Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Getting snags down after a hurricane

Posts

Getting snags down after a hurricane

#1

Getting snags down after a hurricane

TomD

I have a snag from from Hurricane Arthur. It is a a large tree across my access road and it is at a steep angle such that I can drive under it, and it is supported by a large tree at the far end. I have removed many such snags before, but this one is a large tree, and certainly a potential killer if it does anything unpredictable. I think one option is to use one of those manual chainsaws that are used to beaver away at overhead limbs. With that, I could drop the the middle, even if it would bind up a bar, and of course, I could be out of the way of where the bombs are falling. Not sure I have access to one, or any likely means of getting one here. LV used to sell them. I guess I could get a length of chain and try to make a couple. Anyone ever see a FAQ on that?

I have a girlie model of f150, and my tractor isn't running at the moment. So towing the tree out is probably not possible. One option would be to buy a power winch for the truck or tractor, and use that as the muscle. I don't own a winch, so it would be a useful pick-up on a tool. Never let a crisis go to wast, to quote the Mayor of Chicago.

Any suggestions of good sites or videos, or proceedures on how to drop a thing like this.

Re: Getting snags down after a hurricane

#2

Re: Getting snags down after a hurricane

don stephan

Sounds like you can cope with it as is for now. My suggestion is to get on an arbor company's list to take it down as their schedule allows. Granted, may be 6-12 months, but you don't want to earn a Darwin award, and snags can be dangerous even for experienced arborists.

Re: Getting snags down after a hurricane

#3

Sounds like a dangerous one,

Keith Newton

I recently bought a #9000 winch from HF for about $300 for my trailer. So far, I'm pretty happy with it. They were out of snatch-blocks at the time, and I really needed one, so called around only to find one at the monster truck store for $50. Later, I found a couple at Amazon for $14 each with package damage, so I bought two more. With these, and some towing straps around trees, or shackles on the trailer, it gives lots of other options for compounding the pull, or using other trees around as a turning block pull another direction.

Otherwise, be asking around for someone with a bucket truck that can be suspended up there with it where the risk is less. But please be careful. i hate cutting leaners, especially with a rootball. It is hard to predict what will happen with those opposing forces, when released.

Even big trees which have blown all the way to the ground are challenging. The rootball usually wants to fall back into the hole. Yard, or open area trees with low branching, will have a lot of spring tension back toward the stump, which may give it thrust back that way when you cut through the trunk. I usually do a short cut straight up from the bottom to stop the thrust, then come down from the top angling about 30º back toward the stump hole/ end of the other cut. Wood or plastic wedges to keep the kerf open, until the angled cut meets the vertical stop cut. The stump sides goes up, while the other shoots back, and I bolt backwards.

This dynamic may be similar to what you could expect, except for a leaner, it may still only drop a little, then still be a leaner, that has a different challenge each time you nibble away at it.

Re: Getting snags down after a hurricane

#4

'Round Here

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

we call them widowmakers.

Wait for the road crew to clear it

Re: Getting snags down after a hurricane

#5

picture please

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

A picture would be helpful. I don't consider a tree leaning into another a dangerous tree but they sure can be bar pincers. If you only have one saw that can be a real problem. I start at the butt and make upper cuts from the bottom to top. Basically I cut up the tree in firewood length blocks starting at the butt and working up. Each block that is cut off leaves the new butt section on the ground. The challenge is to get the bar out as the cut is finished.

Usually as the tree becomes ever more vertical it will rotate and fall out of what it is hung up on. You don't want to be on that side. If it does not rotate and fall then it becomes a problem as it gets near vertical. Leave it and let the wind blow the rest down. Or get someone to pull it down.

Re: Getting snags down after a hurricane

#6

Hire a pro...hangers are dangerous!

Tom Dunlap

I'm an arborist...I do this sort of thing for a living. Hung trees are one of the most dangerous removals. They give me cotton mouth and I've been cutting/climbing for 40 years.

Take a lesson from YouTube...its cluttered with hung trees that didn't go right. And very few that [by luck alone] went right.

It might be a simple job but not likely.

If you need to hook up with a qualified arborist drop me a note, I might no someone who would but things on the ground so that you can do the safe part...clean up.

YOu might find a good training video on the 'net. but, how are you going to know if what is in the vid is the best/safest way to remove a hanger? You won't and that could lead to death or injury.

Re: Getting snags down after a hurricane

#7

Re: Looks easy!

TomD

This might work.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1KH_Ebe0cuQ

This looks safe, but I don't think I could get 8 pounds of this stuff for under 200 up here.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sbOcuqyTLNE

Re: Getting snags down after a hurricane

#8

What is the danger?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I am presuming we are talking about a tree that tipped over and before it hit the ground it encountered another tree that arrested its fall. Normally such a tree will be to one side of the tree it hit so there is only one way it can fall to the ground, namely the opposite side of the tree it is hung on. So, sawing from the protected side, the tree will either slip uneventfully down the side of the tree it is hung on, or, as the block falls off, the newly formed butt falls to the ground resuming the lean of the tree but at a greater angle, with some risk of pinching the bar if not careful.....or at least that is my experience. There are some techniques for sawing clearance that make the bar pinch less likely but I have hung a bar thoroughly when the sawed off block doesn't fall free. On rare occasions the trunk won't slip down the side of the tree it is hung on as it goes ever more vertical from sawing pieces of its end. At that point it becomes a problem. Or it it is already nearly vertical it is a problem. Either pull it or leave it for the wind to take down. If there is a danger in this operation, other than a bar pinch, I have not encountered it and would like to know for I hang my share of trees, especially bushy beech. . Logging we just hooked the skidder to the butt an pulled it down.

As warned, the root ball may tip back into the hole when cut free. That can be alarming if unexpected.

Re: Getting snags down after a hurricane

#9

Re: picture please

TomD

I don't have a picture, and it will be a few days till I get back. But I will put one up if I can. I have several saws, but only my dad's Husky up here. I will get back when I know more.

There are other trees in the area that are ready to fall on the work area, so that is a further hazard. We don't have many big trees on our lane, so this one probably took a bit of a hit from the wind. Plus the normal weather does not come from the ocean side. This isn't really a big tree, marginal size for lumber. More than big enough to squash me though.

More on the key technique:

http://www.arborcanada.com/blog/category/cutting-hazardous-trees-storm-damage/

Re: Getting snags down after a hurricane

#10

Good info source

Tom Dunlap

Tom,

You found a very good source of info if you do decide to take on this project.

The guy who runs ArborCanada is a buddy of mine and knows what he teaches. Read his info carefully and make the plan clear.

Hung and tensioned/sprung trees are very dangerous. There is extra energy stored in the trunk now. How that energy is released is key to success or death/injury. Thinking of it as a horizontal fall can lead to a disaster. Trees and limbs have been known to spring back and decapitate people.

Tom

Re: Getting snags down after a hurricane

#11

Re: Good info source

TomD

Thanks Tom, good to know.

I have no qualms about making the cuts, as a technical mater, I have made enough plunges, etc...

After that it is just a mater of towing it off from a distance...

Main questions that occur to me are:

1) what are the dangers of making a key, where the tree just freaks and blows out from the cuts themselves. I have reasonable confidence I can judge leans and such and at least not introduce angles that might cause the tree to slide off it's base. But what about the tree having structural flaws that will cause the key to be defective, or otherwise the whole thing blows out.

2) less concern is I blow the cut sequence and end up with a bound saw, but I can live with that in both senses of the word, I suppose. One has to correctly assess the tension in the spar, and I don't have a huge chance of nailing that.

Re: Getting snags down after a hurricane

#12

Re: Death and dismemberment

TomD

For me it was more a spidy sense thing. It just looks like a giant mouse trap, and logs can move in weird directions from spring forces, or from sliding from gravity.

Two recent stories from my neck of the woods.

One concerns the guy who delivers our rock. A natural comedian, and great guy to talk to. He was walking the woods during lumber season, and took a sprung limb to the leg. Dropping him to his belly, and rapidly bleeding him out. He only barely got back to his home base some 3 miles away, and will never walk the same as his leg was nearly torn off. Nothing to do with snags. I was shocked to hear that he was not hit by a trapped limb from his own action, it was just a limb somehow naturally released that shot out at him as he passed. A one in a million thing.

Just last week, before the storm, a local lady had a tree fall on her as she was sitting by the shore. She was killed outright. Her husband was mauled, don't know how badly.

This stuff happen when the woods are in as good condition as they get. Any time you go in there and poke lions with a stick, you can expect more bad stuff to happen. This is pretty scraggly land. I have driven through areas in the US where the homes are on land with tall thick and straight trees. Pretty darn big, but looks like clean felling. I wouldn't call this land natural. It has been cut before, so you get some stuff happening that is pretty weird, but it isn't like a corn field either.

Re: Getting snags down after a hurricane

#13

The often irrelevance of professional sources

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I don't spend much time trolling the internet for information so I do not know if such a source is available and authoritive. What most need is information on cutting firewood, or just being rid of trees. Techniques and situations for someone felling and bucking into marketable logs the 200' tall fir trees in the west have little to do with felling and bucking into short lengths the smaller trees in the eastern forests, wood lots and yards. The chains and saw differences make the information even less relevant. Try doing a boring cut with a semichisel safety chain in oak, for example. That is not to say that safely information in these sources can be ignored, but I find what little I have watched more entertainment than useful for cutting firewood situations.

Re: Getting snags down after a hurricane

#14

Re: The often irrelevance of professional sources

TomD

I couldn't agree with you more. I have often pointed out the irrelevance of pro sources to the work we do.

I have never had any difficulty in making plunge cuts with the saws I own, I guess they are not that safe.

Re: Getting snags down after a hurricane

#15

Re: Death and dismemberment

Barry L Elder

Presuming you have Homeowner's Insurance, I'm sure they would be pleased if you got a few quotes from tree monkeys willing to do a professional job. Qualified tree monkeys would also save almost all the wood in the tree for you to play with! Our local Botanical Gardens was nearly destroyed by Hurricanes Frances and Jeanne in 2004 and they were fortunate enough to get a grant from some government agency and hired professionals to clean up all the hangers and clean up the profile of the trees that were left. I was amazed how fast they worked. (No injuries or accidents)

Re: Getting snags down after a hurricane

#16

Re: What is the danger?

Keith Newton

Some years ago where my sister worked, the mantianance man got his cousin to help take down a leaner. After making a cut nothing happened, so he walked around behind to look from another vantage, on the way back around it released and crushed him against another tree, killing him instantly.

Re: Getting snags down after a hurricane

#17

unclear

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Selectively culling bushy beech from my forest lands results in plenty of hung trees. I have never considered dealing with a tree leaning(presuming not nearly vertical for that is a horse of another color) into another tree a particular problem. In fact I have come to believe that what the leaning tree will do is the most predictable event in logging. Predictability is the main factor is determining risk. If it is not as predictable as I think, I would like to know the details so as to avoid some unforeseen problem.

The details of this accident remain unclear. I have no idea how this person got killed. Was it something stupid like standing under it, cutting the tree being leaned into or something I might not have foreseen as a possibility?

After making a cut nothing happened...cut what,where? Cut the leaning tree at the base as I would normally do as a first step, or something creative?

, so he walked around behind..... behind what? I can't picture where one would be inclined to go walking in this situation, or why.

on the way back around it...around what

released ...the leaning tree fell to the ground?

and crushed him against another tree ...even more confused where he was at that he was between some falling tree and another tree. I can imagine a location where one would be crushed to the ground but I am baffled where(and why) one would be wandering to be crushed against another tree. If he foolishly wandered under a cut-off leaning tree then this person should not have owned a chain saw for this is just one of many ways he would eventually get hurt or killed. It doesn't demonstrate that cutting a leaning tree is particularly dangerous.

A hung tree is normally not symmetrically hung so there is no question that such a tree will stay to one side of the tree it is hung on if, or when, it falls. Staying on the protected side of the leaning trunk would seem to be safer that driving to the location and back home, or am I missing something?

Re: Getting snags down after a hurricane

#18

Re: unclear

Keith Newton

Bill, I'm sorry I don't know all the details, and didn't go to the scene of the accident myself, and my memory after over 20 years of second or third hand details are sketchy.

It was leaning against another tree, but I don't know to what degree, or any description of that tree.

He did not go under the line of fall.

I think he made the cut from standing height, rather than lower, since they weren't out to harvest a log, and the trunk may have been defective as well, like hollow or splitting. Both of these would add a degree of uncertainty.

After he had made the cut, which he expected would get it to fall, it was still hung on the other tree, at which point he started looking for other options. He had gone around the stump, I suppose to look for tangled limbs or something, then on the way back, something broke loose, and the tree came over the top of the stump and nailed him.

Beyond that, I don't know any other details, like size or species, distance it moved , or whether there may have been other factors like smaller trees being pushed down trying to Spring back up.

Re: Getting snags down after a hurricane

#19

Re: unclear

TomD

There is a difference between what happens in felling, and in my case a wind storm. In felling, ideally you have severed the tree, it has fallen over, completely free of the stump, it falls towards the ground and gets hung up. You dispose as mentioned in your earlier post, and it probably is obvious whether the top or bottom of the tree is under tension at any given cut.

When a tree blows over, etc... It usually (?) coils like a spring, or more accurately like a bow limb. A dry limb of a bow, say 3/8" x 2", can kill any animal that walks the earth including the male elephant that weighs 14000 pounds. You also need an arrow. Here we have a limb bent through a greater range, and you have a section maybe 30 or more times thicker, with stiffness increasing to the cube of the diameter. Of course the tree is wet wood, but that is not going to save your life if it unloads. To make matters interesting, you are not sure which side of the tree is under tension.

I got the tree down today. It went easily, I used the key cut, which basically makes the end of the tree into a slip joint. It was poplar, and when I released the top, the top of the joint split violently, and returned to vertical, about 60 degree change of direction. It was a still held in place, by the lower cheek, and I nibbled away at it until it finally came down.

Wasn't too thrilled with the horizontal plunge cuts. Easy to do, but they are in a position where any reaction would throw the flat out saw across an arc at the level of one's neck. I didn't see a different way to do it, but it did feel mildly like amateur hour, as though there ought to have been a better way for me to run those cuts. Also, I live between 3 houses, and never have the right stuff with me. Only protective gear I had was hearing protectors. If I had had some chaps I might have worn them like a scarf.

When a tree is in the position we are describing, someone walking behind the stump as in the "unclear" example, should the tree straighten explosively, is not with us for long. The earlier injury I described, where the guy's leg was nearly torn off, was a tree about the size of his arm. So as the size and weight increases, there are serious loads being authorized. I have to think back on today, on all the times my wife walked behind the tree, I think she was far enough back. But the dude gets caught not knowing what kind of moves the tree can make next.