Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

OT-Archiving old pix

Posts

OT-Archiving old pix

#1

OT-Archiving old pix

mdclor

Probably like many here, we have a collection of old pix-LOML's great aunt, my father @ 1 year of age, LOML's grade school graduation, uncles, aunts, etc. etc.

Mostly, they reside in albums in boxes and are never seen. We can't bring ourselves to just discard them, but don't want leave a mess for our kids to address 20+ years from now. :D

What is the best way to archive these pix? Scan each individually on my printer/scanner or look for a company that has higher resolution hardware? Is anyone aware of a file system template that is easy to use, is that even necessary? What about the issue of technological obsolescence? I don't want to store them on CDs only to have a newer technology supplant CDs which would become unreadable, think 3.5" floppies. Also, I think I have read that images stored on CDs for long periods of time degrade.

Any thoughts and suggestions will be appreciated.

Re: OT-Archiving old pix

#2

Re: OT-Archiving old pix

Bill Howatt

Good question!

I have often said that there are many times more pictures taken now that there were a 100 years ago but I wonder if we will have as high a survival rate 100 years from now. The old prints and negatives stood the test of time very well.

Any scanner you buy for your computer has more than enough resolution for your photos and 300 pixels/inch or 600 is more than enough. After all they are probably just "snapshots".

This gets us to the problem of long-term storage and its 2 major problems, the longevity of the media itself (CD deterioration for example) and the obsolescence of the hardware/software. Seen any 8" floppy drives lately?

Supposedly there are CD/DVDs available that are supposed to last for many years so that may be a solution. Unfortunately it doesn't address the obsolescence problem.

You may find that keeping them in the print format is the best. If you can write any names, dates, location, event, etc info on them it is invaluable. I have lots of family pictures without a clue of who the people in them are. If you scan them take the time to process them in a photo editing program to include the info as part of the picture. You can do this by adding a border and putting text in the bottom border. Also, you can put a lot of info in a filename.

Do you have one child/young person in the family that you know would be a good custodian of the picture files? This person would be responsible for ensuring the archive does not go obsolete and would likely have to copy them to other devices as time marches on.

I would save them in very standard formats such as JPG or TIF at present. Storing them as some photo-editor's proprietary format may have advantages while editing but it could quickly disappear from availability in the future.

Right now I have my photos on hard-drives. One in the machine and several externals. So far USB from USB1 has had a 18 year run and is still going.

I'll be interested in hearing other opinions on this topic. It also applies to personal voice recordings and videos. I was a able to read a 30 year old cassette with voice on it which I though was pretty good but cassette players are now an example of obsolete hardware (almost).

Bill

Re: OT-Archiving old pix

#3

I'm no expert, but

Keith Newton

I think I have heard that you should store them several ways. I think if I were to do this, I might just set up the camera on a tripod with a easel type stand in front of it, with good lighting out to the sides, so they don't produce any surface glare. Then, it would be as quick as pressing the shutter button, while your spouse takes them away and places the next. If there is info written on the back, just flip it and shoot that next.

With a 8 GB card, shooting at 12 mp in the camera, I think you can get over 2000 images on that little stamp size card. You can then load them into your computer, and even clean up and improve lots of damage that age usually leaves on them. While you are doing this, you should also name all the people in the shots and give any related information, like where the shot was taken, and about when.

If your kids don't know their ancestors, just having the pic doesn't mean as much as when they do, and you never know at some point in their life later on, they may want to dig into it.

After that, you can load them onto a thumb-drive, and on your backup HD.

If you have gone through all the above, go ahead and copy then onto a thumb drive for each kid, and maybe make them a special little box for it, then toss in any of the old pics that you think may be special to each.

Re: OT-Archiving old pix

#4

Re: I'm no expert, but

James Heaston

Check w/ the Historical Society & see what they do.

Could be as simple as going to a scrap booking store.

Re: OT-Archiving old pix

#5

Re: I'm no expert, but

Chuck in Mtl.

I had a similar situation with many old photos stored in a variety of albums some of which were in poor shape. To make matters worse they were stored in a plastic bin in a damp location and developed a musty kind of smell. Activated charcoal packets got rid of the odor from the photos. I then scanned all the photos to the highest quality TIFF file I could. I then placed the photos in several archive quality photo albums. CD's degrade over time but archival quality are available still i think. My scans are only stored on an external hard drive which is only run once in a while. As for technology changing we can only use what is available today, maybe tomorrow will bring a better way.

Re: OT-Archiving old pix

#6

Yes to TIFF, no to JPG

Rod Peterson—Ormond Beach, FL

Absolutely save every image as a TIFF. That's a lossless, bit-for-bit format. JPG uses a compression algorithm to save bits, but each subsequent save derogates the image just that little bit. It's not noticeable in the first or second save, but it adds up (or more correctly, subtracts down)—think 20th generation photocopy compared to the original.

TIFFs take much more space than JPGs, but with the capacity of inexpensive media today, it's relatively insignificant. When it comes to editing images (cropping, resizing, red-eye removal, etc.) always do it in a lossless format such as TIFF, and then, if you're going to email, for example, save a copy as a JPG and send it. Same if you're uploading to a photo processor (like Walgreens).

If you're really anal, like me, you'll save your originals in TIFF, and then never touch them (I use "-org" appended to the filename—myphoto-org.TIFF, for example). Make a copy of the original TIFF image (in TIFF), do your editing on it, then save with another name. If you mess it up, you can always reload another working image from the original.

Rod

Re: OT-Archiving old pix

#7

More Anal Yet

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Shoot/Save in RAW, then re-save in TIFF, then make JPEGs for printing/sharing. My TIFF files run to 150mg each, but storage is cheap.

Re: OT-Archiving old pix

#8

Re: OT-Archiving old pix

Paul Leuba

How about capturing slides digitally? I have hundreds of our young family slides that are sitting in Kodak slide trays. They would be much more accessible to our now adult children and grandchildren if I could find a reasonable way to convert them to TIF or JPG.

Paul in Hunt Valley, MD

Re: OT-Archiving old pix

#9

Re: Yes to TIFF, no to JPG

John McGaw

You may be overstating the downside of JPG files. I can pretty well guarantee that, given the test of copying a given JPG file a hundred times, the final copy will be identical to the original. Any loss that might occur would only come about if the file was opened in an editing program which re-coded it for saving. Don't edit it or edit only a throw-away copy and you can safely make as many identical generational copies as you wish.

One thing to consider when making large archives of any sort of file is error correction. Take the time to create a 25% PAR2 file set to go along with the set of images and you should be able to weather most 'bit rot' problems, should they ever occur. Personally, I can't remember the last time I had a data loss on a CD or DVD. That is probably down to using the absolute highest-quality media, verifying the burn after completion and then storing the media under dry cool conditions and protected from scratches.

Re: OT-Archiving old pix

#10

Re: OT-Archiving old pix

Bill Howatt

You can buy gizmos to convert slides. I was going to use my scanner but realized it would take a long, long time - the slide holder was at the far end and the carriage had to travel all the way down to read the slide.

I took a piece of scrap and drilled a hold near one end for the camera's tripod screw. I then got a piece of white plastic about 4-5 " high and fastened it in a semi-circle at the the other end. I made a slide-holder by cutting some grooves in some small stock with the TS blade.

Slide holder was mounted at a location where the camera on macro would have the slide almost fill the frame.

Couple of halogen worklights were then directed onto the white plastic from behind the camera. The white plastic produced uniform illumination of the slide. If you think you have light leakage into the lens, throw a piece of dark cloth over the setup.

I did a slide in a few seconds.

Before you start, go through the slides and cull them for faded, duplicates, and "why did I take that" ones.


Bill

Re: OT-Archiving old pix

#11

Re: Yes to TIFF, no to JPG

Bill Howatt

Yes, the problem is with editing and saving.

On a more practical slide I go back to my statement that they are most likely holiday snapshots, family gatherings - not professional portraits. I'll also say that for the most part you will convert them to slides, look at them when you are done and then they will be stored away just like the others with nobody looking at them for a long time, if ever again - particularly scenery shots.

Another trick professed by some for CD/DVD quality burns is to burn at half speed than the maximum. Obviously whether this works depends on how your burner and software operate. This was often recommended on a hard-drive imaging program software site where the loss of 1 bit would render the image useless. As mentioned, always verify the burn, a thumbprint can ruin a copy.

Bill

Re: OT-Archiving old pix

#12

In my haste…

Rod Peterson—Ormond Beach, FL

I hadn't written about JPG degradation in a long time and had somehow misremembered that essential element about "editing" as part of the resaving process. You're right, of course. I knew better but clearly had forgotten better.

Still, as you reinforced the notion of a "burn" copy for editing, the secondary point I in-artfully crafted remains.

Thanks.

Rod

Re: OT-Archiving old pix

#13

Re: OT-Archiving old pix

mdclor

My thanks to everyone for the tips and suggestions. I especially like taking pix of the old pix. That has got to be the fastest way to get them all digital.

Re: OT-Archiving old pix

#14

Re: OT-Archiving old slides

Keith Newton

Thanks Bill, I like the simplicity of your setup. I need to do something like this with a ton of slides. Only, i think I will make it side load, where I can push them in one side, while letting them fall out the other side.

Oh, oh, oh! and maybe I can make it so that by shooting downward, I can set a stack on the in-feed side then used a little pusher to feed off the bottom.

But first, I need to figure out a good way to clean off the dust which permeates everything due to living in my shop, and me being a dust pig.

Re: OT-Archiving old pix

#15

Re: OT-Archiving old pix

Dave Bair

My old Epson scanner will process 4 slides at a time at extremely high resolution. It takes about 90 seconds per slide and will color-correct those old Ektachromes. I imagine a newer scanner will at least equal 10-year one.

Re: OT-Archiving old pix

#16

Re: OT-Archiving old pix

Dave Bair

You may want to investigate using the "Cloud" for storage. No worries about losing data due to drive crashes, fire, etc. You can also buy a lot of flash drive memory for a reasonable price, although I don't know if they have the same aging problems as (supposedly) CDs and DVDs.

Re: OT-Archiving old pix

#17

Careful About the Cloud

Jerry Nicholson

The "cloud" is just someone's servers somewhere, probably more than one place.

These things can and do disappear regularly. Generally you get a notice to move your stuff but when its gone, its gone. I definitely would not depend on the "cloud" for long term storage.

DVDs might last a long time but I have over 50gb of JPEGS and over 250gb of videos. Right now I am depending on multiple hard drives, including one regularly cycled into my safety deposit box, but my descendants will have to figure out how to save this stuff in the long run. That is, if they care.

Jerry

Re: OT-Archiving old pix

#18

Re: Careful About the Cloud

TomD

Currently I don't use the cloud because I can't afford to upload all that stuff, internet is not reasonably cheap in Canada. But I would use it as an offsite location in the event of a fire. While I have quite a bit of redundancy in my storage. It is all within my walls, so if they go poof, that is the end of that.

Culling photos would be the first step, I have so much dross. That said, if photos are considered as information, bad photos can contain as much or more than good ones. If a future generation was interested in what their ancestors looked like, they might never get a picture of a persons bad side, or of them not smiling, etc... So while I feel I should toss the junk, it all has some purpose. Plus if we reach the Singularity, and start producing virtual family members, all the junk might come into play. :)

Re: OT-Archiving old pix

#19

Re: OT-Archiving old pix

Paul Leuba

That setup is ingenious, Bill. Thanks for posting the information and the picture.

Paul in Hunt Valley MD

Re: OT-Archiving old pix

#20

Glad to be of help


Re: OT-Archiving old pix

#21

Brilliant set-up. Thank you for posting


Re: OT-Archiving old pix

#22

getting to digital is only the first step

ian in Sydney

what I suggest is that you get them all onto your hard drive (you may need more than one HD)

THEN

make sure you create TWO full back-ups of your hard drive (using external hard drives) that you store in other people's houses.

If you live in an area subject to brush fire, earthquake, hurricanes or tornadoes make sure the back-up copies are placed in another city many miles away.

If you create a new back-up every month and rotate your backup hard drives you'll protect your computer from most catastrophes that might befall AND also keep your old photos.

Re: OT-Archiving old pix

#23

Archival media

Kurt

I'm not expert on this stuff but recently became aware of a new optical media. Writable/rewritable optical disks use a phase change dye that will degrade over time, poor stage conditions hasten degradation plus the aluminum substrate can corrode. There is a new substrate that uses a mineral rather than a phase change dye. It's write once but creates pits like a factory pressed CD/DVD rather than dye spots and may not have corrosion issues. It's claimed to "last 1000 years". Whether there'll be drives to read them in 50 years let alone 1,000 years is a question. Still seems like a possibility for longer term storage.

mdisk.com

I have no affiliation, just curious about it.