Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Water Bath for Shaker Boxes

Posts

Water Bath for Shaker Boxes

#1

Water Bath for Shaker Boxes

Bill Marr

Part of the process for making these traditional boxes is to heat the side and top bands in a water bath to make them plyable for bending. Since I'm not sure how many of them I'm going to make I didn't want to invest more than I had to to make or purchase a trough for the purpose. John Wilson sells a copper trough for about $140 and others for lesser amounts. If possible I'd like to make one. I am considering using a length of aluminium rain gutter, cut down to size, with end caps and a lid. Are there any safety considerations regarding a heating coil or flame such as a Coleman stove as it relates to the aluminium material. Thanks for your thoughts.

Bill

Re: Water Bath for Shaker Boxes

#2

Re: Water Bath for Shaker Boxes

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I know nothing about making these boxes but I have seen lots of chair part steaming apparatus consisting of a pressure cooker and a hose hooked to the vent and a piece of PVC pipe. Pieces to be steamed are placed in rack in pipe, pipe capped and cooker heated.... and various variations of this theme. The point is that it is convenient to make steam in some cooking vessel like a pressure cooker and pipe the steam to some container rather than have everything in one vessel.

Re: Water Bath for Shaker Boxes

#3

Re: Water Bath for Shaker Boxes

John McGaw

I use one of Wilson's low-end galvanized boxes and it works well enough with a cheap K-Mart hotplate as a heat source. The length is such that I can't do more than a #5 box. I guess that an aluminum (or even an aluminium) rain gutter might work if you can rig a tight cover but I'd go for the heaviest-gauge material I could find as well as using the widest size -- having the maximum area in contact with the heat is vital or the water will never get hot enough to do the job. With aluminum I'd expect that letting the thing run dry would be a recipe for disaster.

BTW, I've tried using my steaming rig for Shaker boxes and it just doesn't work as well as the 'boiling box'.

Re: Water Bath for Shaker Boxes

#4

Re: Water Bath for Shaker Boxes

Dick Coers

I made one myself. Went to a roofing company and bought an old tarnished piece of copper. I use an old griddle for the heat source. It's easier to balance the heat box on it compared to a hot plate, and lots more contact with the heat source. A Coleman stove and a thin piece of coated aluminum gutter sounds like trouble to me. Since the gutter is narrower on the bottom, it won't balance well and you may need a lot more water to cover the wood.

Re: Water Bath for Shaker Boxes

#5

Re: Water Bath for Shaker Boxes

don stephan

I used a piece of 6" alum gutter, capped at each end, with strip of 2" insulating styrofoam on top to hold in heat. 6" elec hot plate with block of wood at each end of the gutter to hold it steady on the hot plate's coil.

Re: Water Bath for Shaker Boxes

#6

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Water Bath for Shaker Boxes

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

I use a 4 foot piece of Aluminum rain gutter (from the Borg), with end caps silicone sealed.

My heat source is a two burner propane stove that's about 2 feet long. For a cover, I just use an old pine board I had laying about.

It's worked quite well for maybe 25~30 boxes so far.

Re: Water Bath for Shaker Boxes

#7

Re: Water Bath for Shaker Boxes

Bill Marr

Gents,

Thank you for your help. One of my biggest concerns was whether or not the heat source directly under the aluminium gutter would cause it to severly warp or melt. I since talked with a local chemical engineer who said that the melting point of aluminum is 1200 degrees F so I don't need to worry about that. Supporting the trough on either side will be essential to help keep it balanced. It sounds like some of you have had success with this approach. I think I'll give it a try and I'll let you know how I make out. Thanks again for your advice.

Bill

Re: Water Bath for Shaker Boxes

#8

Paint Fumes

Tony - Memphis

Beware of the fumes created when you apply direct heat to the paint on the gutter...

Re: Water Bath for Shaker Boxes

#9

Support

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

Support your length of gutter on some concrete blocks or two stacks of bricks and set your coleman stove under it so the burners are below the gutter. Light the stove and burn off the paint. Fill the gutter with water and heat it up. It should work fine as long as your end caps don't come off in the heat.

Lee

Re: Water Bath for Shaker Boxes

#10

If you are starting with green wood,

Keith Newton

Which certainly makes it easier, you maybe able to roll it up enough to put it into a big stew-pot, or fish fryer. It will be pushing itself out against the outside, but being under water, that is fine.

Besides the cooker, be on the lookout for some heavily insulated waterproof gloves, and good long-jawed tongs.

Re: Water Bath for Shaker Boxes

#11

You've used green wood before?

Dick Coers

I'd think the dry time on the drying forms would be quite a long time. Have you ever had the box bands cup when drying from green?

Re: Water Bath for Shaker Boxes

#12

Re: You've used green wood before? *LINK*

Keith Newton

Well, Dick, You've got me. I have never made a shaker box before, but my dad made some. I have done plenty of steam bending, and yes I have used tons of green wood before.

I don't think there would be much difference in the moisture content of dried vs green wood after boiling for 5 minutes, at that thickness. The point I was making, is that the green, or mostly air-dried, will be much more limber, making it easier to just roll up into a coil to drop into a big pot of boiling water. After it has been in there a while, you can feel how soft it is with the tongs, and can already have some of the coil or bend made while still under water, which might save some time going to the form.

I just happened to have some 1/8" air-dried R Oak out in the shop, which I cut on my Woodmizer a couple of weeks ago for a laminated bend project. It was still limber enough to roll up tight enough to fit into a big stew pot.

As for living on a form until dry, that isn't necessary. The lignin should take a set as soon as it has cooled. After that, it could come off and be held together with a spring clamp, or even worked to completion.

I don't think cupping should be a problem once the bend on the long axis plane is made. I've tried getting wood to bend on two axis before, and it is really hard to achieve, even with really thin material.

You may have missed the thread I started a few months ago when I bent some oak into a tight little coil spring. I did it just to challenge myself to see if I could, with no other purpose in mind.

If you don't think that looks very challenging, maybe you would like to figure out a project that pushes beyond your and your peers limits to share.


https://www.flickr.com/photos/7391658@N03/sets/72157644095226123/

Re: Water Bath for Shaker Boxes

#13

Re: You've used green wood before?

William Duffield

It seems to me that green vs. seasoned is not much of an issue with Shaker boxes, since the side walls are only 1/8" or so thick, and drying time from green is not very long.

That said, the tops and bottoms are a horse of a different feather, and must be well dried, or they will pull the brads out when they shrink.

Re: Water Bath for Shaker Boxes

#14

Re: Water Bath for Shaker Boxes

Bill Marr

Gents,

The wood I'm bending is aged 1/16 inch quarter sawn cherry. Good points about burning the paint off and side supports. I'll set it up outside the shop on the patio bricks to control the process. Thanks for the good advice.

Bill

Re: Water Bath for Shaker Boxes

#15

Re: You've used green wood before?

Dick Coers

As for living on a form until dry, that isn't necessary. The lignin should take a set as soon as it has cooled. After that, it could come off and be held together with a spring clamp, or even worked to completion.

I don't think cupping should be a problem once the bend on the long axis plane is made. I've tried getting wood to bend on two axis before, and it is really hard to achieve, even with really thin material.

With respect, you are giving a lot of technique information on work you have never done. Why would John Wilson teach drying on shaped wood if it was not necessary. He's been doing it for something like 25 years. His research into the old methods and knowledge of all things Shaker boxes is widely accepted. Surprised he would teach unnecessary techniques.

Cupping can easily happen during drying on the larger sizes, especially if the stock is not quarter sawn.


Re: Water Bath for Shaker Boxes

#16

Re: You've used green wood before?

Keith Newton

Dick, I read John Wilson's article last night, and didn't find anything too contradictory. About wood, he said "Green wood, which bends best, isn’t readily available." This might ought to have said, "may" not be available, but if it is, then why not.

Of course he has a copper vat, it is his profession. He even stated that you can use a steam chamber if you already have one.

My original post, was simply to point out that if you can start with green, or air dried, it will be pliable enough to just roll up tight enough to boil in a fish/ turkey-cooker, without rigging a vat. While, if you were starting with KD wood, it would likely be too stiff to bend tight enough to get in a cooker without soaking first. However, I just read that Bill is using 1/16", which is thin enough to get into a cooking pot, even if it was KD.

I would bet that half or more of the readers on this forum already have a fish fryer. I have used mine for this, and it works great.

As for the rest of the process, the John Wilson article is excellent. The only thing I would do differently, is to cut the middle out of those drying plugs to give more air-flow to the inside than those two finger holes permit.

Re: Water Bath for Shaker Boxes

#17

Re: Water Bath for Shaker Boxes

Bill Phoenix, MD


Gents - Embedded, hopefully, are a few pics of my first Shaker oval box.

Top- Birdseye Maple

Sides - Quartersawn Cherry

Bottom - Yellow Pine

Finish - Watco Danish Oil - Natural

Thanks for your guidance along the way.

Re: Water Bath for Shaker Boxes

#18

Just a simple suggestion

Dick Coers

On the larger boxes, it's a lot better to use quarter sawn for the tops and bottoms. Way less seasonal wood movement. Looks GREAT!

Re: Water Bath for Shaker Boxes

#19

Nice!

Tony - Memphis

Looks great. I'd like to try those...someday.

Tony

Re: Water Bath for Shaker Boxes

#20

Re: Just a simple suggestion

don stephan

Better still, plywood. Shakers were supposedly using quartersawn pine, and I found at least one picture of an allegedly authentic shaker box with part of bottom edge broken off, persumably because of bottom expansion. They were so practical, I think they would have used plywood for the top and bottom if it were available to them.