Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Prices of Woodworking Information?

Posts

Prices of Woodworking Information?

#1

Prices of Woodworking Information?

William Duffield

Does this disparity make sense to anyone?

http://www.shopwoodworking.com/popular-woodworking-magazine-1995-2013-dvd?source=igodigital

http://www.highlandwoodworking.com/fine-woodworking-magazine-archive-1975-2013-dvd-rom.aspx

(18 years for $97 vs. 38 years for $70)

I know I've also seen links to online archives of AW issues from when Rodale Press published it and Ellis was Editor. Free access to that material online, even without a complete index, would seem to me to further reduce the value of the DVD. Another advantage, for me anyhow, of the FWW DVD is that it would free up a lot of physical space the paper issues take up in my house.

Re: Prices of Woodworking Information?

#2

Why I keep my hard copies

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Some of the DVD pages are less than crisp if detail is essential.

Re: Prices of Woodworking Information?

#3

Re: Why I keep my hard copies

William Duffield

Since I'm considering buying the FWW DVD in particular, can anyone comment on the resolution of its images and construction drawings?

Re: Prices of Woodworking Information?

#4

DVD adequate for many purposes......

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

but not always. I use the DVD regularly but have no thought of being rid of hard copy. The big advantage of the DVD is its search engine. It is easy to find anything.

Re: Prices of Woodworking Information?

#5

Re: Prices of Woodworking Information?

William Duffield

Oops. I made a subtraction mistake. AW offers 28 years of history for the stated price, not 18. :(

Re: Prices of Woodworking Information?

#6

Comments on the FWW content

ian in Sydney

I've got a copy of an earlier edition of the DVD (through to issue 208 in 2009)

It's great for searching for articles and info.

The early issues are scanned from what look like original copies of the magazine

From about 2006/2007 it looks like the copy on the DVD is based on the digital file used to create the hard copy magazine. The line drawings just have a "crisper" look.

The few early plan drawings I've looked at in detail are usable

Re: Prices of Woodworking Information?

#7

I'd keep the hard copies ...

AZ in Colorado Springs

A DVD with more that a decades' worth of issues is probably going to be used frequently. Small scratches or whatever, and the DVD may become unusable, or maybe some of the files may become unuasable.

If "all the eggs are in one basket" or on a single DVD ... well, I'd keep my paper copies "just in case."

Re: Prices of Woodworking Information?

#8

Re: I'd keep the hard copies ...

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

I understand the potential media failure issues. I plan to copy it onto my backup hard disk, and probably put a copy on my iPad, so I can easily take it out to the shop.

I also appreciate Bill Tindall's warning about the resolution of the old issues. I'll definitely do a spot check on plans and decide whether I need to keep old issues.

I know I need to get a backup for the backup drive, and keep it in a safety deposit box, but it might be a better strategy to assume I can replace the disk from Taunton or from someone else on the internet in the off chance that I lose my copy without losing myself. I haven't searched, but there is the possibility that I could restore it from a peer-to-peer network (e.g., the Pirate Bay) if I lose it.