Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Kitchen sink magic,,,,,,, uh, physics.

Posts

Kitchen sink magic,,,,,,, uh, physics.

#1

Kitchen sink magic,,,,,,, uh, physics.

Keith Newton

I thought I would share this, knowing that some of you have kids or grands that you'd enjoy sharing something so simple and easy with.

Question, how can you suspend an egg off the bottom and sides, in a cup of water, without touching the egg with anything except the water.

Last night I boiled 6 eggs, and forgot to start a timer. After what seemed long enough, I scooped one up in a one cup measuring cup to sample, then held it under a cool stream from the sink faucet. I was a little surprised to find that the egg rose off the bottom, and would stay more or less centered under the stream even as I moved the cup around, even at times to rise slightly above.

It took me a moment to realize what was happening. This is and excellent example of how the pressure drops due to laminar flow of gas or liquids over a smooth curve such as airplane wings, or sails on a boat.

I wouldn't imagine that it would matter if the egg had been boiled, or was raw, but size of container does. I couldn't get it to happen in a large deeper pot. Also, my faucet doesn't have an aerator, which probably would interfere with the smooth flow. My cup measures 3.25" x 1.75", so this may be another of those times when size matters. I suspect that the turbulence under the egg, as the water hits the bottom of the cup would increase the upward pressure.

It takes a little playing with it to appreciate and or understand how it wants to stay centered under the stream. If you move to one side, the greater flow on that side, equals a greater drop in pressure on that side, so it follows the stream.

Re: Kitchen sink magic,,,,,,, uh, physics.

#2

Hmmm...

John in NM

I'm not sure you're witnessing the airfoil effect, since the lift is in the wrong direction, and there is no asymmetry with an egg so no pressure differential. But perhaps I mistake your meaning.

I betcha it's mostly turbulence, though temperature could have some effect too given that eggs' density is fairly close to water.

Re: Kitchen sink magic,,,,,,, uh, physics.

#3

Re: Kitchen sink magic,,,,,,, uh, physics.

Yonak

Have you ever been to a furniture store or other store where they are selling fans ? Sometimes they will "balance" a beach ball on the flow of air. I suspect the same principle is in play in your egg experiment.

Re: Kitchen sink magic,,,,,,, uh, physics.

#4

Re: Hmmm...

ktkjr

Not Bernoulli effect. It's Coandă effect. The same thing is demonstrated by gently touching a spoon (convex side) to a flow of water.

Re: Kitchen sink magic,,,,,,, uh, physics.

#5

Re: Kitchen sink magic,,,,,,, uh, physics.

Keith Newton

I'm pretty sure the ones I've seen were using a type of fan which would produce a vortice, somewhat like a stationary tornado, which has a calm cone shaped area in the middle.

I don't think you could get the same results by putting a squirrel cage blower in the basement, then sending air up through a duct, which would be similar to the water.

Re: Kitchen sink magic,,,,,,, uh, physics.

#6

Except it doesn't work in a bigger pan...

John in NM

If it were anything to do with fluid-surface interaction, it would work in an infinitely sized vessel. I'm telling ya, its just turbulence :D

Re: Kitchen sink magic,,,,,,, uh, physics.

#7

Now that is the Coandă effect


Re: Kitchen sink magic,,,,,,, uh, physics.

#8

Where else.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

can you get cool information like this! I bought some eggs on the way home from work. If I bust one on this experiment I may be banned from kitchen experiments.

Re: Kitchen sink magic,,,,,,, uh, physics.

#9

Re: Kitchen sink magic,,,,,,, uh, physics.

don stephan

You may be able to suspend a ping pong ball in an upward directed flow from a hair drier. Push the ball to one side a bit with a toothpick or thin wire and it will return. Put a small bit of tape on the ball to make it assymetric and watch the fun. I always called it a demonstration of Bernoulli Principle.

Re: Kitchen sink magic,,,,,,, uh, physics.

#10

Have you tried it yet?

Keith Newton

Or are you going with what you know or have read?

I have no doubt that turbulence has a lot to do with it, but I'm sure there is more to it than that. Turbulence alone wouldn't be so quick to follow the stream on top, and stay centered under it.

Re: Kitchen sink magic,,,,,,, uh, physics.

#11

Whoops!

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Pint canning jar and uncooked egg. Nothing, using aerated kitchen faucet. Unaerated laundry sink, low flow, it levitated in jar. Increased flow and it shot out the top. Now that is a trick that in spite of the water rushing into the jar there is enough lift to shoot the egg out the top. Yet another example of fluid dynamics that baffles me.

Re: Kitchen sink magic,,,,,,, uh, physics.

#12

No...

John in NM

I don't really care for boiled eggs :D

Repeating your experiment would also be somewhat pointless as I don't dispute that it happened, just your interpretation of why it happened.

You are likely correct that the Coandă effect is at least partly what kept the egg centered in the flow - but it does not lift the egg - you are relying on turbulence for that and cannot be sure to what degree it is also keeping your egg centered.

Bill's results below are interesting - an aerated faucet doesn't work, which helps your laminar flow theory - but the volume of flow has a huge effect, helping my turbulence theory (too much lift). If you could achieve the same effect in a 5 gallon bucket, I'd shut up and leave you alone :D

Re: Kitchen sink magic,,,,,,, uh, physics.

#13

more data

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

tried a 2 cup pyrex measuring pitcher. It has somewhat tapered sides. Would not levitate at any flow rate.