounted in a table. There have been no injuries reported and that the recall is a precautionary measure.
Ken
Re: Porter Cable recall Explained
Joseph Mulherin, sr
Sounds like an OSHA directive
Could have been, but OSHA has its virtues
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
Having worked, in my trades days, in a couple of settings which would have caused OSHA inspectors to gasp and whip out the notebook, I don't automatically disrespect OSHA directives. There were several incidents, such as the time I was tightening rollup door springs (a hazardous enough task in good circumstances, requiring concentration and obsessive compliance with the procedural steps) while on the very top of a scaffolding, twenty feet up on a single board, with no railings whatsoever and no fall protection, that I'd have been grateful for the sudden appearance of an OSHA inspector.
Re: Could have been, but OSHA has its virtues
Joseph Mulherin, sr
We olderguys and got to this older age without too many mistakes. I worked construction for 35years, saved two guys lives on the job and never got hurt myself because of my foresightedness on how to do the work in a safe manner. Was Foreman on many construction jobs too without anyone getting hurt.
Re: Please
del schisler
seam's the post's were talking about lot's of thing's , i just thro out my opion on where the shock could come from , my thought on the handle fix could be to proct from shock ? sure wouldn't make holding to the handles any better ? so the only place shock could come from i covered what i thought. i know a lot's of IF's but some people may be as up on elec. as you and me , i guess time to put this post to bed ,
Re: Cutting the Cord
William Duffield
Thanks for doing the investigation, Ken. I didn't feel it was my place to call them, since I don't have a router base that could use replacing. Until the new bases arrive, or if you just want to minimize the chances you will cut any router cord and need to replace it, I think the procedure I use could help.
Instead of plugging the router in to a power strip that is typically attached to the front of the bench, I always plug it into an outlet behind me as I face the bench. I then hang the cord over my shoulder, so that gravity keeps all the slack behind me. The portion of the cord between me and the tool stays above or behind the cutting head. If you don't have an outlet (or even a wall) at a convenient distance behind you, an outlet dropped on a cord from the ceiling will do just as well. You can also use the same procedure with a biscuit cutter, angle grinder, multi-tool, sander, and most other hand held power tools whose business end might encounter their cord.
This is not an issue I need to worry about with my Festools. Their poser cord is tied to the dust collection hose with Velcro, and the whole assembly is hung from an overhead boom arm with short bungee cords.
Agree
Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana
I worked in several places that would have been shut down by today's Government alphabet departments. Worked around machinery and chemicals for many years. Contracted as a second job for many years. 73 years old now, never had to take anyone to the hospital (including myself) but guess today's workers can't be responsible for their own safety!