Re: glue turning black
Sgian Dubh
" ... Water good, only use steel wool to buff shellac on quarter sawn white oak prior to waxing,
Tried Elmer's last night-same thing. Idea just popped up. I haven't been working with white oak for awhile but with walnut, cherry, cedar, and maple. Perhaps there is something about the WO which doesn't let it turn black."
There's iron getting into the mix somewhere Brad. Iron, water and tannin equals black. Of the woods you named the one with the highest tannin content is white oak followed by walnut, and even cherry has some tannin it and all will react with ferrous sulphate (a well known colouring agent in wood finishing) to create something in the blue/grey area of the spectrum. Maple too reacts with ferrous sulphate to create what's called harewood or greywood. I've never applied this chemical to cedar so I don't know how it reacts.
But certainly, as Bill suggests, the contamination leading to the black is coming from somewhere. For example, I sometimes see black stains at localised spots where the steel of sash cramp bars touch the glue squeezed out at edge joints in panel glue-ups, especially when gluing up oak panels, but in other woods too. I'd start by looking at the tools you're using to work the glue into these voids. What are they made of? Slainte.